A day after Sewickley Academy fired five administrators and a teacher, the interim head of school said the “decisions were made to ensure that we are meeting our standards of academic excellence.”
The moves came less than two months after an unaffiliated parents group sent a letter to the entire Sewickley Academy community decrying political and ideological persuasion in the school’s curriculum and followed the replacement of the academy’s longtime head of school.
The departures announced Wednesday were the academy’s director of diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice; head of the senior school; head of the lower school; director of admissions and financial aid; director of teaching and learning; and a fifth grade teacher.
Ashley Birtwell, the academy’s interim head of school, said in an email that she could not legally provide information on the reason behind the personnel decisions other than to say they were made to “meet the school's standards of academic excellence.” She did not give an answer when asked if the employees who were let go were not meeting the school’s standards.
The situation at Sewickley Academy has unfolded as bitter debates over equity and social justice initiatives have broken out at schools across the country, including the teaching of critical race theory. The letter sent to the academy community by the unaffiliated parents group — called the Sewickley Parents Organization — mentioned that the school’s curriculum displayed elements of critical race theory and said it wants to ensure the academy continues providing “an educational environment free of political bias and social indoctrination.”
Critical race theory, an academic framework that examines systemic racism in America, has been discussed in graduate schools for decades, but the term rose to the national consciousness last year when former President Donald Trump derided it as progressive propaganda. Critical race theory is not usually introduced at the K-12 level.
Read More
Under the former head of school, Kolia O’Connor, the academy had adopted diversity, equity, inclusion and social justice initiatives as part of its strategic plan EnVision 2024. Even with the plan, the school claimed critical race theory was not a part of its curriculum.
The Sewickley Parents Organization sent its letter to the school community June 1, and the academy’s board of trustees reached out to the group shortly thereafter to learn more about what it wanted.
The board announced Mr. O’Connor’s departure on July 1, saying it was a “mutual decision” between Mr. O’Connor and the board “as they determined that a change in leadership was in the best interest of the school.” Ms. Birtwell, who had been a member of the board, was put in place as the interim head of school immediately after Mr. O’Connor was removed.
Ms. Birtwell confirmed that the board met with the parents organization, but she said it was after Mr. O’Connor had already left. She declined to provide any insight into what was said at the meeting, what the group wanted or who actually met with board members.
“The details of that meeting are private,” she said. “We are unable to share the conversation without the consent of our families.”
Rob Frazzini, an academy parent and spokesman for the Sewickley Parents Organization, said the group did not push for the removal of any school staff members. He said the board — not the parents group — has been responsible for the personnel decisions.
“The mission of Sewickley Parents is straightforward,” Mr. Frazzini said in a statement. “We seek to ensure Sewickley Academy delivers academic excellence, offers a diverse and inclusive environment, attracts, retains and celebrates the best faculty in the country, provides a curriculum and culture free of ideological agenda and makes certain that parents have a powerful voice in the direction of the school.”
Mr. Frazzini said the organization has more than 170 members that come from diverse backgrounds, but he declined to name any other parents who were part of the group.
When Mr. O’Connor left the academy, the school announced it would initiate a nationwide search for a replacement.
But a message the academy sent to families Monday said “as we move towards the start of the school year, we are going to focus our energy and resources in the near term on fully supporting Dr. Birtwell so that she can focus on the academic year and beyond to make the educational experience the best that it can be for our students. We will continue to evaluate the needs of the SA community through frequent discussion and interaction and develop a consensus profile of an ideal candidate who is aligned with our mission and core values.”
In another personnel move, the academy announced Thursday that it had appointed Ken Goleski as assistant head of school. He had previously served as the academy’s acting head of the senior school, dean of the senior school, and a Spanish language and culture teacher.
“I believe that at its core, Sewickley Academy remains a community of learners that appreciates the learning process and bravely looks for innovative and diverse answers to the difficult questions we examine in the classroom,” Mr. Goleski said in a letter to the community. “I am eager to begin collaborating with Dr. Birtwell as she leads the Sewickley Academy community through this transition and toward a bright future.”
Ms. Birtwell said her goals were consistent with the EnVision 2024 strategic plan, including delivering a high-quality, college-preparatory education and continuing to understand, evaluate and address the strengths and opportunities presented by school staff.
She said she was also focused on “refining” the academy’s diversity, equity and inclusion plan.
“We are working with our educators, the board of trustees, and the home and school association to assess and optimize the plan to ensure we are maximizing the potential of our students in alignment with our overall mission and core values,” she said. “SA has always focused on building a safe, diverse, inclusive environment for our students. This will remain core to who we are.”
Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1352.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.