Pittsburgh Mayor Bill Peduto today told the state Basic Education Funding Commission that any new state formula for school funding should ensure that no child receives less funding than currently allotted.

Mr. Peduto also told the panel that "any proposed formula should start with base cost, count students, add weight for those factors adversely affecting a student's chance of success and add weight for factors that affect a district's distribution of resources."

Mr. Peduto was among the speakers this morning at the legislatively created panel's 15th and final public hearing, conducted at the student union of the University of Pittsburgh.

The 15-member commission is expected to recommend to the General Assembly a new formula for distributing state funding for basic education to the state's 500 school districts. The proposal is expected in June.

Advertise with us

Mr. Peduto told the panel that the current funding system is broken and perpetuates inequality. He urged the panel to "develop comprehensive solutions that benefit every child."

He also said, "The state must look more closely at the relative wealth of each district and its ability to provide the resources students need in order to meet our academic standards."

He noted school funding is a shared responsibility among the state, school districts and municipalities "for the opportunities they need to succeed academically and be career ready."

Ira Weiss, solicitor for Pittsburgh Public Schools, told the panel that it should take into account certain "cost drivers." At the top of his list was charter schools, on which the district expects to spend $52.1 percent or 9 percent of its budget this calendar year.

"Charters impact urban districts with high poverty populations disproportionately. We believe perceptions of choice and safety drive this shift to charters by parents to the economic detriment of such districts," he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Weiss also cited special education costs, noting 16 percent of the district's students are in special education and the district provides three centers for students with complex needs. He said the district spends $107.6 million a year on the core special education program.

"There is no coincidence that high poverty and a high special-needs population go together," he said.

He also cited the costs of transportation for nonpublic school students, providing instruction for English language learners and pensions.

He noted that funding from foundations has helped the district to offer special programs, such as the Summer Dreamers program.

"Without proper state funding, districts like Pittsburgh have to rely on the kindness of strangers, the philanthropic community to maintain its level of education," he said.

Advertise with us

Other speakers scheduled today include Ron Joseph, chief operating officer of Pittsburgh Public Schools; Harold Grant, parliamentarian and staff representative for the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers; and Carey Harris, executive director of A+ Schools. Pittsburgh superintendent Linda Lane was present today but spoke at a hearing in Lancaster last fall.

Mr. Grant highlighted the high poverty rates in Pittsburgh, noting 45 percent of all black children under age 18 live in households below the poverty line and 71 percent of the district's students qualify for free or reduced lunch. He also noted that Pennsylvania ranks in the bottom among states in equitable distribution of school funding.

"In order to reduce the equity gap in spending between our poorest and wealthiest districts, Pennsylvania needs a fair funding formula that relies on accurate, reliable, verifiable and current school and community data," Mr. Grant said.

"The formula should direct more funding to districts and students with the greatest need by addressing student factors like poverty, English proficiency and enrollment, as well as district factors like local tax effort, sparsity and the impact of charter schools. All districts should receive minimum funding increases while the new formula is being implemented."

Ms. Harris told the panel, "There is no doubt that our public education system is dramatically underfunded in many parts of the commonwealth."

Advertise with us

She said Pittsburgh has some "unique characteristics," including high poverty and a high percentage off students receiving county social services. She said the many choices offered in the district push up transportation costs.

Education writer Eleanor Chute: echute@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1955.