When Carolyn G. Davis has walked into a Pittsburgh Public School building in recent years, she’s been met with a shocking reality: The structures that were already aging before her 2008 retirement from the district have remained largely the same.
Pittsburgh Public, which operates 54 school buildings across the city, has not completed a major renovation since the early- to mid-2010s. Today, the buildings are devoid of modern amenities. Students are often forced to learn from home as building temperatures in the spring and fall rise due to a lack of air conditioning. And resources vary between school building, something Ms. Davis had to grapple with as a former Pittsburgh Public administrator.
“I had to come up with resources and ways to support my staff,” Ms. Davis said. “I always said we’ve got to make the same number of bricks with less straw. What do we have to do?”
Her concerns were among dozens expressed Thursday night by more than 50 Pittsburgh Public families who squeezed into the Minadeo PreK-5 library in Squirrel Hill for the first of 10 public input sessions scheduled to take place this summer around the district’s facilities utilization plan, a controversial proposal that could lead to the closure and consolidation of some schools.
Throughout the evening, concerns largely centered around large class sizes if buildings are combined, transportation and walkability to school, potential staffing changes and feeder patterns, or the flow of elementary students to middle schools.
Solutions were not provided; rather, district officials and staff from the Massachusetts-based education consulting firm Education Resource Strategies collected the input, which they said will be used when developing the plan.
Read More
“At this point in the project it’s important that we listen to and learn from you regarding your children’s experiences,” School Director Tracey Reed said. “As we think about creating a high quality experience for all students, we want to understand what is strong and important to maintain and what needs to change in the future.”
The input session came months after district leaders first discussed closing or consolidating some schools last year as they face a growing budget deficit that is expected to reach $2 million this year but grow close to $16 million in 2025, along with declining enrollments that have led to the district educating 18,380 students when it has the capacity for 40,000.
In response to those challenges, the school board in April presented a proposed framework for the facilities utilization plan. The framework featured 12 possible recommendations including the creation of a class structure that streamlines students into PreK-5 and 6-8 rather than having some students in PreK-8 and 6-12 schools. The recommendations were based on factors such as current building utilization, facility conditions, educational adequacy, teacher shortages, transportation challenges and student support services. The district contracted with Education Resource Strategies that same month.
Since then, the consulting firm has been meeting with district principals and staff, and collected student input before school ended for the summer.
Now, officials are considering data around the number and size of school buildings, grade configuration, school locations, offered programs, transportation, attendance and feeder patterns, enrollment policies and community resources as they begin to form a plan that could shape the district’s future.
“PPS has got to do something,” Angela King Smith, an Education Resource Strategies partner, said Thursday. “It’s really not an option.”
According to Ms. Smith, the problem largely stems from declining enrollments and families moving out of the city. That’s caused Pittsburgh Public to have several schools that are considered small based on enrollments, something the district is not designed for.
“While they are small right now, oftentimes what we see is that they can be under-resourced and they can have a lot of challenges in trying to serve all the student needs in their building,” Ms. Smith said. “And so they’re trying to address and deliver at a high quality, but they’re constrained in terms of what they’re working with.”
On Thursday, families had a chance to consider challenges facing the district. Sitting around library tables, parents from neighborhoods across Pittsburgh Public’s district five brainstormed their biggest concerns as the district moves forward and what their hopes are for the future of PPS.
Christy Ruhe, who has two children in the district, stressed two main points: current feeder patterns — Ms. Ruhe, who lives in Greenfield, said kids who live on her street are split between Greenfield and Minadeo elementary schools — and walkability.
“It’s really important to me that my kid goes somewhere where they can walk to school safely,” Ms. Ruhe said.
Others, including former School Director Pam Harbin, focused on the community’s need to know if there will be any staffing changes before a plan is voted on.
And many suggested the timeline is too tight to have necessary “hard conversations” that contend with the district’s racially charged past and what that could mean for students and families today.
Under the framework approved by the board this spring, directors were expected to vote in August to open the plan up to a public hearing as laid out in state requirements. But Ms. Smith during an education committee meeting last week asked the district to consider extending that vote until September to permit officials to continue gathering input in a less formal setting and to ensure the district captures voices more difficult to find in the summer months.
It was not immediately clear if the timeline will be changed. Another round of public hearings is expected to take place later this summer.
“Right now we’re kind of exploring,” Ms. Smith said. We’re trying to hear, trying to listen and trying to go out to the communities to gather feedback.”
The next town hall is scheduled for Saturday at Sunnyside.
This story was updated June 21, 2024 to note that the consulting firm is based in Massachusetts.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.