Norwin School directors in a close vote Monday morning appointed a new superintendent.
Natalie McCracken, who currently serves as the Westmoreland County district’s assistant superintendent of K-12 education, was named to the top spot in a 5-4 vote. Directors Alex Detschelt, Christine Baverso, Shawna Ilagan and Nina Totin — many of whom questioned the district’s search process — voted against the appointment.
Ms. McCracken will start July 1. A salary was not listed for Ms. McCracken; rather the motion directed the district solicitor to negotiate a contract, with final approval by the board. She will replace Jeff Taylor, who submitted his resignation in January. Mr. Taylor, whose position at Norwin ends June 30, will serve as assistant superintendent at the Carlynton School District starting next month.
“I think she is the best candidate I saw throughout the process,” school director Raymond Kocak said during Monday’s meeting.
Ms. McCracken did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.
Several board members had questioned the district’s search for a new superintendent, which started in February when directors in a split decision hired Templeton Advantage, a Perry County consulting firm, for $17,000. The motion at the time passed in a 5-4 vote, with Mr. Detschelt, Ms. Baverso, Ms. Ilagan and Ms. Totin voting against it.
Read More
On Monday, concerns over the process continued, with Mr. Detschelt and Ms. Baverso suggesting it was rushed.
While Mr. Detschelt said Ms. McCracken “is qualified” to serve as superintendent, “I feel there were predeterminations at play, resulting in a waste of taxpayer money and time. I would prefer that Dr. McCracken serve as interim superintendent until a more thorough search process is completed.”
Ms. Baverso, who sat on the interview committee, added “I too felt the process was rushed, especially toward the end. I do feel all the candidates should have been brought to the full board. But I do trust in you Dr. McCracken. I have sat on committees with you and I know you can do the job.”
Ms. Ilagan and Ms. Totin both felt other candidates were stronger.
“My final choice was not Natalie McCracken,” Ms. Ilagan said. “Despite her very strong interview and impressive experience and commitment to our district, I just felt there was another candidate who was better suited to be our next superintendent. This candidate had no ties to the district, eliminating any concerns of nepotism, and they brought fresh perspectives and new ideas to strengthen Norwin.”
She added that the other candidate “seemed prepared to make tough decisions” such as realigning positions and reducing staff through attrition, “which will be absolutely necessary moving forward to alleviate the ongoing taxpayer burden Norwin faces.”
“If Natalie is selected by majority board decision today I hope that she will prove me wrong and do everything I saw in the other candidate,” Ms. Ilagan said.
Ms. McCracken, who earned her bachelor of science degree from Indiana University of Pennsylvania, began her education career in Louisa County and Chesterfield County, Virginia, where she taught grades five and six and served as the K-5 Title I Mathematics Specialist, according to Norwin’s website.
She returned to Pennsylvania after enrolling at California University of Pennsylvania, where she earned her master’s of education degree and principal certification. During that time she also completed an internship at Norwin’s Hillcrest Intermediate School. Afterward, Ms. McCracken was hired to teach sixth grade math and pre-algebra at Hillcrest. Two years later, she was named principal of Sunset Valley Elementary, a position she held for six years.
She then earned her superintendent letter of eligibility from California University of Pennsylvania in 2011. The next year, Ms. McCracken was named assistant superintendent of elementary education. She held that position until 2019, when she was appointed to assistant superintendent of K-12 education.
Ms. McCracken also holds a doctoral degree in school leadership from the University of Pittsburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.