"Clear All Data 2/6/2017 10:09:39."

That was the message on the data page for a box labeled "DVR 2." It showed basement camera angles in the Beta Theta Pi house near Penn State University where Timothy Piazza spent some of his last agonizing hours — angles police investigating his death had never seen.

Only there was a problem: The video was gone.

How investigators got from that seeming dead end on July 27 to Monday's announcement of new charges in Mr. Piazza's death — including a fraternity brother now accused of deleting the video — apparently was an odd mix of sleuthing, forensics and plain old math.

Advertise with us

The ability of FBI agents to restore the video, and a flurry of text messages between fraternity brothers captured by police -- some from the day Mr. Piazza was hospitalized discussing how the video could be erased — have further re-ignited an already explosive case, one that has garnered national attention.

According to court records, the now-recovered video from the basement showed much of the alcohol consumption that night, including a hazing ritual of forced drinking called "The gauntlet" that Mr. Piazza and 13 other fraternity pledges endured on Feb. 2.

Read More

Writing in an affidavit of probable cause, State College Police Detective David Scicchitano said he had gone to the State College police station on July 27 with a warrant to review the DVR system for a case unrelated to the Piazza investigation. What he saw were angles for a video feed that "he had been led to believe in the investigation were not working," Mr. Scicchitano wrote.

He verified with the device's manufacturer that the message found on DVR 2 meant someone had manually deleted the machine's video. Another box labeled "DVR 1" apparently had video on it as far back as Jan. 31, including images of Mr. Piazza, 19, a sophomore engineering major from Lebanon, N.J.

Mr. Scicchitano said a fellow borough detective, Craig Ripka, told him that, back on Feb. 6, he had taken several cell phone images while in the house, including some of fraternity brother Braxton Becker, 21, of Niskayuna, N.Y. The images were of Mr. Becker using a key to enter a closet where the video machine was kept and of him sitting in front of it.

Advertise with us

That detective also took images of the machine itself, according to the affidavit.

"A State College system analyst determined that the DVR 2 box was four minutes ahead of the DVR 1 box," Mr. Scicchitano wrote.

That would have meant the deletion occurred at 10:05 a.m. on Feb. 6, except that Mr. Scicchitano in the sworn affidavit stated that he already knew DVR 2 was 37 minutes behind real time.

"So, the above deletion appeared to have occurred at 1042 hours real time," he stated. "Det. Ripka confirmed that this was the time that Becker was in the closet with the DVR machines."

"The analyst also confirmed that the manual deletion would require someone to take the following steps: "Menu"; "Setup"; "Storage'; "Format," and then the deletion."

Advertise with us

The affidavit did not state what the investigation was that brought Mr. Scicchitano to the State College police station on July 27.

The new evidence came after Centre County District Judge Allen Sinclair in September threw out the most serious charges against fraternity members in the death, including aggravated assault, which is a felony, and involuntary manslaughter; he let stand lesser charges including hazing and furnishing alcohol to minors.

Centre County District Attorney Stacy Parks Miller refiled charges earlier in the fall and on Monday added new charges — including involuntary manslaughter — against previously uncharged individuals in the death of Mr. Piazza, based on recovery of deleted video in the Beta Theta Pi fraternity house.

Mr. Becker, the fraternity house manager, is charged with tampering with evidence: “To wit: he deleted surveillance video of an incident knowing a police investigation was underway,” according to the affidavit. He is also charged hindering apprehension or prosecution. Other fraternity members are listed as co-defendants.

Mr. Becker’s lawyer, Karen Muir, could not immediately be reached for comment.

Advertise with us

On Aug. 9, the detectives turned over the basement DVR and the other DVR to the FBI. Agents there were able to recover the deleted footage.

Detectives also had text message exchanges between fraternity members and others regarding the erasure. Finance officer Adam Mengden and Mr. Becker had the following exchange on Feb. 3 after Mr. Piazza had been taken to the hospital, according to the affidavit:

Mengden: “Erasing the cameras could be the look as long as no one found out.”

Becker: “I think the exact same thing ... The guy told me to check them in a few days to make sure they were recording. I could say I checked and they weren’t so I just turned them on.”

The release with the new charges that have been filed:

Advertise with us

Beta Theta Fraternity Charges 11 13 2017 (PDF)

Beta Theta Fraternity Charges 11 13 2017 (Text)

They also had a text message exchange in which Mr. Becker discussed the implications of hazing, according to the affidavit.

In one the girlfriend of Mr. Becker wrote: “but I mean its not their fault a kid fell down the stairs you know? he chose to drink that much and he got himself into an accident.”

Mr. Becker replied: “No that’s the thing ... Is like it was because he was technically hazed into drinking that much.”

Advertise with us

The affidavit details the drinking “obstacle course” and other forced drinking the night when Mr. Piazza was injured by falling down the basement stairs, then was left by his fraternity brothers for hours despite the fact that he was badly injured, and unconscious at times.

That night pledges had to drink vodka three times quickly, then chug a can of beer, then chug wine from a winebag, then drink a cup of beer if they missed throwing a pingpong ball into a cup. The footage revealed that Mr. Piazza never served himself, and that he consumed at least 18 drinks in a period of one hour and 22 minutes.

In the 12-page affidavit supporting Mr. Becker's arrest, Detective Scicchitano described images showing "that the hazing activity by brothers continued during what was supposed to be the 'social."' He stated that numerous brothers gave additional alcohol to the pledges, among them Mr. Piazza:

One brother gave him a can of beer: "Piazza drank from this can."

Another brother held a winebag up to him: "Piazza chugged from it."

Advertise with us

Still another held a winebag up to him: "Piazza chugged from it."

One more held a winebag up to him: "Piazza chugged from it."

Another brother gave a handle of vodka to him: "Piazza chugged from it."

The document later states that "Piazza staggered through the crowded dance floor to the home bar room."

At another point, the document describes Mr. Piazza as having no shirt or shoes as he staggered down a hallway.

Advertise with us

"Piazza was seen on his hands and knees in the away bar room," the detective states in the affidavit. "[Mr. Piazza] buried his head in his hands on the floor..."

According to a text exchange Feb. 3, Mr. Becker was asked by another fraternity brother if videotape taken so far included the obstacle course.

Becker: "Nah. They took tapes from 7 and 9:30 a.m."

"[Expletive] yes" came the reply, to which the affidavit quotes Mr. Becker as saying, "We should be good ... On that front at least."

After Mr. Piazza’s death, Mr. Becker texted to another fraternity member: “It’s awful jeff. We got sloppy. Nugget for the last few days was saying we shouldn’t get the kids this [expletive] up on their first night but no one listened.”

Advertise with us

——-

Co-defendant data sheets filed along with the affidavit listed the following individuals: Brendan P. Young, Malvern, Pa.; Daniel Casey, Ronkonkoma, N.Y.; Jonah D. Neuman, Nashville, Tenn.; Nicholas J. Kubera, Downington, Pa.; Michael Bonatucci, Woodstock, Ga.; Gary A. Dibileo, II, Scranton, Pa.; Luke K. Visser, Encinitas, Ca.; Joseph M. Sala, Erie, Pa.; Michael Angelo Schiavone, Yardley, Pa.; Craig A. Heimer, Port Matilda, Pa.; Lars E. Kenyon, Barrington, R.I.; Parker J. Yochim, Waterford, Pa.; Edward J. Gilmartin III, Scranton, Pa.; Ryan T. McCann, McCandless; Lucas D. Rockwell, Bolling AFB, D.C.; Beta Theta Pi fraternity; Ryan K. Foster, Bedford, Pa.; Joseph G. Ems Jr., Philadelphia; Joshua Kurczewski, Erie, Pa.; Donald M. Prior III, Westport, Conn.; Jonathan Kanzler, Coopersburg, Pa.; Patrick E. Jackson, Bethlehem, Pa.; Reginald Goeke, State College, Pa.; Brian A. Gelb, Bethesda, Md.; Michael Fernandez, Randolph, N.J.; Ryan Burke, Scranton, Pa.; Aidan O'Brien, West Chester, Pa.; and Bo Han Song, Wayne, Pa.

Lillian Thomas contributed. Bill Schackner: bschackner@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1977 and on Twitter: @BschacknerPG.