FRANKLIN TOWNSHIP, Pa. -- Heather Smith, who married right out of high school and started a family, all but gave up on becoming a nurse.
She had planned to hit the books once her two daughters reached adolescence, but she couldn't manage a 100-mile round trip to the nearest community college in a neighboring county. Nor could she afford four-year colleges closer to home.
Then, in 2006, Westmoreland County Community College did something in a state where too few adults like Ms. Smith enroll. It opened a classroom center in a technology park in this Greene County community about 20 miles from her Greensboro home, enabling her to chip away on a degree that had eluded her for 15 years.
"It's been a long journey," said Ms. Smith, 39, a former $12-an-hour health care aide who stands to nearly double her earning potential once she finishes her associate nursing degree in May. "To be able to help my kids get a good start in life is extremely important to me. So is contributing something to my community."
PG graphics
Her late-30s transformation is inspiring. Only trouble is, by at least one measure, it doesn't happen nearly enough in Pennsylvania.
This state ranks 49th in the percentage of residents 25 to 49 without bachelor's degrees who are pursuing undergraduate study. Only about 129,000 of the nearly 2.9 million Pennsylvanians without bachelor's degrees in that age range, or 4.5 percent, are in degree or certificate programs.
The nation as a whole has struggled to draw these older students back to the classroom, a fact cited by policy groups that say the United States has lost ground to other countries in workforce development. Pennsylvania's numbers are especially bleak.
The state trails Louisiana and leads only New Hampshire, which ranked dead last, according to 2009 U.S. Census and Education Department data compiled by the National Center for Higher Education Management Systems. The Boulder, Colo., group provides states and institutions with data to help with policy decisions.
Experts say it's perplexing how a state making significant gains enrolling younger adults, including those right out of high school, continues to miss so many adults in their prime earning years.
If Pennsylvania were to raise its share to the national average, 7 percent, it would translate into 72,000 more adults in college.
That's double the total enrollment of the University of Pittsburgh's main and branch campuses or more than half the enrollment of Pennsylvania's 14 state universities.
"It would have a huge impact, not only for those 72,000 people but for their children," said Joni Finney, a University of Pennsylvania education professor and an expert on higher education access and completion. "Once parents go to college, the likelihood of their kids going into some form of post-secondary education increases. It would have a generational effect."
Adults learning new skills is pivotal to the economy of a state whose younger population is not growing, she said.
"If you don't tap into that 25-to-49-year-old age group, there's just no other place to go," she said. "I think this is a really serious issue for Pennsylvania."
To be sure, it's not as if all adults in the state shun education. College-going rates vary within the state, skewing higher in areas close to big cities and a multitude of campuses.
In fact, the Pittsburgh region's workforce ages 25 to 44 obtains bachelor's degrees at a rate well above the national average, a study last year by the University of Pittsburgh's Center for Social and Urban Research showed. It measured a somewhat different population that did not include such groups as "discouraged workers" no longer looking for a job.
But while Pittsburgh's numbers show promise, the statewide data paint a different picture.
Theories abound as to why so many adults are no-shows.
Some cite cost pressures in a state with relatively high tuition and the time demands facing adult learners who often juggle part-time evening classes with a job and family. Many lack confidence and need catch-up courses that prolong their time in school.
Other experts blame the legacy of steel and other blue-collar industries that for generations gave Pennsylvanians an expectation of well paying jobs without college.
Pennsylvania's unfinished community college system is another barrier. The system, created in the 1960s, was envisioned as having 28 community and technical colleges, but there are 14. That leaves residents in rural areas far away from low cost campuses whose class schedules and support programs cater to adult learners.
The state's sheer size compounds the problem.
"There's a lot more people in rural areas of Pennsylvania than in most states," said Patrick Kelly, senior associate at NCHEMS and director of its Information Center for State Higher Education Policymaking and Analysis.
In recent decades, private and public four-year colleges have courted adult learners with evening and weekend offerings, including those at satellite locations like the Regional Learning Alliance in Cranberry. Online programs like Clarion University's associate of science in early childhood education are reaching students who are too dispersed to justify a physical classroom site.
But Dr. Kelly said states that do better attracting adult learners also tend to have community college systems evenly represented in urban and rural areas.
He cited Kentucky, a state with one third of Pennsylvania's population. Kentucky's public two-year system has 16 colleges compared with Pennsylvania's 14.
"In sheer numbers, 14 strikes me as awfully low," he said.
Some in state higher education circles point to successes of Pennsylvania's 25- to 34-year-olds. Forty-two percent have at least an associate degree, putting Pennsylvania among the top third of states.
But things worsen with age. For example, among Pennsylvania's 35-to-44-year-olds, 34 percent have no more than a high school diploma or equivalency, 8 percentage points worse than the nation.
The Pennsylvania Department of Labor and Industry says it's working to improve training of adults. "It's certainly something we recognize Pennsylvania needs to address," spokesman Christopher Manlove said.
The agency matches employers with skilled workers using resources like its regional workforce investment boards and PA CareerLink offices, which give residents help with training opportunities and job-hunting skills.
The state Department of Education did not respond to requests for comment for this story.
Geography is an enrollment barrier in parts of the state, such as the sparsely populated north-central tier, east of the Erie area and west of Williamsport.
Tiny Cameron County, for example, has the state's highest unemployment rate at nearly 14 percent and virtually no public transportation, said JoAnn Smith, chair of the county commissioners. Reaching Penn State University's Dubois campus and Pitt's Bradford campus can be more than an hour's drive.
"One of our biggest issues is isolation," she said. "If you lost your job and have to drive an hour in your car, think about the cost of gasoline. That's not reimbursable."
Butler County Community College has launched an effort to serve Cameron and 10 other counties in the state's northwest central region.
Other schools have set up shop in counties without a community college, such as the Community College of Allegheny County's Washington County Center.
Building new community colleges means taxpayers in benefiting counties must ante up, and that can be controversial.
In Erie County, where a short-lived technical institute closed years ago, backers of a proposed new community college face backlash over costs.
Even so, Erie County Executive Barry Grossman said too much is at stake economically to let the proposal die. "How do you say no to your top 10 employers who are asking you to do it?" he said.
Since 1999, Westmoreland County Community College has seen its Greene County enrollment grow from 62 to nearly 400. It initially offered classes in high schools but added the Franklin Township classroom center as demand grew. Its nine classrooms and a lab are nearly full, said interim coordinator Nancy Davis.
One student is Robert Satanek, 37, a divorced father of two who's been out of school for years. He's taking general courses to gain acceptance to the associate nursing degree program.
"When I was working unskilled jobs, I always felt down on myself because I felt I had more potential," said Mr. Satanek, who drove a truck, did manufacturing work and is now a nursing assistant at Uniontown Hospital.
Graduating would boost his income and self-esteem. "I'll be able to say 'I got a degree.' I can do something that not just anybody coming out of high school can do."
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.