Joel Bauman equated this past college enrollment season to a duck swimming in a pond.

Above the surface, there doesn’t appear to be much going on as the duck peacefully moves across the pond.

Look underwater, though, and the duck’s feet are “paddling like crazy,” said Mr. Bauman, who serves as Duquesne University’s vice president for enrollment.

That frantic paddling happened at every college across the country this spring as schools grappled with the launch of an updated federal aid application muddied by delays, technology issues and lower submission rates.

Advertise with us

The months-long debacle prompted concerns that the rocky rollout could deplete enrollments, dissuade students from applying for aid, and dwindle the public’s already-low trust in higher education.

As a result, college officials kicked into crisis mode. They calculated and communicated federal aid estimates with students and families. They spent their weekends calling students and families to explain the situation. They pushed back their commitment deadlines to give prospective freshmen more time to make a college decision with costs in mind.

Now, as incoming freshmen begin packing their bags and moving into dorm rooms, colleges are realizing the actual effects of FAFSA delays and hiccups.

For five Pittsburgh-area schools, reality isn’t nearly as bleak as springtime projections. Each school — Duquesne, Slippery Rock University, Point Park University, Washington & Jefferson College and the Community College of Allegheny County — projects stable freshman enrollment or freshman enrollment increases.

Mr. Bauman attributes that to the months of “paddling.”

Advertise with us

“All’s well that ends well,” Mr. Bauman said, “but boy, it could have gone in a very different direction if we and other schools who understood the issues [facing] families didn't take action to support them.”

Freshman enrollment projections

Duquesne will enroll around 1,500 freshmen this fall — a stable number that is a slight dip of 1-2% compared to last year’s freshman enrollment.

New student enrollment is also stable at Slippery Rock and CCAC, which both anticipate increases of around 1%.

Meanwhile, Point Park and W&J will both see significant boosts in their new student populations compared to last year. Point Park’s new student enrollment will grow about 10%, while W&J’s will jump 35% for a total of 481 incoming students.

That will be the largest pool of new students in the Washington County college’s 243-year history.

Advertise with us

“We’re pretty excited,” said Tracey Sheetz, W&J’s vice president of enrollment. “With that being said, the FAFSA chaos did change…how we were reaching out to students and families — giving them a little bit more support, being more communicative than usual.”

Enrollment trends are complex. Both increases and decreases in student populations can be attributed to a myriad of causes.

At W&J, the historic number of new students could in part be credited to a new nursing program or the college’s efforts to admit students who haven’t applied.

Point Park, meanwhile, has bolstered its athletic offerings and offered teach-out plans to students impacted by regional college closures.

Despite Point Park’s increase in new students, Marlin Collingwood, the university’s vice president for enrollment management, said questions remain about high school seniors who didn’t enroll due to FAFSA challenges.

Advertise with us

“The question [that] colleges all over the area are going to be asking is, ‘What students aren't coming? [Those] that didn't fill out the FAFSA, that ended up not coming to school at all,’” Mr. Collingwood said. “...Who’s sitting at home this fall or who's working that would have come to college?”

And just because these five schools enjoy healthy enrollment projections doesn't mean that other schools aren’t struggling.

It was a “reactive year” full of delays and surprises that could have hindered enrollments, especially at regional public schools or less-selective institutions, said Jill Desjean, director of policy analysis with the National Association of Student Financial Aid Administrators.

“I don't think it's outside the realm of the possible that this year's FAFSA cycle has contributed to enrollment drops, at least at some institutions,” Ms. Desjean said.

FAFSA completion rates still down

FAFSA issues also prompted concerns that fewer students would actually complete the form to receive federal aid.

Advertise with us

Throughout the admissions cycle, FAFSA submissions remained lower than usual. As of Aug. 2, submissions among the high school class of 2024 were down nearly 10% in Pennsylvania and nationwide, according to the National College Attainment Network, which tracks submissions using data from Federal Student Aid.

W&J, Duquesne and Point Park all reported that their FAFSA submissions are down among incoming freshmen. Submissions are up at CCAC.

At Slippery Rock, FAFSA submissions are slightly down, by 1-2%, among new students who decided to enroll at the state university.

But among all admitted students — which includes those who will not attend Slippery Rock — submissions were down 12%, said Mike May, vice president for enrollment management. FAFSA filings often correlate to higher deposit rates.

“We were creative and did everything we could, but the delay and the problems with the FAFSA certainly impacted families who either couldn’t complete the process or got so frustrated they just gave up entirely,” Mr. May said.

Advertise with us

Pell Grant changes

The updated FAFSA aimed to ease the application process by shortening the question pool and streamlining government access to the financial information of applicants and their families.

But the form also introduced a new aid calculation formula that expanded access to Pell Grants: federal grants available to undergraduate students from low-income households.

As a result, numerous schools in the Pittsburgh region reported bumps in the number of students who would receive these need-based grants.

At CCAC, over 2,000 students are Pell Grant eligible this year. Last year, 833 qualified, said Dorothy Collins, CCAC’s vice president of enrollment services and student affairs. She called the Pell Grant changes a “benefit” for CCAC students.

Duquesne saw a roughly 40% increase in Pell eligibility among admitted students. Among new students who committed, Pell eligibility increased slightly, from 18% last year to 19% this year.

“That is the good news out of the whole FAFSA confusion,” Mr. Bauman said. “There are more students eligible for the Pell Grant in the admissions pool and the enrolling pool.”