Safety on the University of Pittsburgh’s campus again garnered attention Tuesday night as protests over two conservative speakers saw the explosion of an incendiary device, a declared “public safety emergency” and human barricades of police officers.

About 175 people protested the debate — “Should transgenderism be regulated by law?” — between Daily Wire commentator Michael Knowles and libertarian journalist Brad Polumbo. 

Many protesters limited their opposition to chants and signs, but some ignited flares and started fires on the street outside the O’Hara Student Center, where the debate was held. The loud incendiary device, which some protesters threw at officers, prompted Pitt to send the emergency alert to students. The university also closed numerous campus buildings, including residence halls, throughout much of the evening. 

The protest came just eight days after unfounded calls of a shooting in the Pitt’s Hillman Library elicited campus-wide panic. Pitt received heavy criticism for its communication during the hoax, as the university’s emergency alert was sent over 1.5 hours after the calls started. Many students wished the university told them to avoid the area around the library, enacted a complete or partial lockdown of campus, or provided a faster update when the library was clear.

Advertise with us

On Tuesday, Pitt seemed to demonstrate it heard those student concerns. The university sent an alert about the incendiary device, which sounded like a bomb, moments after it went off at about 7:30 p.m. Pitt then announced building closures as it continued to advise students to avoid the area.

“We heard clearly that our community wants faster, more frequent information, even if we don’t have a complete picture to share,” Ted Fritz, Pitt’s vice chancellor for public safety and emergency management, said in a statement. “[Tuesday] night, we were able to alert the community to a situation while we were still assessing it, and then provide ongoing details, action items and updates on emergency.pitt.edu and social media. We saw traffic on these sites in the tens and hundreds of thousands, which is great.”

Pitt Police and City of Pittsburgh Police had a plan in place before the protest began and kept everyone “as safe as possible,” Mr. Fritz said. The university will conduct a review to identify areas for future improvement. 

Still, some have criticized the university’s handling of the debate and protest. Three officers were evaluated by medics during the protest. No arrests have been made and an investigation is ongoing. 

After the debate ended at about 9 p.m., roughly 250 attendees had to wait 30 minutes to safely exit the building as the officers formed a human barricade around the student center while protests continued. 

Advertise with us

John Burtka – the president and CEO of the Intercollegiate Studies Institute, the conservative nonprofit that sponsored the debate — called the scene “hostile and dangerous.” Mr. Burtka said ISI agreed to pay the university nearly $17,000 for the overtime staffing of 28 police officers and 11 university supervisors at the event. Mr. Burtka believes Pitt “grossly underestimated” the number of officers needed to maintain safety at the event.  

“The violent reaction by the students goes to show there are some topics at universities that college students and even administration don’t think we should be allowed to discuss anymore,” Mr. Burtka said.

Protests and violence in response to college campuses speakers are becoming more common on college campuses. In the past year, schools such as Penn State, Stanford University and the University of California, Davis have dealt with hecklers or violence over controversial campus speakers. As a public institution, Pitt has the responsibility to uphold speakers’ First Amendment rights while maintaining campus safety. 

Both speakers and protesters have First Amendment protections, said Zachary Greenberg, the senior program officer with the Philadelphia-based Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression. But while protesters can chant, hold signs and engage in dialogue, they legally can’t use violence or disruption to silence speech, a phenomenon known as the “heckler’s veto.” 

“We’re glad to see Pitt take seriously its obligation to ensure student safety and ensure the event goes forth to protect the rights of the speaker, the group and the audience,” Mr. Greenberg said. “We want universities to use their resources to ensure student safety and free speech. It is a sad state of affairs that these events face violence and destruction. [Protesters] should use their own words, they should not be disrupting the speech of others.”

Advertise with us

College administrators are often tasked with balancing those First Amendment rights with their stated commitments to diversity, equity and inclusion, said Joe Lizza, the campus safety and violence prevention chair for the National Association of Student Personnel Administrators. 

Mr. Lizza believes schools should create teams of campus and local stakeholders to respond to potentially controversial events. These teams could help de-escalate tense situations, help first responders maintain safety and serve as a “support system” for students who are uncomfortable with campus speakers, he said.

“A goal for administrators and student leaders is to strive for a campus where free speech is protected and civility is strongly affirmed, where the identities of each person are honored, and where diversity is actively promoted,” Mr. Lizza said in an  email. “It is, however, not the role of an institution to attempt to shield individuals from ideas and opinions they find unwelcome, disagreeable or even deeply offensive.”