Sewickley Academy has selected the interim chief who oversaw the ousting of several top administrators — leading to questions surrounding the institution’s commitment to diversity initiatives and a federal discrimination lawsuit — as its permanent school head.

The academy’s board of trustees named Ashley Birtwell as head of school effective Tuesday. She had served in an interim capacity since June when the school fired its former head, Kolia O’Connor.

The board said in a news release that it chose Ms. Birtwell because of her focus on positioning the academy as a world-class institution that prioritizes academic excellence by offering a well-rounded curriculum with robust arts and athletic opportunities.

“Dr. Birtwell’s impressive track record in the seven months she has been the interim head of school has exceeded the trustees’ most optimistic expectations,” said board chair Kate Pigman. “Students, parents, faculty and administration appreciate her steady guidance and clear vision — especially during the challenging circumstances surrounding COVID and the change in leadership.”

Advertise with us

When the board named Ms. Birtwell as interim head in June, it said it would initiate a national search for a new permanent leader with the goal of selecting a candidate “who shared Sewickley Academy’s community values, embraces its mission and can ultimately resolve the challenges the school now faces.”

Mrs. Pigman told school faculty Tuesday that the board began a national search, but it did not have to look far as Ms. Birtwell “has shown through her leadership to be the ideal candidate over the last several months.”

Ms. Birtwell is the first woman to hold the position of head of school at Sewickley Academy. She attended the academy from seventh through 10th grade and earned a Ph.D. in organizational behavior at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. She received a master’s degree in public policy and management at Carnegie Mellon University and an economics degree from Middlebury College.

The board touted Ms. Birtwell’s accomplishments during her time as interim head, including the development of a computer science program for Pre-K-12 set to launch in the 2022-23 school year, designing a global scholars program and creating the first art history program on campus.

“To return to the campus I love and make a meaningful difference in the lives of students, families, faculty and this community makes me truly grateful,” Ms. Birtwell said in the news release. “Our school has such a rich history to build upon. I am excited to collaborate with my colleagues to enhance our solid set of core values and to continue developing pathways for children to build extraordinary lives. What we offer in academics, athletics and the arts is already wonderful — which is why we are so thrilled to strengthen our curriculum and make it more accessible to students and families.”

Advertise with us

Less than a month after Ms. Birtwell was placed in the interim position, the academy fired five administrators and a teacher, including the school’s nationally respected director of diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice.

At the time, Ms. Birtwell said the personnel “decisions were made to ensure that we are meeting our standards of academic excellence.” She also cited issues with declining enrollment.

But the firing of Mr. O’Connor came about a month after an unaffiliated and anonymous group of academy parents sent a letter to school families and leaders expressing concerns about what it called political and ideological persuasion in the institution’s curriculum.

The group, which called itself the Sewickley Parents Organization, said on its website that it wanted to ensure the academy continues providing “an educational environment free of political bias and social indoctrination.” The group also placed advertisements in the Sewickley Herald that asked school stakeholders whether they want to “get politics and activism out of the classroom.”

The situation at Sewickley Academy unfolded amid bitter debates over equity and social justice initiatives at schools across the country, including the teaching of critical race theory. The letter sent to the academy community by the parents group mentioned that the school’s curriculum displayed elements of critical race theory.

Advertise with us

Critical race theory, an academic framework that examines systemic racism in America, has been discussed in graduate schools for decades but is not introduced at the K-12 level. The term rose to the national consciousness in 2020, however, when former President Donald Trump derided it as progressive propaganda.

Under Mr. O'Connor, the academy was well-regarded for its work in the area of DEISJ and had adopted some of the initiatives into its strategic plan, EnVision 2024.

LaVern Burton, the academy’s DEISJ director, was among the five administrators fired less than a month after Mr. O’Connor. She was replaced by Derek Chimner, a PE/health teacher and multi-sport coach at the academy with no noted experience with DEISJ initiatives.

Several of the other administrators and the teacher who were fired also were involved in the school’s diversity initiatives.

One of those administrators, Douglas Leek, was in his first year as the academy’s director of admissions and financial aid. He filed a federal lawsuit against the school alleging racial discrimination and settled for an undisclosed amount in October. Mr. Leek is Black and was replaced by a white woman.

Advertise with us

Since the firings, two Black academy trustees, Douglas Allen and Aaron Washington, left the board. And two teachers who had been involved with DEISJ initiatives, Monica Lynn and Sarah Pease-Kerr, left the school. The reasons why the trustees and teachers left were unclear, and they could not be reached for comment.

The Pennsylvania Association of Independent Schools has opened multiple investigations into the school because of complaints from parents and faculty members over the firings and environment at the school.

Students at the academy also have protested against recent decisions by the school’s administration.

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.