Some Pittsburgh-area property owners could see higher bills next year as school districts grappling with rising costs and the end of pandemic-relief funds consider tax hikes.

Across the region, several school boards are weighing the hikes in their districts’ preliminary 2024-25 budgets. The move comes as normal fees such as cyber charter tuition, payroll and benefits continue to rise; Allegheny County districts also have increased pressure from ongoing property assessment appeals, resulting in lower tax revenue.

And those challenges are exacerbated by the end of Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief, or ESSER, funds on Sept. 30, which funneled millions of dollars to local districts to help them respond to the COVID-19 pandemic. Pennsylvania districts received $471.4 million in ESSER I, $2.2 billion in ESSER II and $4.5 billion in ARP ESSER.

“It’s putting a bigger financial pressure on district budgets than they’ve seen in any time in the last decade,” Marguerite Roza, director of the Edunomics Lab at Georgetown University, said. “With the expiration of those funds, districts, especially those that have committed to taking on more employees or paying higher salaries, are looking for potential revenues to maintain those expenses.”

Advertise with us

Locally, Fox Chapel, North Hills and Mt. Lebanon in Allegheny County are considering raising taxes, along with Burrell, Franklin Regional, Hempfield Area, and Greensburg Salem, in Westmoreland County, and Kiski Area, which splits Armstrong and Westmoreland.

“We’ve been getting by very tightly with what we’ve been doing,” Jerry Muth, director of finance and operations at North Hills, said during a board meeting this month. “It’s just fiscally responsible at this point in time to raise taxes at this level based on the revenue resources we have currently versus the anticipated expenditures.”

Efforts to right size budgets for the upcoming school year are part of a national trend that has districts closing schools, reducing staff or raising taxes to offset the end of pandemic-relief funding. Experts have been warning for years of the impending “ESSER fiscal cliff,” a mix of relief funding abruptly ending, declining district enrollments and slowing state revenues.

So far, seven of Montana’s largest districts issued levies to taxpayers to help create more flexibility in districts’ general funds, The Montana Free Press reported. Others are considering staff reductions and one is closing an elementary school. In Ohio, districts have begun laying off staff, including school nurses. And in Pennsylvania, the Erie School District could cut after-school programs and is considering enacting a 2.46% tax raise, GoErie found.

Locally, districts are facing similar challenges.

Advertise with us

At Plum, district officials could raise taxes as they face the loss of pandemic-relief money, rising costs in payroll and benefits and potential future construction fees, Business Manager Ryan Manzer said in March.

In all, Mr. Manzer is proposing a 6.2% tax increase in 2024-25, 5.5% in 2025-26, 5.6% increase in 2026-27, 5.2% in 2027-28 and 3.3% in 2028-29. It comes as the district of almost 3,600 students is seeing increases in payroll, benefits and special education costs. The district is also considering a $30 million finance plan for a construction project at O’Block Elementary School, where populations continue to grow.

And Plum currently has $1.1 million of ESSER funds in its budget, which “is going to completely drop off the table,” Mr. Manzer said. “We’re working to close out those grants right now but that is a big driver of this budget is the loss of those federal funds.

“This is not easy to do,” Mr. Manzer said of raising taxes.

At North Hills, which educates more than 4,500 students, officials are considering a 3.4% tax hike. The increase, Mr. Muth said, is directly tied to inflation that is driving up costs for things such as payroll and benefits. North Hills is also planning for the end of ESSER funding.

Advertise with us

“A tax increase to me,” Mr. Muth said, “is fiscally responsible and absolutely necessary.”

On top of those challenges, Allegheny County districts are also grappling with assessment reductions that have hit a high not seen since the 1990s, county officials previously said. The reductions are caused by a steep drop in the common level ratio, the number used in appeal hearings to calculate taxable value of a property. So far, the number has fallen from 87.5% to 54.5% this year. It could go even lower in 2025.

But districts are already feeling the impacts through tax refunds and revenue losses. And Pittsburgh Public, which along with the city has been hit hard by the reductions, last month sued the county to force a reassessment.

Pine-Richland, a district of 4,500 students, which is not considering a tax increase in the 2024-25 budget, “had a nice bucket of appeals come through,” Christopher Juzwick, the district’s director of financial and operational services, said during a May governance meeting.

In all, Pine-Richland has issued over $1.1 million in refunds this year. Because of the increase, the district in 2024-25 is budgeting $990,000 for real estate refunds rather than the normal $250,000.

Advertise with us

“We looked at it as hopefully a worse case scenario,” Mr. Juzwick said. “We do believe we accounted for that in our real estate budget this year.”

Still, districts in other counties such as Westmoreland, which are not impacted by the assessment appeals, are also considering tax hikes.

The Hempfield Area School District is contemplating a proposed budget that includes a 5.8% tax increase. The increase, which is not related to a high school renovation project that was stalled in August after bids came in higher than expected, comes after the district saw a $388,000 decrease in revenues and a $2.6 million increase in expenses, Business Manager Paul Schott said during a school board meeting this month.

In all, the district, which teaches almost 5,200 students, saw significant revenue decreases from ESSER funds — Hempfield has $2.1 million in relief funds to spend by September — and taxes. Expenditures for health insurance, salaries and retirement continued to increase.

Franklin Regional, which has 3,300 students, is also seeing increased costs. The district, facing a $643,000 deficit, is considering raising taxes by 3.2%.

Advertise with us

“The driving cost of that is personnel,” Jon Perry, the district’s financial services director, said this month of expenditures. “We’re in the service industry, almost 75% of our overall costs are driven by the cost of personnel and those increased almost $2.1 million, or 4.21% year over year.”

Other increases, Mr. Perry said, are seen in health care costs, tuition payments to the Northern Westmoreland Career and Technology Center and the Allegheny Intermediate Unit, and transportation. The district also included nearly $175,000 of ESSER funds in the upcoming budget, which will cover purchases from July through September.

Districts must submit final budgets by June 30.

For Ms. Roza of the Edunomics Lab, as districts prepare for the end of ESSER funding, they must also plan ahead for coming years.

“That can really force districts to be more proactive to look ahead to see what's coming down the pike,” Ms. Roza said. “I know right now they are approving budgets for ‘24-25 but they ought to have a sense of what it looks like for ‘25-26, as well. Multi-year budgeting has never been more important than right now.”