HARRISBURG — A study commissioned by the state House recommends that the state shift away from mandates dictating how many hours professional educators must devote to training and establish mechanisms to determine if the existing training is doing any good.

The Joint State Government Commission report suggests that the state cease to mandate how much “seat time” that educators must devote to training and instead establish a system where educators could satisfy training requirements by demonstrating that they understand the content. The report also calls for giving school districts greater flexibility in determining which staff need training in specific areas and “limit the audience for trainings on such topics as substance abuse, dating violence, pregnancy, and sexually transmitted diseases to certain qualified personnel who would most often come across risk-taking behavior in their role and responsibilities.”

The report also suggests that proposed educator training mandates be scrutinized by the Independent Fiscal Office, which would produce reports on the financial impacts of those mandates, and it calls for the creation of a Pennsylvania School Employees Professional Development Council to make recommendations about needed training and whether existing training mandates should be changed.

The study was triggered by House Resolution 163, which was approved by the state House unanimously in February 2022.

Advertise with us

“Pennsylvania public schools are required to routinely carry-out certain training requirements for public educators. Some of the training requirements school entities must comply with are redundant, overly burdensome, and/or no longer necessary,” said state Rep. Ryan Mackenzie, R-Lehigh, the prime sponsor of HR 163, in a cosponsor memo.

The language of the resolution, itself, declared: “Relief from burdensome training mandate requirements can save school districts and taxpayers money and result in more efficient operations.”

It pointed to reporting questioning the effectiveness of mandated training given to teachers who are told to report suspected child abuse.

Legislation passed in the wake of the Jerry Sandusky sex abuse scandal at Penn State (Act 126 of 2012) “amended the Public School Code of 1949 to mandate training for all school employees who have direct contact with children, contains very specific and detailed training requirements. These include the mandate that all school entities and independent contractors of school entities provide their employees who have direct contact with children with a minimum of three hours of training every five years on child abuse and sexual misconduct recognition and reporting."

But state data has shown that child abuse tips from teachers are rarely substantiated, the report noted. School employees made over 8,300 reports of suspected child abuse in 2021 but only 5.4% of those tips were substantiated. That’s more reports than any other group but the lowest rate of substantiation. For comparison, child care workers reported just 1,008 suspected child abuse cases and almost 9% of those tips were substantiated.

Advertise with us

“A miniscule percentage of substantiated reports is striking and certainly deserves further attention. To what degree it is due to the exaggerated or unclear requirements in the statute itself and to what degree it is due to imperfect training is a question that needs to be investigated,” the report states.

Mr. Mackenzie said that the resolution was backed by advocacy groups including the Coalition of Public Charter Schools, the Pennsylvania Association of Intermediate Units, the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators, the Pennsylvania Principals Association, and the Pennsylvania School Board Association.

The report grew out of the work of an advisory committee authorized by HR 163. That committee included members of those school groups that had called for the review in the first place, as well as a teacher, an education support professional, a parent and the Pennsylvania State Education Association.

That committee met six times, most recently in May.