Gov. Josh Shapiro says his vision for Pennsylvania’s state-related universities could leave a “lasting legacy” on the commonwealth, but whether that vision will come to fruition — and whether it will actually make an impact — remains unclear.

During his budget address on Tuesday, Mr. Shapiro said he’d like to enact a performance-based funding system for the four state-related universities, the University of Pittsburgh, Penn State, Temple University and Lincoln University.

He also proposed a 5% increase in funds for these schools. He’d like that funding to be approved with a simple majority vote by legislators, rather than the two-thirds currently required — a move that aims to avoid political disagreements over funding.

“He’s setting some priorities,” said Joni Finney, an education consultant and the former director of Penn’s Institute for Research on Higher Education. “But those priorities should be sustainable over time.”

Advertise with us

Under Mr. Shapiro’s plan, state leaders would develop a “predictable, transparent, outcome-based funding system” to “incentivize outcomes that benefit all Pennsylvanians.”

Different outcomes analyzed could include schools’ first-generation enrollments, the share of graduates who stay in Pennsylvania, and the share of students who enter high-demand fields such as agriculture, education and nursing, Mr. Shapiro said.

The governor also said he wants to push for “transparency and increasing accountability” at the state-related universities, which receive millions of dollars in government funds every year, but are only required to report minimal information about their finances.

The system plan received support from Penn State President Neeli Bendapudi, who has repeatedly called on lawmakers to enact a performance-based model in the Keystone State.

“While this is just the first step in the state’s budget process, I am appreciative of Gov. Shapiro’s proposal to increase funding for the state-related universities, and for his support of performance-based funding as a means to grow the state’s investment in higher education,” Ms. Bendapudi said in a news release.

Advertise with us

States such as Ohio, Tennessee and Washington have already enacted performance-based funding systems, according to Ms. Finney. This structure has been the most successful in Tennessee, she said, though it hasn’t drastically impacted funding.

“It's had mixed results at best,” she said. “What it's really done in Tennessee is make the [university] presidents hyper-aware of their numbers — how they're doing on access [and] affordability. But it really hasn't changed the state appropriation that much except on the margin.”

Mr. Shapiro also wants to change how the Legislature approves the university funding by making the annual funding streams – Pitt gets more than $150 million a year – a part of the Department of Education budget, rather than standalone appropriations referred to as “non-preferred.”

That would mean a simple majority vote in each chamber, rather than the two-thirds majority the items currently require.

The move comes after some lawmakers voted down the state-related schools’ funding over their high price tags and lack of transparency. Additionally, Pitt has come under fire by Republicans for its fetal tissue research.

Advertise with us

Sen. Kim Ward, R-Westmoreland and Senate president pro tempore, told the Post-Gazette her office was reviewing whether such a change was constitutional. She said that like most of the proposals put forth by Mr. Shapiro, the specific details and language will need to be seen before a final judgment can be made.

Meanwhile, Sen. Jay Costa, D-Allegheny and the top Democrat in the Senate, when asked whether Senate Republicans would contest such a change, said he anticipated that they might. “But we haven’t gotten there,” he said.

In response to the funding plan as a whole, Pitt released a brief statement that didn’t touch on specifics.

“We're grateful for Governor Josh Shapiro’s continued support of the University of Pittsburgh and Pennsylvania’s students and families,” university spokesman Jared Stonesifer said in the statement. “Pitt looks forward to working with the Shapiro Administration and the legislature to enact a higher education plan that delivers for students and puts Pennsylvania on a path to a more competitive workforce and a more robust economy.”

Broadly looking at Mr. Shapiro’s higher education plan — which includes a proposal to merge the state system universities and community colleges — Ms. Finney believes it’s a “modest proposal” at its core when “you peel the rhetoric away.”

Advertise with us

She is concerned that the plan doesn’t factor in the economic and population challenges that impact Pennsylvania’s colleges and universities.

Ms. Finney would like Pennsylvania to form a board that can independently analyze higher education in the state and work with governors and legislatures to enact policies. States like Texas, Virginia and Tennessee already benefit from coordination models like this, she said.

“It's sort of like driving with a hand over one eye,” Ms. Finney said. “You have to be able to see the entire state and the educational programs and where you have problems.

“What you get is a governor introducing a big agenda on higher ed, which will go away after he goes away and after a new legislature goes away. There's no sustained policy leadership for higher ed [in Pennsylvania].”