The board governing Pennsylvania’s 14 state universities could vote Thursday to shift much of its long-held responsibility for setting tuition to member universities, freeing them to develop individual, multi-year price plans.

Under a proposal that would take effect in fall 2020, the State System of Higher Education’s board of governors would continue to set a yearly system tuition, but only for campuses that do not opt to create their own price plans, officials said.

Each campus long has set its own room, board and most other fees. But adding to that list tuition — the largest single cost at most schools — would be a sea change for campuses that for decades have existed somewhere between independence and total system control.

Those who like the idea, including State System Chancellor Daniel Greenstein, have cast it as giving more local freedom in decision-making in return for greater accountability against goals that include sustaining programs and staying affordable.

Advertise with us

The board’s University Success Committee is to discuss the proposal Wednesday at the Dixon University Center in Harrisburg, said State System spokesman Kenn Marshall. If the panel endorses it, a vote by members of the full board could come Thursday morning.

“They are not giving up ultimate control in the sense that the price plans must be approved by the system,” Mr. Marshall said.

However, it will be up to individual schools to decide whether to seek strategies that boost or lower prices, and how to distribute institutional aid using their new freedom in how much campus income can be used for both need- and merit-based awards.

Two system policies governing financial aid would be rescinded.

“The recommended revisions … are based on the concept that State System universities will serve more Pennsylvanians if their pricing strategies are flexible and student-centered, recognizing differences in each university’s region, program offerings, and characteristics of the individual student — especially the student’s ability to pay,” stated material accompanying a board resolution.

Advertise with us

For the system’s 98,000 students, it also could mean earlier  notice of tuition increases. It would bring an end to the traditional practice of setting new rates in July, just weeks before the start of fall classes.

“Tuition rates will be set annually no later than April 30 for the upcoming two academic years,’’ according to background material for Wednesday’s meeting. “The tuition rate for the second year, based on the most current three-year average increase in the State System’s basic tuition rate, will be set as tentative with the opportunity to be adjusted.”

The 14 system universities, including California, Clarion, Edinboro, Indiana and Slippery Rock in Western Pennsylvania, are the least expensive public university option in Pennsylvania. This year’s $7,716 base undergraduate tuition is less than half of what is charged by the University of Pittsburgh or Penn State.

But population loss in parts of the state and steep enrollment declines,  coupled with government subsidies near the bottom nationally, have left some campuses in or near financial crisis the last few years.

Amid those woes, the State System set out more than two years ago to redesign itself. It weighed everything from its board structure to whether it can still justify 14 campuses.

Advertise with us

Skeptics in the Legislature questioned the system’s ability to make bold changes. That body commissioned a study that in April 2018 recommended more radical moves, such as cutting the system to as few as five to eight universities through mergers, or even making them branches of schools like Pitt and Penn State.

Since the State System’s founding in 1983, a centrally set tuition has been the norm, with deviations only through pilot programs approved by the board of governors the last five years. But as disparity continued to grow among campuses with regard to their financial health and enrollment, some imposed still higher fees, even has their enrollments declined.

The total price gap including tuition, room, board and other fees across the State System once was $1,460 but has now grown to $6,499, with Indiana University of Pennsylvania now highest at $25,405 and West Chester University the lowest at $18,906, according to system data. It’s unclear how the proposal might affect that gap over time.

The meetings Wednesday and Thursday could reveal if there are any remaining concerns about whether campus-set tuition could make schools less affordable, and if more analysis needs to be done.

One frequent voice expressing concern about recent campus price experiments and  their potential to drive away students without safeguards has  been Kenneth Mash, president of the Association of Pennsylvania State College and University Faculties.

Advertise with us

After looking at the proposal Tuesday, he said in part, “most of my concerns have been alleviated.”

“If anything, I would have liked to have seen the policy require specific reporting on the impact of tuition policies on students of lesser means. But even there it looks as if the chancellor is empowered to ask for more.”

The policy, which requires periodic review of impacts, stresses that affordability has a different meaning for each individual.

Campus-set tuition rates “recognize regional economic differences in costs, household income, cost of living, and average buying power within the region.”

Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @Bschackner.