Third in an occasional series.

Deirdre Keller’s third-grade class started the day putting the final touches on the field day games they were creating for a school-wide competition to see whose game would be played at the big event at the end of the school year.

They spent an hour outside testing their games and getting feedback from their classmates before heading back inside for a break and a cheese stick. Then, it was time for a class favorite: the edible school yard.

The class split into three groups for their lesson in the school gardens planted next to the main entrance. One group planted flowers, one group pulled weeds and one group used fresh-squeezed lemons and mint from the herb garden to make lemonade, which the entire class shared at the end of the lesson. The groups rotated between the garden beds so each student got a chance to perform each activity, which helped them put into real-life practice some of the things they learned about grids, annual and perennial plants and sustainable agriculture.

Advertise with us

“I think one of the biggest things is it really is supported and prioritized that we get outside on a regular basis,” said Ms. Keller.

Such is the way at Environmental Charter School, arguably one of the more popular charter schools in Allegheny County with about 630 students and a waiting list of about 500. The school currently has two locations near Frick Park, a lower school for students in kindergarten through third grade and an upper school for students in fourth through eighth grades. Soon, school administrators plan to release a timeline for opening a new high school and a second K-8 school.

Created with Highstock 5.0.12Pittsburgh and Environmental Charter, by the numbersThe Post-Gazette used data from the Pennsylvania Department of Education tocompare Environmental Charter School with Pittsburgh Public Schools on a variety offactors.The Post-Gazette used data from the Pennsylvania Department of Education to compare Environmental Charter School with Pittsburgh Public Schools on a variety of factors.

Created with Highstock 5.0.12Enrollment: Pittsburgh, Environmental Charter17 ,56017 ,56017 ,48717 ,48717 ,46017 ,46016 ,33416 ,33416 ,53416 ,534441441525525604604628628628628Pittsburgh K-8 EnrollmentEnvironmental Charter School enrollment'11-'12'12-'13'13-'14'14-'15'15-'1605000100001500020000Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Created with Highstock 5.0.12Pittsburgh students in Environmental Charter135139141130180155118184241300395424473510Non-Pgh students in Environmental CharterPittsburgh Students in Environmental Charter'09-'10'10-'11'11-'12'12-'13'13-'14'14-'15'15-'160200400600800Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 5.0.12Pittsburgh Public Schools students in charters5456747668297696546252 ,0112 ,0232 ,3852 ,7322 ,9193 ,0763 ,296Pittsburgh Public Schools students in cyber chartersPittsburgh Public Schools students in non-cyber charters'09-'10'10-'11'11-'12'12-'13'13-'14'14-'15'15-'16010002000300040005000Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Jon McCann, the school’s CEO, and Nikole Sheaffer, director of innovation, said they had a real “Pollyanna-type” attitude about the way the school would function when it opened in 2008. They expected their charter school would collaborate with other public schools in Pittsburgh and work together to “transform what public education can look like.”

But so far, that has not happened the way that they had hoped.

Twenty years after the passage of the Pennsylvania Charter School Law, charter schools like Environmental remain controversial not just because they redirect funds away from school districts, but also because, critics argue, the academic performance of charter students are lower than their counterparts in traditional public schools.

School districts pay a per-student “tuition” to charter schools based on what the district spends per student in traditional public schools. Local school boards also act as the charter school “authorizers,” who make decisions with regard to granting, revoking and expanding the schools’ charters within their districts.

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 5.0.12Pittsburgh tuition costNonspecial education student priceSpecial education student price'00-'01'01-'02'02-'03'03-'04'04-'05'05-'06'06-'07'07-'08'08-'09'09-'10'10-'11'11-'12'12-'13'13-'14'14-'15'15-'16'16-'17$0$10000$20000$30000$40000Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Not surprisingly, Mr. McCann said, that has created an often tense relationship between districts and charter schools, pitching them into a battle for money and students rather than promoting collaboration, as some lawmakers in 1997 intended when they allowed for the creation of the new schools.

“There is a general sense of frustration that the law and the constructs have not changed to support this sector of public education,” Mr. McCann said. “It doesn’t work for anyone. It just causes friction.”

Steve Robinson, spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, said his organization is primarily concerned with the way charter schools are funded and how they are held accountable for student performance and use of funds.

“Charter advocates will argue that they are every bit as accountable, but the fact is they don’t have to jump through all the hoops and all the same disclosures,” he said.

Advertise with us

For instance, they can simply expel a student who poses a disciplinary problem and they don’t have to enroll students with the most severe disabilities. They aren’t operated by an elected school board that is accountable to taxpayers, some critics point out.

Ms. Sheaffer did indeed say charter schools “moan about the same regulations” as every other public entity with regards to audits and state reporting.

“We don’t select our students,” she said. “We don’t kick students out. We do everything the school district does and then we have our authorizer come in and do it again.”

Mr. McCann pointed out that there are other ways to measure the success of his school, which aims to create critical thinkers and teach ecological literacy rather than simply “graduate students.”

“How do you quantify 500, 600 people trying to get into your school?” he said.

Advertise with us

The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette examined Pennsylvania System of School Assessment test score data kept by the Pennsylvania Department of Education. The newspaper found that during the 2015-16 school year, the average number of students who received advanced or proficient scores on the PSSA was lower in charter schools than in other types of public schools.

But there are exceptions, and Environmental Charter is among them.

Roughly 75 percent of Environmental Charter school students who took the third grade test for English Language Arts scored advanced or proficient in the 2015-16 school year, compared to roughly 58 percent of third grade students at Phillips K-5 Elementary on the South Side, which is part of the Pittsburgh Public Schools district. Math scores for third graders at Environmental Charter School were similarly higher than math scores for the same-aged children at Phillips.

Created with Highstock 5.0.12Test scores comparedPSSA test scores for third-grade students in Environmental Charter School comparedwith those of Phillips K-5 Elementary School, in Pittsburgh, sorted by proficiency inEnglish and Math, 2015-16:PSSA test scores for third-grade students in Environmental Charter School compared with those of Phillips K-5 Elementary School, in Pittsburgh, sorted by proficiency in English and Math, 2015-16:

Created with Highstock 5.0.12ENGLISH LANGUAGE ARTS30%30%11.1%11.1%45.7%45.7%46.7%46.7%17.1%17.1%35.6%35.6%7.1%7.1%6.7%6.7%Percent AdvancedPercent ProficientPercent BasicPercent Below BasicEnvironmental CharterSTUDENTS SCORED: 70Phillips K-5Elementary SchoolSTUDENTS SCORED: 450%25%50%75%100%Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education;Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 5.0.12MATH31.9%31.9%15.6%15.6%44.9%44.9%31.1%31.1%5.8%5.8%26.7%26.7%17.4%17.4%26.7%26.7%Percent AdvancedPercent ProficientPercent BasicPercent Below BasicEnvironmental CharterPhillips K-5 ElementarySchoolPhillips K-5 Elementary School0%25%50%75%100%Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education;Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

For parents, the existence of charter schools means they have a choice other than their neighborhood school or an expensive private school for the education of their child. Nearly 133,000 students, or 7 percent of the state’s students, were in charter schools in the 2015-16 school year, the latest for which the Pennsylvania Department of Education has released data.

Carrie DiFiore, whose 9-year-old daughter Lili is in Ms. Keller’s class, chose Environmental Charter School after her niece’s experience there. Ms. DiFiore, who lives in South Side Flats, was attracted by the school’s goal of producing creative thinkers and responsible citizens.

“They look outside of the school a lot and they have a lot of collaboration not only within the school but with Carnegie Mellon and Grow Pittsburgh,” she said. “It’s a very holistic way of thinking about learning. It’s really neat to watch the kids and see how engaged they get and how excited they get.”

Ms. Sheaffer, who also serves as the charter school’s director of communications, said Environmental Charter School plans hundreds of “experiences” a year for its students, including visits to the park, activities to study the effect of climate change, trips to observe urban architecture and visits with local businesses.

Advertise with us

“It is a really, really great way to teach a way of thinking about the world and take responsibility,” said Ms. DiFiore, who also had the option of sending her daughter to Phillips.

On a recent spring morning at Phillips, Dina Aivaliotis’ third grade class was practicing their multiplication tables. After splitting into groups and completing the different math “stations” — worksheets, a computer game and card game among them — they took a bathroom break before engaging in a spirited debate about “Macaroni Boy,” the novel they were reading as a class.

Cathy Qureshi, whose 9-year-old daughter Keira was in the class, said her family didn’t even consider schools when they purchased a home just a few blocks away.

“Our opinion is we just lucked in to one of the best schools in the city of Pittsburgh,” she said.

Phillips is one of Pittsburgh Public Schools’ “partial magnets” for Spanish instruction, said Principal Mike Calvert. Only about a third of the students enrolled at the school live in the neighborhood — the rest choose to come there from across the city school district. About 65 percent of the students are “economically disadvantaged” and just under half of them are white, he said.

Advertise with us

The school has a waiting list of students who want to attend, Mr. Calvert said. The school is also among several PPS schools participating in a RAND Corporation study of “restorative practices” in an attempt to reduce exclusionary disciplinary actions like suspensions and expulsions.

“I think they see that and the resources we provide and it’s hard for charter schools and private schools to compete,” he said.

And that is the goal of school choice overall, at least according to advocates like Betsy DeVos, the new secretary for the U.S. Department of Education. She has thrown her support behind charter schools, as well as tax credit and school voucher programs that redirect money into scholarships for kids who want alternatives to their neighborhood public school. Having choice, she believes, will ultimately lead to improvements in all kinds of schools.

Skeptics of charter schools and school choice remain unconvinced.

“The heart of it is, charter schools were founded on the premise of privatizing public education,” said Ira Weiss, whose law firm represents local school districts including Pittsburgh Public Schools, Montour and Baldwin-Whitehall. “Their [performance] numbers should be out of the park, and they’re not,” Mr. Weiss said. “And they’re playing the game with house money.”

Advertise with us

The Center for Research and Education Outcomes at Stanford University, or CREDO, has conducted multiple national studies on the effectiveness of charter schools.

One report, in 2013, found that charter schools overall had improved since a similar study had been conducted in 2009. The study found that charter students in 26 states and New York City on average got the equivalent of an additional eight days of learning each year in reading as compared with their peers in traditional schools.

In math, the 2013 study found there was no significant difference in learning between charter students and those in traditional public schools. But in Pennsylvania, according to that study, charter students on average covered 29 days less material in reading and 50 days less in math, placing in the bottom three states in the 2013 study. Researchers at the time said the poor performance of cyber charter schools could have been bringing down the state average.

In 2015, a national CREDO study found that about 70 percent of students in cyber charter schools fall behind their counterparts in traditional schools — losing the equivalent of 72 days of instruction in reading and 180 days in math during the typical 180-day school year.

A second study that same year, however, found that students in urban, brick-and-mortar charter schools on average receive about 40 days of additional learning in math and 28 additional days of reading per year than their counterparts at traditional public schools.

Advertise with us

Mr. Weiss has been an outspoken critic of the way charter schools are funded, arguing that the schools don’t have the same expenses as traditional schools — such as big capital projects, a unionized workforce and transportation for students.

As solicitor for several school districts, he also has helped school boards review and negotiate proposed charter schools or charter expansions and renewals. For instance, the Pittsburgh Public Schools board voted in 2012 to close Career Connections Charter High School in Lawrenceville, saying the school didn't meet all of the conditions of its charter, didn't meet requirements for student performance and didn't provide expanded choices or serve as a model for other schools.

Most recently, Mr. Weiss said, his firm agreed to “settle” with Environmental Charter School over the charter school’s planned expansion.

The Pittsburgh school board initially denied the school’s application, which it then challenged in front of the state Charter School Appeals Board, which handles similar matters for charter schools across Pennsylvania. The board ruled in favor of the charter school in February, and Mr. Weiss said he intended to challenge that ruling in Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court.

To avoid more litigation, the two parties agreed on the expansion if Environmental made some compromises. Among them was a promise by Environmental to diversify its student population. In the 2015-16 school year, 69 percent of Environmental students were white and 17 percent were black, according to data from the state Department of Education.

Advertise with us

Created with Highstock 5.0.12NUMBER OF STUDENTSRacial breakdowns: Environmental, Pittsburgh PublicAs part of a "settlement" with the Pittsburgh Public Schools, Environmental CharterSchool has reiterated its commitment to diversifying its student population.-2015-16 school yearAs part of a "settlement" with the Pittsburgh Public Schools, Environmental Charter School has reiterated its commitment to diversifying its student population.-2015-16 school year7723231081082020393900431431628628434383183112 ,81512 ,8156546541 ,8001 ,80028288 ,0198 ,01924 ,19024 ,190Environmental Charter SchoolPittsburgh Public SchoolsAmerican Indian/Alaskan NativeAsianBlackHispanicMulti-RacialNative Hawaiian orother Pacific IslanderWhiteTOTALSTUDENTS05k10k15k20k25k30kSource: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Created with Highstock 5.0.12ENVIRONMENTALCHARTER SCHOOLENVIRONMENTAL CHARTER SCHOOLSTUDENT RACIAL BREAKDOWN,2015-16 SCHOOL YEARSource: Pennsylvania Department of Education;Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

Created with Highstock 5.0.12PITTSBURGH PUBLICSCHOOLSPITTSBURGH PUBLIC SCHOOLSSTUDENT RACIAL BREAKDOWN,2015-16 SCHOOL YEARSource: Pennsylvania Department of Education;Research: Liz Navratil, graphic: Ed Yozwick

“The biggest thing is to be realistic and coming up with a positive out of a bad situation,” Mr. Weiss said.

But Environmental Charter has been working for months to do more “to connect with the diverse population of the city of Pittsburgh and work on a program that they all feel that they have access to,” Ms. Sheaffer said.

Advertise with us

Still, as negotiations continue with the Pittsburgh district, she said it is the responsibility of the adults in the education field to come up with solutions that not only benefit students and taxpayers, but all schools as well.

“We hope that this is the beginning of a long and beautiful relationship with PPS,” she said.

Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590 or on Twitter @Ebehrman. Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1438 or on Twitter @LizNavratil.