When the Class of 2021 at Carlynton High School in Carnegie gathered materials for a time capsule to commemorate their senior year, two of the items pretty much summed it up: a Chromebook and a mask.
“That represented our senior year and just like our time,” said senior class president Natali Lustiv. “It's just so weird because I feel like next class won't really have to wear masks and who knows, like later years, they're gonna be so confused. They'll be like, ‘They really had to wear masks during school?’”
For the Class of 2021, they really did — at least most of them. Some seniors never made it into a school building at all, remaining virtual the whole year. But whether they were in school five days a week, masked and sanitized, or home in front of a computer, or some combination of both, all members of the Class of 2021 had something in common: it was a senior year they’d never imagined, and one they’ll never forget.
There were assigned seats — spaced six feet apart — at the school lunch table, there were football Fridays without a raucous student section, there was concern about what to take pictures of to fill a yearbook.
“Having this senior year is kind of special to me,” said Mariah Jones, a senior at Baldwin High School headed to Vassar College in the fall, “because it’s unlike any other senior year ever.”
At Carrick High School, senior picture day included temperature checks, social distancing, facial recognition, hand sanitizer and Lysol. At Pine-Richland High School, students participated in a new kind of extracurricular activity: a Healthcare Leadership Council. And at Pittsburgh Allderdice, teacher Katherine Bienkowski was juggling four devices at the same time by the end of the year to run her hybrid classrooms smoothly.
Read More

As part of the Pittsburgh Public Schools, students at Allderdice in Squirrel Hill learned virtually for the vast majority of the school year. Most high school students did not return to the classroom until May 3 — in-person for two days per week, if at all.
The first class that Mrs. Bienkowski taught once hybrid learning began only had one student there in person. She said she felt anxiety leading up to that day, but that even meeting just that one student was “so rewarding.”
Mrs. Bienkowski, who teaches AP English and African American literature, teared up when she spoke about meeting many of her senior students in person for the first time at their Senior Celebration day, which took the place of a prom.
“What I saw was, even though it was a real struggle for a lot of students, many were willing to put some extra effort in to get something out of the remote schooling, to help each other when needed, to try to build a community in the classroom despite all of the obstacles and barriers and frustrations in having remote schooling for a majority of the school year,” she said.
‘I have to do something’
At Woodland Hills High School in Churchill, senior Maya Beckley chose to remain online for the entire school year, though she could have returned in person for hybrid class at the end of March.
Although she found it difficult at first to learn without the typical one-on-one style that comes with in-person classes, Ms. Beckley balanced school deadlines and extracurricular activities, all the while holding a part-time job.
As president of the WHHS Black Student Union, Ms. Beckley helped organize and run a T-shirt fundraiser, a Fudge Farm fundraiser and an online assembly in which guests and students celebrated and spoke about Black History Month.
“I learned that I can do something and I have to do something, because if I don’t do anything, then I’ll feel like I haven’t done much and I’ll feel bored,” said Ms. Beckley, who will attend Penn State at University Park as a computer science major in the fall. “I want to make sure that I’m making a change and I want to make sure that I’m getting involved because, you know, this is my community.”
Some students, like Fox Chapel’s Isabella Krisky, moved back and forth throughout the year between hybrid, completely virtual and completely in-person, depending on the school district’s response to the level of COVID-19 threat in the community.

During her senior year, Ms. Krisky took the unusual step for a high school student of attempting and passing the national LEED Green Associate exam, which certifies professionals in green building principles. Going back and forth between online and in-person learning made it tougher both to find the motivation to take on the LEED exam and to actually study.
“I didn’t have somebody sitting down in front of me saying … ‘Here are some links online,’” said Ms. Krisky, who plans to major in environmental engineering at Carnegie Mellon University. “It was just trying to find time in this crazy pandemic world where all things are moved around.”
‘Kudos to the families’
For districts such as Fox Chapel that did offer a significant amount of in-person school, there were also challenges. At one point in the Bethel Park School District, half of the district’s eight schools were closed due to high levels of COVID-19 spread, said pandemic coordinator Zeb Jansante.
“Kudos to the families and the way they handled that back and forth that was going on,” he said. “They were really amazing, the way they handled it.”
Oakland Catholic High School brought students back in person earlier than most schools, following a model of in-person instruction offered both locally and nationally by Catholic schools. “What was missing was that personal, human-to-human interaction that you get when everybody is in your classroom, and they can do pair work, and small group work, and they don’t have to be concerned about distance,” said school president Mary Claire Kasunic.
Pine-Richland let two of its seniors, Zeyad Amr and Gabrielle Stone, participate in the district’s plans to navigate COVID-19, giving them a seat on the newly created Healthcare Leadership Council. The council was created to involve and inform parents, staff and students in COVID-19-related decisions.
Mr. Amr said his experience on the council allowed him to see the amount of decision making that goes into organizing a school year, especially during a pandemic. “It was very eye-opening seeing these decisions being made and being a part of the team that helped make some of these important resolutions,” he said.
Running track with a mask
Many other students still participated in more traditional extracurricular activities — but with modifications. At Carrick High School, the yearbook staff scrambled to create a senior-only edition once hybrid school began in the spring.
“It was really trying to get the [yearbook committee] excited for a yearbook, and in the back of my head, trying not to panic, because I'm thinking to myself: ‘We're not having any events, we're not having any activities, how am I going to make this happen?’” said Danielle Leach, senior English teacher and yearbook advisor.
After being unable to run her indoor track season because of high COVID-19 cases during the winter, Ms. Jones at Baldwin High School did run outdoor track, with masks on except while running, and gloves to pass the baton during relay races.
After she and the rest of the team managed with the modified season, they finally were rewarded with a slice of normalcy at senior night on June 2. The whole team celebrated the seniors and ate dinner together while the seniors received their lettermen pins like every other year.
At Upper St. Clair High School, senior Jaden Keating managed college recruiting and a pandemic-changed senior football season. The team only played eight games this year, as opposed to the usual 10 or 11 games, he said, with “a lot less fans than normal.”
Mr. Keating knew he wanted to play football in college, and has committed to play at West Virginia University.
COVID-19 gave him more appreciation for the social aspects of both school and football that he previously took for granted. “This year made us realize how much we need people,” he said.
“We can be independent because COVID kind of forced us to be independent, but you really do realize how much you miss your friends and how much you should really cherish your time. You never know when something like a quarantine can happen.”
Demonstrating resilience
At Perry High School, which was virtual for most of the year, principal Robert Frioni tried to balance online school into a traditional school concept with the motto “different but very much the same.”
Trying to keep with the plan of a regular school year, Pittsburgh Public Schools, and Perry High School specifically, worked together to create a senior celebration ceremony in place of the prom and the annual senior banquet. Commencement will be held at the Petersen Events Center on June 12.
Mr. Frioni is looking forward to a level of normalcy next school year with students returning to in-person learning.
But he’s proud of the students and faculty during the 2021 school year.
“Our seniors have demonstrated adaptability and resilience,” he said. “They persevered in this uncertain space, and they’ve done extremely well.
“The lessons learned from this year are ones that could certainly be used in life in general to be successful and prosper moving forward.”
Post-Gazette staff writers Boyce Buchanan, Jesse Bunch, Emma Skidmore, Zoe Stratos and Anya Sostek were the authors of this story.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.