Communities in Western Pennsylvania and throughout the Rust Belt have experienced a decline in population since the collapse of the steel industry decades ago.

A lack of job opportunities, an aging population and other issues present difficulties in reversing that trend.

But recent developments in Beaver County have given officials some hope that population growth and economic revival are possible there.

The Shell petrochemical plant, expected to open in 2022, is slated to create 600 permanent jobs in Potter Township along the Ohio River.

Advertise with us

Officials, however, said they know it will take more than that to make the county attractive to newcomers. A key component is offering quality education while remaining fiscally responsible.

Even though the school districts in Beaver County have worked hard to do just that, officials said, they believe a negative perception of the schools has been a barrier to growth. To that end, the Beaver County Partnership for Community and Economic Growth’s Quality Education Council commissioned a study to examine the future of education there.

Goals of the four-phase study – led by researchers from Johns Hopkins University and scheduled for completion in the fall – include a comprehensive look at education in the county, an exploration of how it can improve, and plans for where it could be by 2030.

The study, thought to be the first of its kind, could lead to significant changes.

“We know we need to get at improving the quality and equity of education for students in Beaver County while we control or perhaps reduce costs. We know that those are things that we have to do,” said Charles “Skip” Homan, chairman of the Beaver County Partnership. “And we know they will probably suggest some sort of consolidation – whether it’s more sharing of services, whether it’s creating some centers of excellence or magnet-type schools — all those possibilities will be on the table.”

Advertise with us

Looking for options

Beaver County has lost about 40,000 residents since 1970, going from a high of more than 200,000 then to about 165,000 in 2020. At the same time, the county’s school-age population dipped from more than 50,000 in 1970 to under 25,000 in 2020.

But it only has one fewer school district than it did in 1970, the result of the merger of Center Area and Monaca in 2009.

Daniel Matsook, who at the time was superintendent of the Center Area School District, said consolidation talks began as his district considered building another elementary school.

Because of population declines and rising costs, Center Area and Monaca decided to see whether a combination of resources could provide better opportunities for children in a cost efficient manner. After several years of study and political maneuvering, they merged to form the Central Valley School District.

Advertise with us

But mergers are not the point of the ongoing study, Mr. Matsook said. Rather, it’s about how districts can cooperate to benefit all students without new burdens on taxpayers.

“The bottom line is, some of those factors that went into the first phase of the feasibility study for the partnership resulted from some of the same factors [as the Center-Monaca merger] – and that is population trends,” Mr. Matsook said. “Where are the trends going in Beaver County, and what does that mean for our schools and our services and the facilities that they have?”

The districts already share a variety of services, courses and staff.

Robert Postupac is superintendent of the Western Beaver and Blackhawk school districts, making him the only person in the state who leads two school systems.

The dual role started after Blackhawk had to reduce early childhood instruction in 2015 and parents asked Western Beaver whether they could place their children in its PreK Counts program.

Advertise with us

Later that school year, the Blackhawk superintendent resigned and its board asked Mr. Postupac to fill in on an interim basis. The districts eventually reached a cooperation agreement, and he took the Blackhawk superintendency while staying with Western Beaver.

Mr. Postupac’s salary is about $60,000 less at each district from what he would receive as a full-time superintendent at either. Other parts of his contract also are split between the districts.

“Ultimately, it’s a pretty big cost savings for both schools to have just one administrative leader,” he said.

How the latest study came together

The Beaver County Partnership for Community and Economic Growth formed in 2016, bringing together stakeholders in an effort to reverse population losses.

Advertise with us

The Quality Education Council — made up of about 60 school leaders — emerged from the partnership to learn more about the fiscal impact of population and student enrollment trends. In 2018, it proposed a feasibility study and received a grant for it from the Pennsylvania Department of Education.

The first two phases of the study – mostly data collection and analysis – were completed in 2019.

Among the most alarming of the findings, county officials said, was that about 44% of the county’s workforce commuted from outside its borders.

“The implication is that young families that are coming to the region are electing to live outside Beaver County, and we suspect that one of the reasons is at least the perception of our school districts,” Mr. Homan said.

Most of the county’s 14 school districts perform at or above average in areas such as graduation rates and college preparedness. But their facilities are aging and in need of significant upgrades in many cases.

Advertise with us

“All the high school buildings were built 30 to 50 years ago,” Mr. Homan said. “So when you drive by a [school in] Moon Township or South Fayette or Seneca Valley, the facilities are a lot newer and certainly appear to be a lot better.”

Beaver County offers lower tax rates than some surrounding communities, but that might change.

The difference between education expenses and what districts collect from real estate taxes is made up by state and federal funding. But government funding is unstable and school costs continue to rise, leading inevitably to more of a burden on taxpayers.

The Quality Education Council said the gap between current real estate taxes and total school costs is about $3,000 per household in Beaver County. By 2035, the council said, that gap is expected to grow to about $5,000

Educational equity and economic expansion

Advertise with us

Officials said they know that rising taxes and dilapidated schools won’t attract new families.

What helps, said Jack Manning, a Beaver County commissioner who worked to secure the seed money for the study, is equitable and diverse educational opportunities.

“I’m hoping that if nothing else, the study will show us [how] to ensure that particularly the underserved communities and underserved school districts are providing all the opportunities they can on an equitable basis that the large schools – even the schools outside of Beaver County where I think we’re losing population – have to offer,” he said.

That could mean allowing students to travel outside their district to attend classes in subjects that their own schools don’t offer, or introducing more collaborative efforts like the county’s Career and Technology Center, where students from all 14 districts can learn trades.

What that doesn’t mean, Mr. Manning said, is making school districts merge.

Advertise with us

“We have one merger that turned out to be pretty successful ... but that may not be the answer,” he said. “And forced mergers are absolutely not the answer in my book. You’ve got to have the buy-in from the parents and the residents.”

Mr. Manning also said it is important to create pathways to careers.

“When we started talking about economic growth originally in Beaver County, it still came down to, ‘Do we have the people?”’ he said.

While the jobs accompanying the petrochemical plant are nice, natural gas is not the only industry in Beaver County. Health care, information technology and farming remain significant players in employment in the county.

“We’re working very hard to diversify the economy of Beaver County and make it as resilient as our people have been since the collapse of the steel mills,” Mr. Manning said. “But we’re certainly not looking to all our eggs in the petrochemical basket anymore than we want to put it back into the steel that was there at one point in time.”

Advertise with us

A template for others

The Johns Hopkins research team has interviewed more than 70 school and government officials, business and nonprofit leaders and other community stakeholders over the past several months to get a full view of the challenges facing education.

Steven M. Ross, a senior research scientist and professor at Johns Hopkins’ Center for Research and Reform in Education, leads the group, which he said has received much feedback on what is needed to attract new residents.

The team, Mr. Ross said, will take all of that information into account but will not tell Beaver County what to do.

“We’ll lay out what we’ve heard,” he said. “We’ll be reflective listeners, we’ll be mirrors, and say, ‘We have heard that these problems exist and these goals exist – therefore these gaps exist. And we have heard that there are [opportunities] to bridge these gaps, and here they are. So what do you want to do?’”

Advertise with us

Mr. Ross said he hopes other communities in Pennsylvania and beyond can learn from the study.

“My main goal is to see success with Beaver County,” he said. “As somebody who deeply cares about school reform and improvement and community improvement, I would hope that other people could benefit throughout Pennsylvania.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.