When it comes to the rigor of its expectations for students in grades 4 and 8, Pennsylvania falls short on the federal tests known as the Nation’s Report Card.
According to a study released today by the National Center for Education Statistics, math and reading proficiency levels for fourth- and eighth-graders in Pennsylvania are below those in most states and at the federal level.
Gary Phillips, the vice president of the American Institutes for Research, said in a conference call that expectations for eighth-graders in some low-standard states were similar to those for fourth-graders in high-standard states.
“States are setting wildly different standards, and in many cases, very low standards,” Mr. Phillips said. “It’s important for the [National Assessment of Educational Progress] to stay the course and retain its role as an independent monitor.”
National Center for Education researchers reached their conclusions by comparing state proficiency standards to federal ones. Almost all states administer standardized exams in math and reading to students in grades 4 and 8, with states setting their own benchmarks for what level of performance constitutes “advanced,” “proficient,” “basic” or “below basic” on each test.
Since both the tests and the benchmarks for achievement are different, it is difficult to compare states.
Read More
In each state, however, a randomly selected, representative sample of students in grades 4 and 8 also takes the National Assessment of Educational Progress, which measures skills in reading and math and is widely regarded as the gold standard in school testing.
Overseen by the U.S. Department of Education’s National Assessment Governing Board, the National Assessment tends to set higher benchmarks for performance than many state tests.
Every state, with the exception of New York, established proficiency standards below the National Assessment’s threshold. But some did better than others. Massachusetts, North Carolina, Texas and Wisconsin set expectations in at least one of the testing categories that measured up to the federal standards.
Pennsylvania did not do well in the state rankings of rigor, adopting on all of its exams benchmarks for proficiency that would lie in the “basic” range on the federal assessments. In some states, the proficiency levels fell into what would have been a “below basic” level on the National Assessment.
In three of four of the testing categories, Pennsylvania set expectations for “proficient” achievement that rated below the majority of states. Only in fourth-grade reading did it establish benchmarks that were deemed more rigorous than the majority.
Researchers based their findings on testing data from 2013, when the state had not yet fully implemented its new education standards, called the Pennsylvania Core.
The Pennsylvania Core includes certain elements from the Common Core State Standards, which were released in 2010 and are an initiative to set more uniform expectations across the country for reading and math achievement in each grade. Pennsylvania’s tests didn’t fully reflect the Pennsylvania Core until spring this year.
Presenting the report’s findings in a conference call, researchers noted that states with Common Core-aligned standards — New York and North Carolina, for example — tended to set higher expectations than those that had not already adopted them.
Daniel Solomon: dsolomon@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1586.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.