At a recent talent show at Quigley Catholic High School in Baden, four members of the school’s debate team performed a skit they’d written mocking the presidential debates — complete with border wall jokes and a female student’s Bernie Sanders impression.
Presidential debates, such as tonight’s Republican face-off in Miami, aren’t usually fodder for teenage entertainment. But this year — in which student debaters and their coaches have watched their serious craft play out in wild fashion on national television — isn’t any year.
“It’s amazing, to be honest with you,” said Thomas Belsterling, a senior and four-year member of Quigley Catholic’s speech and debate team, who “just stuck my lips out a lot and nodded my head up and down” to play Donald Trump in the skit.
In a high school debate competition, be the topic STEM education or tax codes or foreign policy, facts are king. “You can’t just go up there and make a claim,” he said. “You hear, ‘Where’s your statistic? Where’s your source? Don’t you think that’s a biased source?’”
For presidential candidates, however, it often seems like anything goes. The debates have grown into must-see TV for cable networks, with Republican debates drawing record ratings and CNN featuring a regular countdown until the next one. Though there is discussion of the issues, there is also name-calling, flagrant inattention to the rules and personal attacks.
In the most recent GOP debate, Donald Trump opened by defending the size of a piece of his anatomy in response to a dig by Sen. Marco Rubio, R-Fla., that Mr. Trump had small hands. Mr. Trump also has assigned nicknames to his rivals, such as “Little Marco” and “Lyin’ Ted” for Sen. Ted Cruz, R-Texas.
Read More
“It’s very frustrating as a high school debater to watch this,” said Kimberly DelSignore, a junior on the North Allegheny Senior High School team. “It’s easy for a lot of people who aren’t in the debate community to believe that there’s only one kind of debate — one person standing up there shouting.”
The debates this year have broken the mold for how these contests — both presidential and academic — usually work, said Calum Matheson, assistant professor of public deliberation and public life at the University of Pittsburgh and director of the William Pitt debating union. Both Mr. Trump and Democratic candidate Bernie Sanders have used the debates to emphasize their populist credentials in a manner not seen before in modern debating. “There are some parallels to populism in the early 20th century,” he said, “but there has not been a combination like this one of a publicly extremist debate. I can’t think of an example where millions have been exposed that has been as contentious.”
The more obvious techniques that have worked for the candidates bear little relation to high-level college debating, he said — and Mr. Matheson was a champion undergraduate debater at Michigan State and then a debate coach at Harvard University.
“There’s a lot of bravado that wouldn’t work in an academic debate, where the quality of the argument is more important,” he said. “Trump gets so much attention because what he’s doing is so unorthodox — he breaks all the rules, he’s rude to his opponents, he uses short, declarative sentences … It’s not traditionally good debate but it’s clearly working.”
For Tim Waxenfelter, the speech and debate coach at Quigley Catholic who can remember watching the 1956 convention on television when he was 9 years old, this election and debate cycle has been “confusing.” At times, he said, it’s been easier for high school students to accept the candidates’ behavior than it has been for him.
“They’re not as turned off by it,” said Mr. Waxenfelter, who has coached debate for 30 years. “They’ve seen politics for a very short time. They can’t reach back in history. They don’t know what a Ronald Reagan looks like or what an Eisenhower looks like or John Kennedy.”
And while much of what his debate students see in the debates is negative, there are positive lessons. “They do carry out one thing that debaters are taught and they do it almost to a fault,” he said. “Reiterate your strong points and attack your opponent on his weak points.”
At North Allegheny, the students are also finding some positive lessons. “The candidates do a fantastic job of appealing to the emotional sense of the audience,” said senior Apoorv Anand.
“They speak in such a way that’s very consistent. They have good control of the crowd, what issues are brought up and what gets said when,” said senior Sid Narayan.
The high school students also recognize that all debates are not created equal. While they are trying to appeal to one judge, the presidential candidates are taking their message to the whole country.
“They are trying to achieve something fundamentally different than we are,” said senior Joe Zhao. “The task that they are faced with is one that is much larger and more complex.“
Anya Sostek: asostek@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1308.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.