A Shaler man will remain in federal custody while he awaits trial on 12 charges related to a string of violent comments left on YouTube videos earlier this year threatening to “do a mass shooting” targeting, among others, specific politicians, transgender individuals, and Democrats.
Other groups that 32-year-old Robert Hlovchiec allegedly made explicit threats against were Black and Hispanic people, Muslims and liberals, according to testimony Friday and court records unsealed last week.
U.S. Magistrate Judge Maureen P. Kelly, in explaining her decision to keep Hlovchiec in custody, read through the various threats he has alleged to have made in a span of days in late February and early March.
“…do a mass shooting.”
“…kill someone in a heartbeat.”
“…tracking someone to kill them and their family.”
“… put a bullet in the head of any Democrat.”
Kelly said the affirmative nature of the comments meant she couldn’t justify letting Hlovchiec back into the community pending trial.
“The evidence I have before me is not just someone mouthing off online about their personal views, but it is you threatening people and you inciting and encouraging others,” she said. “And [then] you doing research about killers — and not just one: one after another after another after another.”
Those that Hlovchiec allegedly researched included mass shooters, serial killers, and Joden Rocco, who stabbed a Black man to death on Pittsburgh’s North Shore in 2018. Evidence presented in court indicated that Rocco had made a string of racist remarks in the hours leading up to the fatal encounter.
FBI Special Agent Briana Stone testified that the investigation began after a referral from Google citing Hlovchiec’s YouTube comments as cause for belief “that there currently exists an emergency involving death or serious bodily injury to a person or persons.”
Stone said that in the months before the FBI became involved, Shaler police had twice gone to the Hlovchiec home after they were alerted to threatening social media posts.
The remark that sparked a visit by police, Stone said, indicated Hlovchiec’s desire to “do a mass shooting” against Hispanics for “poisoning America with fentanyl” and against liberals “for supporting it.” Stone said the post ended with “I promise.”
The 12-count indictment was filed July 7 and unsealed after Hlovchiec was taken into custody two days later. Though court records do not name the politicians Hlovchiec threatened, testimony in court indicated the threats were against U.S. Rep. Ilhan Omar, a Minnesota Democrat, and New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani. Both politicians are Muslim.
Federal public defender Liz Patton had argued that Hlovchiec never actually took any of the actions he threatened, nor did he have any access to firearms. She asked for him to be released to an in-patient treatment facility and then to his Shaler home where he lived with his parents. Patton said she was ready to agree to a complete restriction on internet access for her client and for his father to be named his legal custodian.
Hlovchiec’s father, Robert J. Hlovchiec, told the judge that the extent of his son’s struggles were clear to him now. A former corrections officer, he said he would “be over [his son] like a cop.” He and Patton both said they believe the younger man suffers from addiction to alcohol and marijuana and needs mental health treatment.
He said that after a second visit from Shaler police, he began to think his son’s situation could be serious.
“I dropped the ball,” he said, before the judge interjected: “You’re not a trained mental health professional or addiction professional or behavior specialist,” Kelly said. “So don’t be so hard on yourself.”
Kelly said the fact Hlovchiec had the support of his family weighed in his favor when she was deliberating whether he had remained jailed. In the end, she said, there was too much evidence weighing against him.
“There’s nothing to preclude you from walking out of [in-patient treatment],” she said. “There’s nothing to preclude you from taking your parents’ car and going and taking violent action.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.