The word “equity” is getting a lot of attention in education lately.

The state last week sent its plan for “ensuring equitable access to excellent teachers for all students” to the U.S. Department of Education.

The Education Law Center in Newark, N.J., which advocates for equal education opportunity, and The Leadership Conference Education Fund in Washington, D.C., which promotes human and civil rights, teamed up to release two reports today on the need for fair school funding.

And, according to the law that established it, the bipartisan Basic Education Funding Commission in Pennsylvania is charged with reporting out by Wednesday on how the state can establish a fair school-funding formula.

Advertise with us

Of today’s reports, one by both groups is called “Cheating Our Future: How Decades of Disinvestment by States Jeopardizes Equal Educational Opportunity.” The other is the fourth annual national report card by the Education Law Center on the fairness of school funding.

The Education Law Center’s report buttresses supporters’ call for a change in the way education dollars are allocated. Counting both state and local public school spending, Pennsylvania gets a letter grade of A for effort in 2010, 2011 and 2012.

But when the way those dollars are distributed is considered, Pennsylvania ends up with grades of D in 2012 and 2010 and a grade of F in 2011.

That’s because poorer public schools got less money than wealthier schools. In 2012, for example, schools with the lowest amount of poverty averaged $14,588 per student while those with the highest amount of poverty averaged $13,285.

The report also identified Pennsylvania as one of seven states with more pupils per teacher in high-poverty districts than in low-poverty ones.

Advertise with us

The joint report highlighted per-pupil spending in Pennsylvania in 2012-13 as ranging from $8,700 per student to nearly $23,000, which amounts to a difference of $357,000 a year for a class of 25 students. It also said the state pays a smaller share of funding for schools — about 36 percent — than most other states. Local taxpayers pay a larger share.

The joint report noted inequities across the country, saying, “In a time of economic growth and rising state and federal revenue, we are leaving the nation’s most vulnerable public school children behind.”

The state plan on teachers is required by the federal government to say how the state will ensure that “poor and minority children are not taught at higher rates than other children by inexperienced, unqualified or out-of-field teachers.”

The plan submitted last week noted a number of shortcomings, including “inequity of financial resources.”

In 2011-12, the state said the difference in expenditures between high and low poverty districts, not counting most federal aid, was 33.5 percent. That’s the same figure the U.S. Department of Education used in March to determine that Pennsylvania’s school districts have the most inequitable spending for poor students in the nation.

Advertise with us

Another shortcoming noted in the state plan is that students in the state’s poorest and highest minority charter schools as well as in the Philadelphia School District are being taught by teachers who are not highly qualified. Highly qualified teachers have bachelor’s degrees, a state teaching certificate and demonstrate subject matter competency.

While the number of emergency certificates has fallen over a decade from about 5,000 to 872 in 2013-14, they typically are in core academic subjects and special education. Twenty-one principals in 2013-14 did not have the required credentials and were working under emergency permits, as were 49 school nurses and 19 guidance counselors.

The state plan said some schools had inconsistent leadership or high rates of turnover.

Based on October 2013 data, the average teacher turnover in school district buildings was 6.2 percent, while it was 4.91 percent for the wealthiest school buildings and 8 percent for the poorest.

For charter schools, the average teacher turnover was 18.77 percent, 10.84 percent in the wealthiest schools and 21.4 percent in the poorest.

Advertise with us

The state plan also said teacher preparation programs did not prepare teachers for the poorest and highest minority classrooms.

The state plan highlighted the change in administration, including Gov. Tom Wolf’s proposal for more state basic education funding.

Its suggestions to improve the distribution of teachers focus on human capital management; ongoing professional learning; teacher and principal preparation; and fiscal equity.

Education writer Eleanor Chute: echute@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1955.