Odds are a music major practicing the oboe with an instructor wouldn’t pose much risk of passing the coronavirus if the pair stayed far enough apart. A string quartet might be safe, too.
But what about a band? asked Allegheny College president Hilary Link in a recent Zoom call with top aides. Not to mention a symphony, with musicians huffing into a tuba or a trumpet. “You can’t have a social distanced orchestra,” she said.
If her small, 1,800-student liberal arts campus 90 miles north of Pittsburgh was to bring students back for the fall in a pandemic, it first had to undergo a painstaking analysis of everything conceivable that could go wrong.

Colleges and universities across the region and the country have spent the past weeks scrutinizing everyday campus life — students lined up in food courts between classes, fans packed into football games and lab partners working elbow-to-elbow. All of those traditions now could be deadly in the era of COVID-19 if not properly managed.
In recent weeks, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette was granted access to private meetings in which Allegheny College leaders decided if the school could reopen this fall. All topics from enrollment to finances were on the record, save matters of privacy that the school was forbidden by law to reveal. The newspaper agreed not to publish details of the talks until a decision was announced.
On Thursday, Allegheny made that decision: It plans to reopen dorms and resume in-person classes with modifications.
Read More

The ideas and angst shared in the college leadership’s Zoom calls between May 15 and late last week reflect the quandary facing large and small campuses nationwide — each under enormous pressure to resume face-to-face classes in a way that does not worsen a national health crisis.
“We all definitely want to reopen, but we have an obligation to our community to do it safely,” said Ms. Link in an interview before one session.

The virus that emptied campuses in March already has cost millions of dollars in income, from endowments and housing refunds to lost event revenue. An ill-conceived reopening could do still more damage — to student outcomes, the college’s public image and its bottom line.
Nationally, many students have delayed decisions beyond the traditional May 1 deadline and told survey-takers they will not pay in-person prices for another semester of online classes. Projections of enrollment losses of up to 20% have some schools worried about whether they can survive.
As Allegheny College officials discovered, even retrieving belongings from dorms that students had to abruptly leave in March could become fraught.
Some of the Western Pennsylvania college’s students started a petition drive after the school said it would pack and store belongings or ship them home — at a cost. The school later dropped the charge, but ill will persisted — even as the college helped some students watch the process via Skype and FaceTime.
“We are very uncomfortable with strangers going through our personal items,” rising senior Megan Taylor, 21, of Indiana, Pa., wrote in an email to the Post-Gazette early this month. “Some of us have sensitive documents.”
Two movers quit. Vitriol bubbled over to social media. Even a bottle of wine, open since spring break, became an issue when a staffer honored one family’s request at curbside pickup to re-enter a dorm and retrieve the bottle.
Ms. Link, who fielded angry messages herself, said it reinforced how frayed nerves can be in a crisis that has made items as ordinary as an open pickle jar symbols of normalcy for students worth keeping.
“Fundamentally, I get it,” she said. “I’m stressed about my own kids and what they’re going through.”

No hugging students
This fall, Allegheny is aiming for a freshman class of 480 students. As of last week, it was at 93% of that target, said Cornell LeSane III, senior vice president for enrollment and dean of admission.
The hourlong “core group” meetings that Ms. Link and a handful of senior administrators held to figure out the plan for fall were extensions of a dozen campus implementation groups that met to discuss topics from health to pedagogy.
The tone of the gatherings was relatively relaxed. Digital meetings have their quirks, and, like so many others meeting via Zoom, the participants dealt with the occasional screen freeze or a member’s difficulty unmuting the stream.
But there was urgency, as well, over getting surveys out to students about their needs and working with faculty and students who were immuno-compromised or simply not comfortable with face-to-face instruction. At the other extreme, some professors unaware of the risk were showing up at curbside dorm pickups.
“They want to say goodbye. They’re showing up without a mask and they’re hugging students,” said April Thompson, vice president of student life and dean of students.
A flood of changes to the reopening plan — one-way pedestrian pathways, reopening a spacious dining hall and ending the on-campus semester before Thanksgiving — illustrates the detail that had to be worked out. It’s a plan that officials have to master to quickly pivot if the presence of the virus suddenly spikes.
Rural, but international
Founded in 1815, the 32nd oldest college in the U.S., the well-regarded liberal arts school is in a remote setting that falls below the radar of some prospective students who want easy access to culture, bars and airports.
In a pandemic, that isolation might be its biggest asset — being situated in a sparsely populated northwestern Pennsylvania county (Crawford) — where COVID-19 cases totaled only 30 as of June 7. (By contrast, Allegheny County had 2,003 cases through Sunday.)
Families worried about population density and virus transmission might adjust their small-town-vs- big-city calculation.
“I keep saying, ‘I think this is the moment for rural institutions,’” Ms. Link said.
That said, Allegheny attracts students from 47 states and 70 countries to Meadville, a community of less than 13,000 residents. That recruitment diversity is historically a point of pride. But in a pandemic, it adds worry since an undergraduate arriving from New York, Spain or Mongolia might not know they are carrying the virus.
In one Zoom meeting, as images of campus vice presidents in their area homes popped up on computer screens, the group weighed all the things that could go wrong.
A case spike in neighboring Ohio or New York could scuttle planning. So might a shift in government health directives.
What if a student from Seattle self-quarantines, then boards a flight to Meadville through JFK in New York City, where the individual is exposed?
Normal life during the semester itself presents risks: Colleges regularly see visits from friends and family, delivery drivers coming and going, students and teachers who live or work on campus but leave for appointments, or weekends at home.
“We aren’t going to be able to build a force field around campus and lock everybody in,” said Ms. Thompson.
Building a funnel
Consensus grew around a plan to establish — as best the college could — that students starting classes are virus-free.
It would require what amounted to a funnel. Student move-in — hundreds of them getting into dorms over three-days in August — needed to stretch to two weeks so families trying to social distance would have staggered arrival times and students could undergo repeat COVID-19 testing.
Under the plan worked out, arrivals will take a drive-thru test at the Robertson Athletic Complex — the school’s football venue — then move into dorms and self-isolate for three to five days. They will be re-tested before the Aug. 31 start of classes.
Ms. Link, who began working at Allegheny in July after overseeing Temple University’s Rome campus, reached out to health providers in Pennsylvania and Ohio to see if she could buy tests or outsource the work.
“They can do 1,000 tests a day,” and even bring a mobile unit to campus, she told her aides. That’s more than Allegheny needed, but it raised confidence that 5,000 tests could be obtained initially and up to 3,000 more after that, enough for 500 faculty and staff, too.
“I want to be able to say not just that we are going to test. I want to actually be able to say we can get what we need,” she told others on the Zoom call on May 22.
A shortened semester
Perhaps the biggest hurdle was the structure of the school year itself.
Most — faculty included — saw merit in a shortened in-person semester, free of breaks during which students might leave and be exposed, Provost Ron Cole said.
But faculty also struggled to envision how 15-week courses — science labs among them — could be pared by up to 20% yet still cover material needed to maintain academic integrity.
It had become clear in the spring that remote study put students from poorer households at a disadvantage. Plus, not all rural communities have reliable internet connections, and some students simply cannot afford an extra trip home to another state or nation.
“We are back at the place of inequity and unfairness,” Ms. Link told those on the Zoom call.
There was back and forth on when to start.
Squeezing the required instruction into a semester was critical and, to an extent, starting dates were fungible, Mr. Cole said.
Not so for the people responsible for opening dorms and giving students notice when to travel. “That’s most critical to me,” responded Ms. Thompson, the dean of students.
Eventually, they settled on a hybrid plan splitting the traditional 15-week semester with 16 credits into a pair of “modules,” the first with four courses starting on Aug. 31 and ending the week before Thanksgiving.
Students would finish the courses and take final exams during a three-week “module” in which they would work from home, though some could opt to finish up from their dorms.
For spring semester, the order would be flipped: A remote module would start in January with a single course and a capstone experience, followed by a 12-week on-campus module starting in late February.
The plan has the advantage of reducing the campus population during flu season in December, January and February.
Students and sickness
Officials worked on contingencies for students who end up testing positive for the coronavirus, deciding they will be isolated on or near campus. Infected students will be able to continue studies remotely depending on their symptoms.
Five staff will be trained as contract tracers to find out who has been exposed and limit the virus’s spread.
Unlike enormous research campuses like Penn State and the University of Pittsburgh, Allegheny does not have a medical complex.
But it has a global health studies program and graduates working in places including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta — expertise directly relevant to the crisis.
The college decided to create an unusual entity, the Allegheny College Health Agency, to address COVID-19 issues.
The new agency is being led by Gabrielle Morrow, a local physician; Becky Dawson, an epidemiologist and biology professor in Allegheny’s global health studies program, and Ms. Link.
Decisions that will wait
Allegheny College entered the pandemic financially stronger than some small schools, with an $231 million endowment. But COVID-19 promises to inflict heavy costs, many yet to be tabulated.
Even if her college eventually had to pass costs on to students, said Ms. Link, it would likely mean more tuition discounting down the road. The school’s total cost to attend tops $60,000, although its net price after financial aid in 2017-18 — what most students actually pay — was about $25,000, according to federal data.
But higher education’s convoluted price structure was a topic for another day.
In mid-May, Ms Link had joked that she would bury her face in her hands if forced to make an open-or-close decision immediately.
By last week, she and her aides sounded more optimistic given the plan they had cobbled together.
Said Mr. Cole, “It’s looking pretty good.”
Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.