The race for the Pittsburgh Public Schools District 3 board seat this year pits a well-known incumbent with years of experience in a variety of roles in politics against a political newcomer.

Sala Udin, a former City Council member and Freedom Rider, is seeking a second term on the school board. But he has drawn a challenger in Lamont Frazier, a trade union member and youth football coach who touts his support for organized labor.

They will match up against each other in the May 18 Democratic primary, which will likely decide who ultimately takes the seat as no Republican candidate has emerged. The winner will be the board representative for Garfield, East Liberty, most of the Hill District, and parts of Oakland, Stanton Heights and Bloomfield.

Mr. Udin, of the upper Hill, has become one of the most outspoken members of the board as a frequent critic of Superintendent Anthony Hamlet and district administration. He was one of only two school board members to vote against renewing Mr. Hamlet’s contract last year and often speaks out about the district’s educational standards, which he says are inadequate, especially for Black students.

Advertise with us

“I’m trying to sound the alarm for an educational crisis in Pittsburgh Public Schools, and hopefully use that opportunity to raise the standards of performance — raise the standards of performance of the superintendent, raise the standards of performance in teachers, raise the performance standard of the parents and students,” Mr. Udin said. “We’ve all got to buy in to a higher quality of education and not allow mediocrity to become our standard.”

But to Mr. Frazier, of Garfield, the continual complaints from Mr. Udin have not produced enough results. He said he would bring a new perspective to the board and would work to find answers to problems facing the district.

“Let’s stop criticizing what’s going on with our schools and start to find out ways to help, find out ways to figure out solutions,” Mr. Frazier said. “Enough of the criticisms. We all know what the issues are.”

Mr. Frazier said his first priority as a school board member would be to see what he could do to repair district finances. He said he would seek ways to bring more funding into the district by building bridges with large corporations that have set up shop locally, such as Google and Uber. He said he would also push the government to increase taxes on corporations and would be in favor of raising property taxes.

A carpenter and member of Laborers’ Union Local 1058, Mr. Frazier said he would like to expand the district’s career and technical education programs, which can lead to well-paid jobs for students right out of high school.

Advertise with us

Mr. Udin’s top goal remains improving the academic performance — particularly the reading skills — of Black students, who annually underachieve, especially compared with their white peers. He said he wants the district to implement a system where children are taught to read using the most scientifically advanced information and data available.

“They have to be taught how to read early — in preschool, in kindergarten, in first and second grade,” he said. “The end of third grade is an important milestone because the curriculum materials that we use change after the end of the third grade. And if children are not proficient in reading by the end of the third grade, the likelihood is that they will not even graduate from high school.”

But constantly bringing up the low achievement of Black students has become distasteful to some in the community, according to Mr. Frazier.

“Everyone I talked to was, like, ‘[Mr. Udin] just complains, and he never offers any solutions. He just wants to holler,’ ” Mr. Frazier said. “That’s the biggest thing, he just wants to complain or yell at other school board members and talk about what their districts are not doing or how our kids are failing at this and that.”

Mr. Udin said he has ideas, such as implementing reading interventions for the youngest students. However, he said his ideas have been blocked by outside groups that hold sway over some board members.

Advertise with us

Mr. Udin said the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers and One Pennsylvania — both of which endorsed Mr. Frazier — have used their influence to stop his plans in the past and encouraged people to run against him because they were displeased by past comments about teachers and administrators. 

“They put candidates in the race to shut me up,” he said. “The PFT president told me to shut up and dribble, and since I didn’t shut up, they put a completely inexperienced youth football coach who has never expressed any leadership interest in public education, in politics in general or in raising the standards of performance in Pittsburgh Public Schools [in the race].”

PFT President Nina Esposito-Visgitis said she had never met Mr. Frazier before he decided to run and the union does not recruit candidates. She noted that the PFT endorsed Mr. Udin in 2017, but she said it did not this year because he has not built bridges with the union.

Mr. Frazier said he decided to run because as a lifelong Pittsburgh resident and former public school student, he understands the struggles children deal with in the city and he wants to see what he can do to help.

“I just want to be a fresh voice to the school board,” he said. “Right now, there’s a lot of politics being played in the decision-making regarding our schools and our kids. I just want to eliminate that, get down to the basics and figure out the solution.”

Andrew Goldstein: agoldstein@post-gazette.com.