Surprising even themselves, Donald Trump and his Republican rivals turned Thursday’s presidential debate into a civil and detailed discussion of Social Security, Islam, trade and immigration that left Mr. Trump to shake his head and declare at the midpoint: “So far, I can’t believe how civil it’s been up here.”
Trying to put a positive face on the open warfare among Republicans, the party’s national chairman assured the candidates debating in Miami that the party would get behind whomever is nominated — including insurgent front-runner Mr. Trump.
Republican chairman Reince Priebus, in an opening statement, seemed to urge those who strongly oppose Mr. Trump to think twice. “This party is going to support the nominee, whoever that is, 100 percent,” he said.
Those unity appeals seemed to carry over into the opening exchanges of the debate. Mr. Trump opened the debate with a none-too-subtle message for GOP forces to unite behind his candidacy, saying, “The Republican establishment should embrace what’s happening.” Mr. Trump then announced that one-time foe Ben Carson would endorse him today.
The candidates then found plenty of areas of common ground. And often when they differed, they laid out their differences in even tones and without vitriol.
“We’re all in this together,” said Mr. Trump, sounding more like a conciliator than a provocateur as he strives to unify the party behind his own candidacy. “We’re going to come up with solutions. We’re going to find the answer things.”
Read More
Not that it was all sweetness and light. Texas Sen. Ted Cruz, eager to cement his position as the party’s last best alternative to Mr. Trump, did have a firm counter to Mr. Trump, saying flatly at one point: “His solutions don’t work.”
In a meaty discussion of Social Security, Mr. Cruz and Marco Rubio said they’d gradually raise the retirement age for younger workers to help stabilize the system and stave off financial disaster for the system.
Mr. Trump, in contrast, said he’d do “everything within my power not to touch Social Security, to leave it the way it is.”
The billionaire businessman couldn’t resist taking a dig at the Democrats, saying he’d been watching them intensely on such issues —"even though it’s a very, very boring thing to watch” — and that they weren’t doing anything on Social Security.
Mr. Cruz said the system was “careening toward insolvency” and it would be irresponsible not to address that. Mr. Rubio said Mr. Trump’s plan to save the system by reducing payments wouldn’t work. Eliminating all fraud and waste “is not enough,” he said. “The numbers don’t add up.”
Mr. Rubio and Mr. Trump tangled over the proper United States posture toward followers of Islam.
Mr. Trump defended comments in a CNN interview where he said there is tremendous “hate” for the United States among Muslims.
Mr. Rubio countered that American Muslims “love America,” and that the U.S. will need healthy relations with Muslim nations to defeat the Islamic State extremist group.
Ohio Gov. John Kasich defended the majority of Muslims as being different than those who join radical terrorists groups, while also describing “radical Islam” as the greatest threat to the U.S. today.
Speaking on trade, Mr. Trump said that the U.S. has had “horrible negotiators, horrible trade deals.” But Mr. Cruz said that Mr. Trump’s plans would only boost the prices of consumer goods.
Mr. Cruz and Mr. Trump also sparring over whether Mr. Cruz changed his position on subsidies for renewable fuels while campaigning in Iowa, and over whether the Republican front-runner stands with Democrats Hillary Clinton and John Kerry over the nuclear deal in Iran.
Mr. Rubio opted not to attack Mr. Trump on immigration, despite recent news alleging his company denied pay to some foreign workers.
Mr. Kasich says he is a believer in immigration, and without it “I’d be running for president of Croatia.” But he also said he wants tough border control and a wall with Mexico.
Mr. Rubio also drew cheers from the Miami audience, which is home to a significant Cuban-American population, when he said he would require Cuba to commit to specific terms — including free elections, free press, and to stop throwing dissidents in jail — in order to normalize relations.
Each of the candidates had an urgent mission as the GOP debate gave them a last chance to put their case to a televised audience of millions before voters in Florida and four other states dish out delegates next Tuesday. Those elections will go a long way toward determining the outcome of the primary season.
Mr. Cruz was seeking to make it a two-man race with Mr. Trump. Mr. Rubio was out to save his flagging candidacy by energizing voters in his home state of Florida. Mr. Kasich was hoping his above-the-fray strategy would finally pay off.
Mr. Trump, for his part, was itching to give his front-runner’s campaign a giant thrust toward the nomination by dominating his dwindling cast of rivals.
Mr. Priebus said in advance he was hoping for a more “G-rated debate” than the last Republican face-off, a week ago, when the candidates engaged in a two-hour brawl that featured shouting, insults and even sexual innuendo.
Mr. Trump told CNBC on Thursday that the imperative to win the GOP nomination had made him “not necessarily as politically correct and even as nice as you would like to be as a person.”
Earlier in the week, he’d pledged a “softer” debate in Miami, but he also made his vow to finish what he’d begun.
The candidates split down the middle — Mr. Trump and Mr. Cruz vs. Mr. Rubio and Mr. Kasich — on the likelihood and implications of the GOP race coming down to a brokered Republican convention this summer.
“I think I’m going to have the delegates, OK?” Mr. Trump said.
As for who has a realistic chance of winning the nomination, Mr. Trump simply wrote off Mr. Rubio and Mr. Kasich, saying, “There are two of us that can, and there are two of us that cannot, OK?”
Mr. Cruz heartily agreed with Mr. Trump on that.
Mr. Rubio countered that disappointing “delegate math” aside, he’d keep on fighting.
Mr. Kasich, for his part, said it wouldn’t be so bad to have a contested convention. He added there are plenty of primaries left, so “let’s not get ahead of ourselves.”
Mr. Trump’s rivals, in a desperate scramble to halt his march to the nomination, gradually ramped up their criticism as the night wore on.
Mr. Rubio’s overarching message: “I know that a lot of people find appeal in the things Donald says. The problem is presidents can’t just say anything they want because it has consequences around the world.”
While Mr. Trump talked about showing a softer side, some of his rallies have had a harder edge, with the candidate at times seeming to encourage physical altercations with protesters. At a rally in Las Vegas, for example, he said he’d like to punch a protester in the face. On Wednesday, a man was charged with assault for attacking a protester who was being escorted out of a Trump rally in Fayetteville, N.C. And a Breitbart News reporter has alleged that Mr. Trump’s campaign manager physically pulled her away from the candidate after a news conference earlier this week.
Mr. Rubio, Mr. Trump’s chief antagonist, has been rethinking his own tone.
After mocking the billionaire businessman on everything from a bad spray tan to his spelling to his “small hands,” the Florida senator admitted to having regrets.
“My kids were embarrassed by it, and if I had to do it again, I wouldn’t,” he said.
Florida is the biggest prize of Tuesday’s five-state round of voting, and all 99 of the state’s delegates will go to the winner.
In all, 367 Republican delegates will be at stake, with voting also occurring in Illinois, Missouri, North Carolina, Ohio and the Northern Mariana Islands.
Earlier Thursday, Mr. Cruz showcased his first Senate endorsement, from Mike Lee of Utah, a Tea Party favorite. Mr. Cruz has few friends among the GOP in the Senate.
As Mr. Rubio’s fortunes declined this past week, Sens. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina and Dean Heller of Nevada raised the possibility of Mr. Cruz as the alternative, but others stood firm in their support for Mr. Rubio and declined to even discuss the prospect of Mr. Cruz as their choice.
Mr. Kasich, who has tried to stay out of the name-calling, pinned his hopes of survival on bringing home the 66 delegates in his state’s winner-take-all primary. He has yet to win anywhere.
In the race for delegates, Mr. Trump has 459, Mr. Cruz 360, Mr. Rubio 152 and Mr. Kasich 54. It takes 1,237 to win the Republican nomination for president.
As if Republicans aren’t having enough problems, several new polls indicate an additional one — an upswing in the public standing of President Barack Obama.
The popularity of the incumbent president often has had a measurable effect on how elections turn out. If Americans have a more favorable image of the current occupant of the Oval Office, they’re seen as more likely to keep his party in power.
Bloomberg News and Tribune News Service contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.