Maanasa Reddy spent hours this school year poring over class assignments in her Upper St. Clair home, sometimes staying up until 2 or 3 in the morning.

Just a few hours later, her alarm would start ringing, forcing the high school senior to drag herself out of bed so that she wasn’t late for school.

“I have to get up by 6:45 and that would be really tough,” she said. “I know that’s not even just me, there’s a lot of people that don’t get enough sleep.”

As students struggle to balance early start times with after school activities and jobs, districts across the state are slowly shifting their school days to begin later. That includes Upper St. Clair, where students could see school open 30 minutes later if the board approves a motion next week.

Advertise with us

The idea of later start times has been a national debate for years as advocates push for the change they say will improve student outcomes. And the thought has recently seen a resurgence as districts shift their focus to student mental health following the pandemic.

“Making the change is imperative but it’s like trying to turn a cruise ship around in the ocean,” said Gail Karafin, state leader of the Pennsylvania Start School Later chapter, a coalition dedicated to raising awareness about the relationship between sleep and school hours. “It’ll take awhile because there are so many moving parts to the puzzle [but] if we want students to do better I think one of the things that will help … is to make schools start later.”

In Pennsylvania 33 out of 500 school districts have changed their hours, according to Start School Later. That includes several Allegheny County districts such as Avonworth, Hampton Township, Pine-Richland, Quaker Valley and Woodland Hills.

Across the country, states are also looking into the concept. California last year became the first state to require public schools to open later, meaning high schools now start at 8:30 a.m. while middle schools begin at 8 a.m. Florida is currently considering a similar measure. A bill recently passed the state Senate, which would mandate schools to follow the same schedule as California.

But as schools consider making the change, many face challenges such as ensuring the timing of sporting events and after school activities line up with those from competing districts. School officials also have to adjust transportation schedules, which typically follow a tiered system, allowing districts to rely on fewer buses and drivers. Tighter schedules may require districts to depend on more resources at higher costs.

Advertise with us

Still, Orfeu Buxton, director of the Sleep, Health & Society Collaboratory at Penn State, said later start times helps students return to the true purpose of school: to learn.

“If you can barely keep your eyes open you’re not going to learn anything, you’re not in a good mood, you’re not in a state that’s joyful or prepared to take on new challenges much less perform well,” Mr. Buxton said.

According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, teenagers who do not get enough sleep are more likely to be overweight, not engage in daily physical activity, suffer from depression, engage in unhealthy behaviors such as drinking, smoking tobacco and using drugs, and perform poorly in school.

The organization last year recommended that middle and high schools start at 8:30 a.m. or later so students get the necessary amount of sleep.

Peter Franzen, an associate professor of psychiatry and clinical and translational science at the University of Pittsburgh’s School of Medicine, said the change is because of biological markers happening during development “that make it more difficult for teens to fall asleep early.” During puberty, circadian rhythm – the physical, mental and behavioral changes that follow a 24-hour cycle – is altered, typically delaying sleeping and waking times.

Advertise with us

“So right at the same time their biology is pushing schedules to be later, school is starting earlier and then you end up with the school sleep squeeze,” Mr. Franzen said.

He noted that schools with later start times see several benefits such as less absenteeism, more alertness in the classroom, higher grades and SAT scores, lower rates of depression and fewer car accidents.

Those are all benefits reported at Hampton Township School District since the high school’s start time was moved from 7:30 a.m. to 8:20 a.m. last school year, said Superintendent Michael Loughead.

“Based on our experience and the information from other high schools around the country, we would strongly recommend that later start times be considered for high schools in Western Pennsylvania,” Mr. Loughead said in an email. “We know that mental health is a significant concern for adolescents, and later school start times is another opportunity to provide support for students.”

Upper St. Clair

Advertise with us

The Upper St. Clair School District has been considering later start times since the early 1990s.

But a strategic plan first commissioned in 2015 that focused on the high school experience and touched on later start times spurred the most recent conversations. Despite being sidetracked because of the pandemic, district officials have been working to make the idea come to fruition.

As things currently stand, high school classes start at 7:30 a.m., with bus pickups beginning as early as 6:55 a.m., Superintendent John Rozzo said during a board meeting last month.

Under the proposed plan, start times would be pushed forward by a half hour. That means the high school would start at 8 a.m. and end at 2:45 p.m. Elementary students would begin at 8:35 a.m. and end at 3:05 p.m., and middle schoolers would start at 8:55 a.m., finishing at 3:40 p.m.

“What we’re hoping to see … is an improvement in their academic performance, an improvement in their alertness, but I think just in their overall health,” Mr. Rozzo told the Post-Gazette. “The research really supports the later start times yield those outcomes.”

Advertise with us

In addition to improving behaviors, health and academic outcomes for students, Mr. Rozzo said changing the start times will also eliminate kids waiting for the bus in the dark.

“Think about the winter,” he said. “It’s cold, it’s icy a lot of times and they’re in the dark at 6:55 getting picked up. There’s a huge safety concern with that.”

The district is currently working through the logistics of athletics and after school activities, and transportation.

“The biggest challenge as you can imagine, and again it’s not just here, it’s the logistics and it’s the net impacts on members of a school community,” Mr. Rozzo said. “Any change is a change and it doesn’t always affect everyone the same way as we well know.”

School directors are expected to vote on the possible change during Wednesday’s board meeting.

Advertise with us

While students wait for a final decision, many are eager for the chance to sleep in.

Sophomore Michael Barrie said he’s “pretty excited” about the change. Michael said he often feels drowsy in the morning before his afternoon classes and tennis practice.

His mom, Amy Barrie, said she doesn’t have any concerns about the change.

She said that later start times might make it easier for some families when dropping off and picking up their kids from sports. Ms. Barrie noted that she hopes the district will become a model for others in the region considering a similar change.

“There’s movement,” Ms. Karafin, of Start School Later Pennsylvania, said, “and it’s going slowly but I’m fully convinced that eventually the right thing will happen and these kids will get some rest.”

Megan Tomasic: mtomasic@post-gazette.com