If Woodland Hills Superintendent Alan Johnson succeeds, the school district won’t make another national list of the 10 districts with the highest out-of-school suspension rates of elementary school students.

A week ago, The Center for Civil Rights Remedies at UCLA issued a report saying that the Woodland Hills rate of 23.8 percent of elementary students suspended out of school one or more times during 2011-12. The national average is 2.6 percent, and the state average is 2.0 percent.

The report — “Are We Closing the School Discipline Gap?” — also showed racial disparities in Woodland Hills, with 30.2 percent of elementary black students and 8.51 percent of elementary white students suspended one or more times. A student who is suspended more than once counted only once in the report.

Woodland Hills has been trying to reduce its suspension numbers and the national report prompted Mr. Johnson to ask staff to compute the most recent rate to see how much progress has been made.

Advertise with us

The district’s 2013-14 rate shows that 16.48 percent of elementary students were suspended one or more times, a drop of more than 7 percentage points from 2011-12. Racial disparities remained, although rates had dropped to 22.93 percent of black students and 7.23 percent of white students.

While he said the numbers aren’t down “nearly enough” and expressed concern over the disparities, Mr. Johnson said, “We’re trying to change the culture. I think we’re starting to be successful.”

About 65 percent of the students in the district are black. Elementary school enrollment is about 2,200.

Mr. Johnson believes one initiative that has made a difference is the opening in 2012-13 of the Rankin Promise, which is an alternative program for students in grades 4-12. Previously, the district had an alternative program only for grades 7-12. About 120 attend Rankin, including 25 or 30 in grades 4-6. Their suspension numbers are included in their home schools.

He said the Rankin Promise has resources to address behavior concerns, including time-out rooms, therapeutic classrooms, a psychologist and a behavior interventionist. He said the regular elementary schools, which serve K-6, do not have enough resources.

Advertise with us

If a child is acting inappropriately in the alternative program, he said, “We don’t have to automatically suspend.” Instead, the specialists can work with the child and try to develop a plan to keep the student in the classroom.

He said the district also has done professional development to help staff better understand a range of socioeconomic situations. Given many students come from low socioeconomic backgrounds, he said most teachers and administrators — including himself — have participated in a day-long “poverty simulator” to help them better understand students.

He said he also uses the “bully pulpit,” adding, “Every year on the opening day, I stress the need to build personal relationships with kids.”

He said the district also is trying to improve instruction, including a school realignment plan that puts grades 4, 5 and 6 in one building and uses STEAM — science, technology, engineering, arts and math — to try to better engage students.

Mr. Johnson noted that some districts have banned or severely restricted suspensions, but he said, “I could send out a directive this afternoon: Thou shalt not suspend any more students in grades K-3. I don’t want to do that.”

Advertise with us

He said such an edict might improve numbers but wouldn’t improve the school environment.

The issue of school suspensions is attracting attention cross the nation. A year ago, the U.S. Departments of Justice and Education issued guidance on school discipline, calling on schools to examine their policies and practices and eliminate disparities.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania last week updated its 2013 report called, “Beyond Zero Tolerance.” The online version, available at www.aclupa.org, includes links to the latest research as well as resources for parents, students, educators, administrators and advocates.

Harold Jordan, senior policy advocate for the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania, said it is critical for school districts to take a close look at why students are suspended and to look for patterns.

He said research shows that black students tend to be suspended at higher levels for offenses that are subjectively measured, such as disrespect, while white students tend to be suspended for offenses that are objectively measured, such as smoking.

Advertise with us

“We’re not in favor of disorderly schools,” Mr. Jordan said. “We’re saying what’s happening now is not fair to people, and it’s not working and it has dramatically negative social consequences, especially kids becoming disengaged with school.”

Mr. Johnson said school suspensions create a “vicious cycle” in which suspended students fall behind academically, get frustrated, act out and get suspended again.

In working to reduce the number of suspensions, Mr. Jordan said, “the goal is to create a better school climate for everybody.”