The Pittsburgh Public School Board will continue to operate without student representatives after directors this week tabled a motion that would have given teens a seat on the board.

School directors on Wednesday tabled the motion in a 7-2 vote. Directors Sala Udin and Gene Walker voted against tabling it.

“Tabling this motion does not say we don’t want to have student voice,” school director Sylvia Wilson said. “I actually think that we have some very good, strong student voice advocates right now in our high schools, those who meet with the superintendent as well, which certainly wasn’t in existence many years ago. … I think the fact that we have some unrest on the board right now about the resolution would be the proper way to table, and table does not mean kill.”

Under the resolution, first presented during last week’s board workshop, one 11th grader and one 12th grader would have been selected to sit on the board by a committee of high school principals. The committee would review applications including two letters of recommendation and student transcripts. The superintendent would have made the final recommendation. 

Advertise with us

Students picked for the role would then have been tasked with attending public agenda review and legislative voting meetings as non-voting members, and they would have prepared a monthly report. They would have also been assigned a board member who would act as a mentor throughout the student’s two year terms. 

The goal was to provide a link between students and the board.

The idea mirrors similar initiatives across the country. According to a 2009 survey from the National School Boards Association, of 39 responding state associations, 25 said they had students serving on local school boards. And during a 2020 survey of 49 state associations, 31, including Pennsylvania, said that having student board members was a local option. In the Pittsburgh area, several school boards have student representatives. 

But at Pittsburgh Public, concerns over the proposal quickly arose among board members. 

“I think that there’s some work that we have to do to be able to set ourselves up for success to then also welcome in the voices of students for them to be able to be successful on this board,” director Devon Taliaferro said during the workshop meeting. “I am kind of hesitant to see an effort like this done in this moment. I think if we can get ourselves as a board in a position where we are truly focused on board governance and putting students first in the way that we govern as a board it makes it more of a stronger opportunity to bring in student board representatives.”

Advertise with us

School director Jamie Piotrowski on Wednesday added that there are several unanswered questions over how the program would work. 

She suggested that having only two students is not representative of the student body. Ms. Piotrowski also questioned what would be included in the student report, which could focus on “a lot of heavy stuff” talked about during board meetings. 

“I’d be concerned about what this report is meant for,”  Ms. Piotrowski said, “who the audience is and what the purpose of it is.”

Ms. Piotrowski said that the motion should be tabled and then reintroduced at the policy committee, which could direct the administration to create a program rather than “just housing this as a resolution that then becomes very difficult to find in BoardDocs and then as the board changes this program could essentially disappear.”

But school director Sala Udin took a different stance. 

Advertise with us

“Student voice is a very important element of our education system,” Mr. Udin said. “We should be trying to amplify student voice, not muzzle it.”

He said that tabling the motion would “be sending a very negative message to the students.” Mr. Udin countered statements made by other board members, saying that “we don’t need to wait until the board gets its act together. … We need to send a message, strong message, right away, that we welcome student voice on this board.” 

Ms. Taliaferro added that she does the believe the board should revisit the idea of student representatives at a later date. 

“I’m not saying that we table this forever, I’m even happy to bring it back in six months from now after we actually do our own work and get our own selves in a way that we all are very clear how to govern as a school board,” Ms. Taliaferro said. “I don’t think that we are successful at that right now and I don’t know how adding a student board representative at this time will help us get there.”