The Fairness Center, a public interest law firm based in Harrisburg, has filed a lawsuit claiming the Philadelphia School District has more than 20 so-called “ghost teachers” on unlimited leaves of absence from the district to work full-time for the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers while the district scrambles to fill 89 teaching vacancies.
These teachers are considered public employees under the law, although the union reimburses the district in full for all of their salary and benefit costs. Still, the teachers legally receive pension benefits from the Pennsylvania School Employees Retirement System, despite many having been absent from the classroom for more than 15 years.
While the suit was filed only against the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers also employs three full-time union employees listed on district payroll.
“The [Philadelphia] union and the district have gone beyond the authority provided to them in the Public Employee Relations Act. They've bargained for the use of public employees to do private work ...” said David Osborne, general counsel for the Fairness Center.
Mr. Osborne said “the first assumption” the suit is challenging is that the union officials remain public employees. The suit calls for the elimination of a provision in the collective bargaining agreement between the district and the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers that allows teachers working full-time for the union, but still on the district payroll, to continue accruing seniority and pension benefits.
The suit also contends the contract fails to establish a method of reimbursement from the union to the district for the union workers’ salaries.
Read More
Although not required in the contract, Mr. Osborne said that the Fairness Center has found the union is reimbursing the district for the full-time union workers’ salaries and health benefits. He maintains the district’s documentation of the reimbursement is incomplete.
“There are no institutional controls governing how long they’re allowed to leave, what those people do and no requirement that they reimburse,” said Mr. Osborne. “One of the major shortcomings that this whole episode brings up is the lack of control that the district has over its finances.
“The lack of the reimbursement mechanism is just one of the examples of how the district isn’t doing the best it can.”
George Jackson, a spokesman for the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers, called this aspect of the lawsuit a “non-issue,” as the district is already doing, and has always done, what the Fairness Center wants written into the contract.
Of the provision in the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers’ contract with the school district outlining union employees’ pay and activities, Mr. Osborne said, “It’s not a perfect provision but it’s far more responsible than the provision in the Philadelphia contract.”
The Pittsburgh contract is “less egregious,” according to Mr. Osborne, because it contains “enhanced institutional controls” through which it establishes the method for reimbursing the district that Philadelphia’s does not, stating that “the Federation shall reimburse the Board in full for all salary costs, benefit costs, and employer costs incurred by the board in releasing teachers from duty.”
In addition, the local contract requires that union workers reapply for leave once a year, while the Philadelphia contract has no such limits.
One provision of the local contract is similar to Philadelphia’s: Full-time union workers continue to accumulate credit toward their pensions.
According to Mr. Osborne, allowing full-time union employees to continue to accrue this credit while away from the classroom supports private work.
Though the lawsuit does not directly challenge the state’s contribution to union employees’ pensions, Mr. Osborne sees it as relevant since the reclassification of the union employees as private employees would discontinue the payments.
Full-time union employees continue to accrue seniority in both contracts as well.
Philadelphia and Pittsburgh base layoffs on certification and seniority, so seniority is critical when job cuts are being made.
Nina Esposito-Visgitis, president of the Pittsburgh Federation of Teachers, worked as a speech language specialist in the district for 21 years and is covered by the same contract as district teachers, but her 13 years on leave for the union count toward her district seniority, giving her a total of 34 years seniority.
“It’s not fair that a teacher who spent the last decade in the classroom should be laid off before these ghost teachers,” said Mr. Osborne.
Ms. Esposito-Visgitis maintains that her seniority has been earned. “I continue to accrue system seniority because I have been in service to our district, our teachers and our students for 34 years,” she said.
She provided a long list of actions the union has taken that have benefited the district, including participation in developing the RISE teacher evaluation system and a $40 million grant from the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
Ms. Esposito-Visgitis said that “frivolous lawsuits” like Mr. Osborne’s distract from the work in public education that should be prioritized.
“It saddens me that there is an organized, continued attack against unions across our state. It makes me sad and it makes me angry,” she said. “It takes me away from the work that we do for the kids.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.