Sometimes, Alexis Trubiani will take a drive to see for herself whether a student’s listed address is actually an occupied residence.
The Clairton City School District only has to pay a charter school for a student who lives within its borders, but a charter school doesn’t have to immediately notify the district if the student moves to another area. It can take months to sort out the confusion and get the money back if an error isn’t corrected immediately, so Ms. Trubiani, the district’s student services liaison, prefers to be proactive.
She has been tasked with tracking the district’s charter school payments for the last five years, filling a role the district created specifically for that reason. During her first two years on the job, she said she found enough money in over-payments to charter schools to pay her salary twice over.
“Things sometimes don’t match up,” said Ms. Trubiani, an alumna of the school district, who also serves as its public relations director.
And in a school district like Clairton, which has just over 760 students and operates with an annual budget of $15 million, paying a charter school when it isn’t legally required is a mistake it can’t afford.
Twenty years after lawmakers passed the Pennsylvania Charter School Law, one of the most common complaints schools districts have is about the funds they drain from traditional public schools.
Read More
The number of students attending charter schools varies widely from district to district — with Wilkinsburg, Sto-Rox and Woodland Hills losing some of the largest percentages of students to charter schools locally, according to state data. As a result, it's common for some districts to spend millions each year on payments to charter schools — over which they may have only limited influence.
Created with Highstock 5.0.12Charter school tuitionAmount spent, in millions of dollars, by selected school districts on students attendingcharter schools:Amount spent, in millions of dollars, by selected school districts on students attending charter schools:2012-132013-142014-152015-16WilkinsburgSto-RoxDuquesne CityWoodland HillsPenn HillsPittsburgh$0$25000000$50000000$75000000Note: These numbers are estimates based on each school district's enrollment in Oct. 1 of each school year.Actual enrollment numbers, and therefore costs, can vary throughout the year. Exact figures are kept by the school districts.-Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, Graphic: Ed Yozwick
Roughly 9,500 students living within Allegheny County school districts attended charter schools in the 2015-16 school year. Of them, at least 2,400 attended cyber charter schools, according to data from the Pennsylvania Department of Education. By comparison, nearly 142,000 students attended other public schools in Allegheny County.
“I think the law is not going to go away and that brick-and-mortar charter schools are going to remain part of the public charter school menu,” said Ronald Cowell, president of the Education Policy and Leadership Center and a former state representative who voted in favor of the Pennsylvania Charter School Law in 1997. “What that looks like in 500 different districts is going to vary immensely. I think the biggest barrier to greater cooperation between school districts and charter schools — particularly charter schools located within their jurisdiction — is how we pay for charter schools.”
School districts pay charter schools “tuition” for each student who resides within district limits and attends the charter school.That number varies from district to district, and is based on a per-pupil cost of what the district would spend to educate that student if he or she were enrolled in a traditional public school. For example, Sto-Rox paid about $8,700 to educate each non-special education student during the 2015-16 school year, while Fox Chapel paid more than $15,000 to do the same.
Districts pay a different, often much-higher rate for students who are classified as special education students.
In a report released this month, the Pennsylvania Association of School Administrators dedicated its top three recommendations for charter school reform to issues surrounding funding. The report stated that the funding formula used to calculate how much a school district spends per child includes costs that charter schools don’t pay for, including fees related to gifted education, extracurricular activities and transportation. The group goes on to call for an adjustment of the funding formula to “reflect the actual cost needed to educate students in these alternate environments,” particularly for special education students and students in cyber charter schools.
“In other words, the formula requires traditional public schools to send more money to charter schools than is needed to operate their programs,” the report reads. “The result is a windfall for the charter schools and a deficit for traditional public schools, particularly for those with a higher concentration of charter students.”
No charter schools are located within the Clairton district, but school board president Richard Livingston still deemed the law “disastrous.” Instead of sharing best practices and serving as an extension of traditional public education, as creators of the law initially envisioned, charter schools have turned the public school environment into something else.
“What it’s turned into is a competition where we’re fighting over the same education dollars,” he said.
Charter schools take between $1.2 million and $1.4 million each year from the Clairton City School District budget, Mr. Livingston said. “That’s a hefty percentage,” he said, and one that contributed to some of the district’s financial decisions, including raising property taxes three times in the past 10 years and furloughing 32 staff members in 2011, the same year former Gov. Tom Corbett cut state funding that assisted school districts with charter school payments.
State data show that during the 2015-16 school year, 113 students who lived within the Clairton district attended charter schools, with the majority of them attending either Propel Homestead or Propel McKeesport. Clairton pays roughly $11,000 for each non-special education student and more than $28,000 for each special education student. The Clairton district also pays for transportation for each charter school student, per the charter school law, even though it does not provide busing for students who attend the district schools.
Created with Highstock 5.0.12Number of studentsLosing students to charter schoolsCharter schools gaining the most students from Clairton City School District and theirenrollment figures:Charter schools gaining the most students from Clairton City School District and their enrollment figures:39393838474740403535272731313773773813813883883943943973973993993893891515131317172020282831314040498498555555555555587587606606599599581581Clairton kids inPropel-McKeesportPropel-McKeesporttotal enrollmentClairton kids inPropel-HomesteadPropel-Homesteadtotal enrollment2009-102010-112011-122012-132013-142014-152015-160200400600800Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, Graphic: Ed Yozwick
Created with Highstock 5.0.12Number of studentsClairton City School District enrollment figures, percent attending charter schools:737766750793785794764838110110211596113Total number of K-12 students in traditionalpublic schools in the school districtTotal number of students who live inClairton school district and attend charters2009-1010.1%2010-119.6%2011-1211.9%2012-1311.4%2013-1412.8%2014-1510.8%2015-1612.9%02505007501000Note: These figures do not include a small number of students who mightattend private schools, technical institutes or state juvenile correctional institutes.Source: Pennsylvania Department of Education; Research: Liz Navratil, Graphic: Ed Yozwick
Charter school operators agreed with Mr. Livingston that the law — which hasn’t been updated in a major way since 2002, when legislators allowed for the creation of cyber charter schools — has pitted school districts and charter schools into a distracting battle for money, rather than a healthy competition to improve the quality of all local public schools. But they argue that the “narrative” that charter schools are bleeding districts of funds is misleading.
“First of all, my frame is it’s not their money,” said Jeremy Resnick, executive director and a co-founder of Propel Charter Schools, which operates 13 schools across Allegheny County with about 4,000 students expected in the fall. “It’s the taxpayers’ money. And it isn’t their children.”
School districts, especially in some areas in Western Pennsylvania, were struggling with funds long before 1997 and the introduction of charter schools, he said.
Jon McCann, CEO of Environmental Charter School at Frick Park, said charter schools don’t receive as much money as some would believe. They don’t get any funding to cover the costs of their buildings, and the schools have to negotiate with property owners to make sure they are getting the best deal possible on their leases. Per the Pennsylvania School Code, districts are already required to provide transportation for students in parochial and private schools as well as charter schools.
Environmental Charter School doesn’t have “bells and whistles,” Mr. McCann said.
“We tend to avoid acres of AstroTurf and shiny things,” he said. “We don’t have that kind of money.”
When it was crafted, the Pennsylvania Charter School Law was meant to allow for the creation of schools that served as an extension for traditional public education, Mr. Livingston said. It was meant to save districts money and only handfuls of students — those interested in the very specific curricula charter schools are required to have — were expected to leave traditional public schools to attend charters.
Legislators likely didn’t expect so many families to move their children into charter schools, said Pennsylvania Auditor General Eugene DePasquale. He has been a vocal supporter of reforming Pennsylvania’s charter school law, which he has dubbed “the worst in the nation.” Among the issues he believes legislators didn’t anticipate in 1997 was the introduction of cyber charter schools, which many believe should be regulated separately from brick-and-mortar charter schools.
Cyber charter schools, which critics argue don’t have the same overhead costs for building and utilities as brick-and-mortars and therefore shouldn’t receive the same amount in per-student tuition, attract thousands of students from all over the state, data show. The Pennsylvania Department of Education acts as authorizer for the state’s 14 cyber charter schools.
Mr. DePasquale has also been critical of the Pennsylvania Department of Education’s over-payment of lease reimbursements to charter schools as well as the lack of a tiered funding system for special education students. Right now, critics say, a charter school can charge a school district the same elevated, special education tuition rate for a student who needs speech therapy, for example, as a student with a more severe disability that requires more attention.
Matthew Stem, deputy secretary for elementary and secondary education, said Gov. Tom Wolf has also expressed a desire to make updates to the charter school law, including revamping the formula for calculating tuition payments for special education students.
A new Charter Schools Division within the department will help the state “fulfill its role as and authorizer [for cyber charters] as well as monitor operations for all charters,” Mr. Stem said. That division will provide new resources to assist school districts with oversight of charter school operations — including how they make payments to them — and charter academic performance.
“We take our responsibility very seriously,” Mr. Stem said about the education department. “That’s why we are realigning our resources.”
But despite all the areas of the law that many agree need improvement, near-annual attempts at updating the charter school law don’t make it all the way through the state Legislature.
“It’s insane,” Mr. DePasquale said. “They still can’t get anything done.”
A bill from Rep. Mike Reese, R-Westmoreland, passed in the state House in April and calls for, among other things, the formation of a commission to study how to address funding concerns and inequities regarding payments to charter schools and cyber charter schools. According to Mr. Reese’s website, the proposal could save school districts about $27 million annually. The Pennsylvania School Boards Association wrote in a 2014 report that, “The net cost to districts for students attending charter schools increased from $434 million in 2006-07 to $1.145 billion [in] 2011-12.”
Districts like Clairton continue to struggle to make ends meet while lawmakers in Harrisburg hold meetings, Mr. Livingston said.
Charter schools frequently advertise to prospective families — something his district can’t afford to do. And charter schools can draw students — and money — from as many districts as they please. The Clairton City School District only can enroll students from within its small area, and it has to make do with the revenues it can generate in a community that makes a median household income of about $30,000, according to census data.
“All of Allegheny County is their school district,” Mr. Livingston said about charter schools. “It isn’t a level playing ground.”
Elizabeth Behrman: Lbehrman@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1590; Twitter @Ebehrman. Liz Navratil: lnavratil@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1438; Twitter @LizNavratil.
Correction (made June 25 at 12:33 p.m.): An earlier version of this story incorrectly stated Jeremy Resnick’s title. He is the executive director and a co-founder of Propel Charter Schools.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.