Authorities as early as July 1999 believed they had likely found Genelle Bradford, the 17-year-old high school senior missing from Wilkinsburg.
The body found in the basement of 604 North Ave. was that of a young Black woman. The clothing she was wearing was similar to that which witnesses said Genelle was last seen wearing when she disappeared two months prior. The North Avenue home was midway between the teen’s part-time job at what was then the YWCA on Ross Avenue and the Holmes Avenue home where she lived with her grandparents.
“There was an extensive investigation, in fact, and her name surfaced very early on,” said Allegheny County homicide Detective Kevin McCool.
He was not the original detective on either case — the missing person case of Genelle and the homicide investigation into the then-unidentified body — but said there were several young women reported missing out of Wilkinsburg at the time.
“It wasn’t like there was just one and it was obvious,” he said. “But her proximity to the house where the remains were found and just the overall circumstances of that residence and the area led our detectives pretty quickly to her being mostly like who the remains were.”
Investigators said at a news conference Wednesday, a day after they announced Genelle was the young woman found dead in June 1999, that a combination of the DNA samples and the technology of the time left authorities of the era unable to conclusively make the match.
Read More
Genelle was two weeks short of her 18th birthday and just a few months shy of graduating from high school when she disappeared on her way home from work April 27, 1999. Two months later on June 28, 1999, a man renovating the abandoned home he had bought the month prior discovered a young woman’s body inside the basement, which was nailed shut from the inside. She was at the bottom of a set of steps that led from the backyard to the storm cellar, the Post-Gazette reported at the time. Duct tape was wrapped around her neck.
McCool said Genelle was never ruled out as a potential ID for the unidentified woman.
“To the contrary, she’s remained basically who we thought it was since June or maybe July of 1999,” he said.
Police at the time tried fingerprints to no avail, and a facial reconstruction drawing also didn’t lead to any results. The case lingered between an unidentified remains investigation and an open homicide investigation, McCool said, noting that investigators would likely not have gone to Genelle’s family unless they were certain of the identification.
“If it were now … we would say, ‘We’re pretty sure this is your loved one, here’s what we’re doing,’ ” he said. “I don’t know what conversations they had back then and with whom, and I don’t know what family [members] were involved back then.”
Genelle’s case now turns toward continuing the homicide investigation police began in 1999.
McCool said investigators “have a couple suspects that we’re interested in,” including at least one person who was known to frequent the abandoned house. Some of the stumbling blocks remain the same, including the transient nature of some of the people going in and out of the abandoned home.
“We couldn’t find them then, it’s even harder to find them now,” McCool said. “A case of this age is always difficult.”
But time can also be a friend, he said: “Allegiances change — somebody may know something who was close to a perpetrator 20 years ago, 25 years ago, and now they’re no longer friends, they no longer have a reason to protect [a suspect].”
If the perpetrator has since died, the detective said, someone might feel safe finally coming forward.
“That’s our hope with a lot of these unsolved cases,” he said.
Traditional DNA testing vs. genealogical testing
It remained unclear what, exactly, the hindrance was regarding DNA testing in 1999, but Mandy Tinkey, director of forensic services at the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office, said it came down to the fact investigators “were unable to confirm any of the biological connection for who she actually was.”
It took advanced, proprietary testing from the Texas-based Othram Labs to definitively link Genelle to the body in the basement.
“[With] the type of analysis that was done at the time, we were not able to do any genealogy work based on those types of [DNA] profiles,” Tinkey said. “This new opportunity did provide us more of a genealogical approach to see more connections to our decedent.”
Othram, a private lab, specializes in rebuilding usable DNA from small, old or degraded samples and then uses it to find potential relatives of the unknown person. It then combs through DNA samples uploaded to specific websites by consumers who use commercial tests to look for family members.
“The technology utilized in forensic genetic genealogy is very different than typical nuclear or mitochondrial DNA analysis,” Tinkey said. “So [Othram’s testing technique] having been available now and not at the time is what changed.”
It is the second time the partnership with Othram, which started in 2024 through grant money from the state, has paid off for Allegheny County investigators.
In February, a murder victim who had remained unidentified since 1992 was identified as 52-year-old Allan Keener, who last lived in Bridgeport, Ohio. That case was unique in that a man was arrested, prosecuted and imprisoned in connection with Keener’s death, although Keener remained unidentified throughout.
Tinkey said the medical examiner’s office could start using Othram’s testing on more current cases, too.
“Now we are also moving forward, since the technology exists, to not have to wait all these years to utilize it,” she said. “Now we know it’s there, we know it’s successful, and we can explore those options a lot faster.”
Forensic genetic genealogy differs from traditional DNA testing in that the latter searches only for an exact match. For example, if criminal investigators collect a DNA sample from a crime scene, they’re generally limited to government databases to search. For someone’s DNA to be in a government database, that person usually has to have been arrested and had DNA taken.
Traditional testing, too, looks at only a small portion of DNA. If the sample is too small, too old or too degraded, testing isn’t an option.
Specialized labs like Othram are able to rebuild DNA sequences from miniscule or broken samples. Then, rather than give results only if there’s an exact match, the labs use specialized software and artificial intelligence to comb through DNA samples uploaded via commercial testing websites for similar projects — that is, for samples that could represent relatives.
Individuals who complete DNA testing through companies such as Ancestry and 23andMe are able to upload their own DNA profile to other sites that allow them to look for relatives. Only two of those databases allow law enforcement to access them: GEDmatch and FamilyTreeDNA, and users have to opt-in to allow law enforcement access to their DNA profiles.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.