It started as a normal school day in May, one of the last of the 2013-14 school year.

Allen Carter, 14, gave his mom a hug and a kiss before he caught the bus to Woodland Hills Junior High School in Swissvale from his home in Turtle Creek.

By the afternoon, the seventh-grader was at Shuman Juvenile Detention Center.

He wouldn’t be a student again at a traditional public school for more than a year, despite his good performance a Rankin Promise, the alternative program he attended. His case mirrors that of students from across the district trapped in an alternative education system that’s proven difficult to leave.  

Advertise with us

Now Allen is looking forward to going to a regular school — Woodland Hills High School — this fall. At the same time, district superintendent Alan Johnson and a team of faculty, staff and administrators are implementing a plan to turn around the troubled Rankin Promise program he’s leaving behind.

The district mandated his enrollment at Rankin, a program for students with emotional and behavioral issues in grades 1-12, after he verbally threatened a classmate. His mother Jeannine Lawson, 31, said the incident happened after a school year of bullying by the classmate finally reached a boiling point. He was sent to Shuman for the next 11 days before being transferred to the Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, where he remained for the summer.

Meanwhile, Ms. Lawson began to meet with district officials and eventually the school board over disciplinary actions against him.

"It's just crazy how quickly things got so far out of control, and people got so far removed from the fact that he's a child, a child who is sick,” Ms. Lawson said. “I think they saw him as a criminal.”

Mr. Johnson said he couldn't speak in detail about Allen’s disciplinary case but there “may have been a reason he was kept there longer.”

Advertise with us

While the district recommends that students transition out of Rankin Promise in 45 days, records for 2013-14 show a length of stay ranging from seven days to 987 days. Students who left during the school year had an average of more than 230 enrolled days in the program.

In 2014-15, Rankin Promise saw one of its highest enrollment numbers to date with more than 200 students in the building. Mr. Johnson said students were being rushed into the program by administrators from their sending schools but weren’t leaving in 45 days, stretching the building’s limited resources and reducing the amount of individual attention students received.

“We had kids literally being dropped off at the doorstep, and Rankin started to become that very thing that I didn’t want to see,” Mr. Johnson said. “We don’t want students spending year after year here. We’re trying to be much more focused on intervening and mediating than just housing students there.”

The program was created in 2009 and was housed at the high school before moving to the former Rankin Elementary School in 2012, the same year Mr. Johnson was appointed as substitute superintendent.

“I wanted to do something different,” Mr. Johnson said. “If we were going to do it, we were going to do it better in a way that actually helps the kids.”

Advertise with us

The intake process includes a contract to be signed by the student and a parent or guardian outlining expectations for behavior, academics and attendance. Referral out of the program is supposed to be largely dependent upon adherence to the contract. Instead, Mr. Johnson said in many instances sending schools didn’t want to take students back because they were concerned about ongoing behavioral issues, even after students technically met terms and conditions of the contract, lengthening students’ stay.

“The system broke down,” he said. “I’d rather close it than have it be that way.”

When Allen reached his 45-day mark in the program, his mother appealed to school administrators for him to be reviewed for a transfer back to the junior high.

Craig Jackson, who was hired after assistant principal Lamont Lyons resigned in February, said he didn’t know what prolonged Allen’s stay but said, “He’s a wonderful student and I wish that we could keep him here to use him as a role model for other students.”

Emails were sent, Ms. Lawson was told. Phone calls and inquiries were made on Allen’s behalf. Yet, at the end of the semester, he had reached 90 days enrolled at Rankin without word of a transfer. That was when Allen determined the remainder of his eighth-grade year likely would be spent at Rankin.

Advertise with us

“I almost cried,” Allen said. “[My teachers] told me I was a good kid. They told me they didn’t understand why I was still there.”

The strict, austere setting, with students escorted from class to class, multiple classroom disruptions and minimal extracurricular activities and programs was a “culture shock” for Allen, his mother said.

“In a mainstream schooling setting...there’s a certain level of desire to achieve and accomplish [and] at Rankin he didn’t have that,” she said.

The district has submitted an application to the state Department of Education to turn Rankin Promise into a separate school with a full-time principal and staff. The program has operated under the supervision of the high school administration, with the high school principal also serving as principal of Rankin Promise.

The building will fall under the new leadership of Janet Carter, former Edgewood Elementary School principal. A redesigned system will require a thorough review for students after 45 days in the program. A team of parents, teachers and administrators may decide to extend the student’s stay, depending on the student’s success. Requests for a longer stay for a student will then be approved by the Rankin principal, special education director or the superintendent.

Advertise with us

All students who were still enrolled in the building in June will undergo a re-evaluation this summer to determine if they will go back to their sending schools in the fall.

Despite his success in the program, Allen also ended his school year uncertain whether he would have to return. Dressed in a white tuxedo shirt, bow tie, vest and slacks, Allen accepted his “Wolverine Spirit Award” during a May board meeting for “social and academic excellence” during his year at Rankin Promise. He was the only student from Rankin Promise to receive the monthly award given to students from across the district for the 2014-15 school year.

“He meets all of the qualifications as far as the academics,” Mr. Jackson said in his introduction of “one of his best students.” “He’s never late. His attendance is perfect, and [he’s had] no discipline. None...He serves as an example to our other kids there.”

It would be another month before he received confirmation from administrators that he could go to the high school this fall.

“I feel like I lost my son that day [last May],” Ms. Lawson said. “In spite of the obstacles he faced while at Rankin, he has slowly come around. But he’s not there yet.”

Advertise with us

When asked about the biggest lesson learned from his year at Rankin, Allen said simply: “I never want to go back.”

Clarece Polke: cpolke@post-gazette.com