Pennsylvania has struggled over decades to curb its pricey college tuition fees, to entice older adults back to the classroom, and lately, to fill empty seats and dorm beds on its public university campuses.
That’s why a new program underway in a state with a dwindling number of high school graduates could help address all three elusive problems — all while giving students like Kimberly McHenry, 32, of Leechburg, a second chance.
The single mother finishing her first semester at Westmoreland County Community College sees a bachelor's degree in psychology as a way out of subsidized housing for her 1-year-old son, Lincoln, and herself. But she doesn’t have time or a single college credit to waste.
A dual admissions agreement inked in November between the community college and Indiana University of Pennsylvania differs from many cost-cutting articulation pacts in that it opens not just classrooms but dorms.
Students can live at IUP while they pursue an associate's degree at Westmoreland, paying community college tuition.
Ms. McHenry, who lives about 30 miles from IUP, doesn’t need a dorm but likes knowing this: Meeting the program’s requirements will guarantee acceptance to the university, with all of her credits transferable. And in the meantime, IUP resources are at her disposal, including labs, the writing center and campus libraries.
Read More
Ms. McHenry, who holds a GED, has solid grades so far. What’s ahead will test her mettle — having begun community college three times previously, only to give up without finishing classes, then getting herself clean from heroin addiction.
Older now and responsible for a small child, she said she is ready to take it all on.
“If I do what I plan to, then he won’t have to live the way I do,” she said. “I want him to be better, but I have to show him. I have to be better for him to be better.”
In a way, this and other pacts between two- and four-year campuses are a test for Pennsylvania too.
This state often is cited as an example of higher education’s power to transform, with national brands like Carnegie Mellon University, the University of Pittsburgh, Penn State University and the University of Pennsylvania — not to mention scores of smaller public and private campuses.
Yet the state as a whole has fallen short in access and affordability. That fact is exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic, which has disproportionately impacted underrepresented populations nationally and cut enrollments generally — most notably at community colleges, according to the Virginia-based National Student Clearinghouse Research Center.
For many years, Pennsylvania has ranked second- or third-highest for tuition in the nation.
Looking for students
Restocking the state’s shrinking 18- to 22-year-old student market has not been easy.
A decade ago, Pennsylvania ranked 49th among states in the percentage of residents age 25 to 49 without a bachelor’s degree who are pursuing an undergraduate degree or certificate, according to an analysis of federal data by the National Center for Higher Education Management Systems, a Boulder, Colo., group that provides states and institutions with data to help with policy decisions.
Only about 129,000 of the nearly 2.9 million Pennsylvanians without bachelor’s degrees in that age range, or 4.5%, were enrolled.

If Pennsylvania matched the 7% national average back then, it would have meant 72,000 more adults — more than half the current enrollment of the 14 member universities of the State System of Higher Education, which include IUP.
Updated numbers shared with the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette on Thursday show that Pennsylvania is still near the bottom but has nudged upward to 45th place.
To qualify for the program that Ms. McHenry has signed up for, students must have fewer than 30 credits and maintain at least a 2.0-grade point average. They will receive enhanced advising and support from both schools to keep her and others in the program on track academically and financially.
“We want to break down potential barriers,” IUP President Michael Driscoll said.
It’s unclear how many students at WCCC, which has a center near IUP, would opt to pay for room and board. Since 2015, about 330 students who began there finished up at IUP, realizing cost savings that program organizers want to extend.
Tuition and fees at IUP for 60 credits, or two years, costs $26,256. Taking those first 60 credits at Westmoreland could cost $12,000 — about $14,000 less.
“You pay our tuition because you are taking our classes,” said Westmoreland President Tuesday Stanley. “You save money.”
A wake-up call
In January, Pennsylvania's higher education community received what some likened to a wake-up call in the form of Southern New Hampshire University. The school, which includes a multistate online education program, signed a seamless transfer agreement with not just one of Pennsylvania's community colleges, but all 14 of them.
The articulation pact allows for transfer of up to 90 credits toward an online bachelor's degree at SNHU, according to the university and the Pennsylvania Commission for Community Colleges.
Including a standard 10% discount, the cost per credit for Pennsylvanians would be $288, cheaper than most public campuses in this state.
When the deal was announced, Penn State's World Campus was charging $576 per credit.
Elizabeth Bolden, the commission president, pointed to a voluminous number of transfer and articulation agreements that have been implemented given community college students’ strong performance in four-year classrooms.
Price disadvantages have plagued Pennsylvania for many years.
Even State System schools — the least expensive option — have lost students to cross border competition from states including Ohio, which can offer prices roughly equal to, if not less, than what Pennsylvanians would pay to enroll in their home state.
The Southern New Hampshire deal also renewed complaints that community college students face financial barriers in transferring, including difficulty bringing their credits along. State System leaders acknowledge they must recapture their price advantage and “create robust program pathways among universities, schools and community colleges.”
Clarion University President Dale-Elizabeth Pehrsson put it more bluntly in an interview last month: “We want to directly compete and take back the citizens of Pennsylvania.”
Even so, State System Chancellor Daniel Greenstein pushed back on the notion that there is any wholesale waste of community college credits.
“I’ve heard the narrative about credits not transferring into the State System. I actually dug into it, and 93 or 95% of all credits do transfer,” he said.
Raising her confidence
State System enrollment peaked at nearly 120,000 in 2010 but has since dropped to just under 96,000 students. In fall 2019 — before the pandemic — 8,774, or 24%, of the system’s 36,134 on-campus beds were empty, according to a review of State System data.
At home this fall, Ms. McHenry began banging away on her future, polishing off courses in principles of sociology, introduction to psychology, basic math and American Sign Language.
Her success has raised her confidence — and transformed how those closest to her perceive her.
“I’ve heard more people say, ‘I’m proud of you,’ that last several months than in my entire life,” she said.
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.