Fresh off its first successful identification of a John Doe using genetic genealogy, the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office is hopeful the technology — and grant money funding the expensive process — can continue to help give names back to the county’s nameless.

Early this year, the office identified Allan Keener, solving the oldest such case on the county’s docket. That case was an outlier in that, while the killer had been tried and convicted, Mr. Keener had remained an unknown for nearly 34 years following his 1992 murder.

The office, through a grant from the state, worked with a private lab that specializes in rebuilding usable DNA from small, old or degraded samples and uses it to find potential relatives of the unknown person. It then combs through DNA samples uploaded to specific websites by consumers who use commercial tests to look for family members.

Lab director Mandy Tinkey, who joined the medical examiner’s office in 2003, said the advances in technology mean cases could be solved in which all other avenues had been exhausted.

Advertise with us

She said advances in technology since 1992, when Mr. Kenner was killed, are incredible.

“Even if we were looking at this case in 2003, this [technology] wasn’t even something that was imagined to be possible,” she said.

With Mr. Keener now identified, there are 10 cases of unidentified people in Allegheny County, according to the National Missing and Unidentified Persons System.

Some are considered homicides, some aren’t.

Ms. Tinkey said all are cases in which other platforms failed to pan out — things such as fingerprints, dental records or traditional DNA testing. Not all of the cases are suitable for this type of advanced testing, she said — in at least one, there’s not enough to generate a DNA profile even with the new technology.

Advertise with us

“That case, we can either wait [for technological advancements] or go in another direction,” she said.

Mandy Tinkey, front center, lab director for the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office and her team in lab on Thursday March 12, 2026. Left to right, Jeff Veltre, Mandy Tinkey, Dan Giannettino, Lauren Karran and Hannah Skropits. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

For those cases that can be run through private lab Othram’s technology, Ms. Tinkey hopes the office can bring closure to families who simply don’t know what happened to their loved ones. It’s not necessarily happy news, she said, but in Mr. Keener’s case, it felt good to be able to finally offer his family the information.

“Over the years when all of the steps we have to try to pursue an identification is done, you’re like kind of thinking, ‘That’s all I can do,’” she said.

‘It’s possible to solve all cold cases’

The idea of investigative genetic genealogy is still working its way into everyday law enforcement, though it’s been a part of true crime parlance since it made its first major headlines.

In 2018, investigators made an arrest in the five-decade-old case of a serial killer dubbed the Golden State Killer. The suspect — who went unidentified for half a century — had been linked to at least 13 murders and 45 rapes in the 1970s and 1980s.

Advertise with us

DNA in that case turned up only distant cousins of the prolific serial killer, and genetic genealogists worked backward to find shared relatives, ultimately landing on Joseph DeAngelo. A sample of his DNA was matched to samples collected decades earlier in the Golden State Killer cases. He pleaded guilty shortly after his arrest and is serving a life sentence.

The technology has again made mainstream headlines in the case of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of “Today” show host Savannah Guthrie who disappeared from her Arizona home in late January.

Authorities have said they believe she was kidnapped or otherwise forced from her home outside Tucson by a masked man caught on her doorbell camera, and investigators have said they’re using genetic genealogy to try to identify a suspect.

“It’s possible to solve all of the cold cases that have DNA associated with them,” said David Gurney, director of the Investigative Genetic Genealogy Center at Ramapo College in New Jersey.

“For active cases, it should be nearly impossible for someone to commit serial murder or rape at this point,” he said.

Advertise with us

How it works

The type of DNA profiling done by labs such as Othram casts a much wider net than what is usually considered traditional DNA testing.

When criminal investigators have a DNA sample, they’re generally limited to comparing it to government databases. That means to find a match, a person has to have been arrested and had DNA taken. The government databases — namely the Combined DNA Index System, or CODIS — can only give investigators an exact match.

That’s what has happened so far in the Nancy Guthrie case, and it’s why investigators are turning to the specialized technology for help: Gloves believed to be worn by the suspect were found a few miles from Ms. Guthrie’s home and, while DNA was found inside, there were no matches in CODIS.

Traditional testing, too, looks only at a small portion of DNA. If it’s too degraded or too old or there’s just too little of it, such testing is out of the question.

Labs that specialize in rebuilding DNA sequences can do so with even minute or broken samples.

Advertise with us

Rather than give results only if there’s an exact match, the labs use specialized software and artificial intelligence to comb through samples uploaded via commercial testing websites for similar profiles — that is, for samples that could represent relatives.

Individuals who complete DNA testing through companies such as Ancestry and 23andMe are able to upload their own DNA profile to other sites that allow them to look for relatives. Only two of those databases allow law enforcement to access them: GEDmatch and FamilyTreeDNA, and users have to opt-in to allowing law enforcement access to their DNA profiles.

From there, it’s generally down to legwork by genealogists. They use the potential relatives returned by the testing to build out a family tree.

“As long as we can develop a genetic profile and upload [it], we can figure out where that person fits into a broader family tree,” Mr. Gurney said.

Sometimes it can be simple.

Advertise with us

In the case of Mr. Keener in Pittsburgh, Ms. Tinkey said, the results came back with a potential identification as well as a possible family tree. Further research confirmed the names of potential close relatives who were then contacted and agreed to submit their DNA.

Mr. Gurney’s team at the IGG Center — four full-time employees, four part-timers, and about 60 volunteers — have helped close about two dozen cases since 2023. They’re working on 11 other unidentified person cases. They don’t publicize what homicide cases they’re investigating.

“It’s the luck of the draw who has taken a DNA test,” he said. “I’ve had cases where we had a half-sibling [in the database].

“As long as there’s not an adoption there, it can be relatively quick to solve. Third or fourth cousins, if those are the closest matches, it’s trickier. We have to build back in the family tree and find common ancestors.”

One major wrench in the process has been the loss of access to records owned by Ancestry, the family tree-building research website.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gurney said the company updated its terms of service last year to prohibit the use of its historical records for investigative genetic genealogy purposes. Ancestry owns Newspapers.com, Fold3, which contains military records dating back to the Revolutionary War, and Find A Grave, a crowdsourced database of cemeteries and other burial sites.

Mr. Gurney said that means some cases might not be solvable because Ancestry holds the only digital records that could provide a missing link in a family tree.

He called the decision inexplicable, saying it’s one thing for cold cases to be out of sight, out of mind, but in active cases like Nancy Guthrie’s, “it could literally be the difference between life and death.”

Mandy Tinkey, front center, lab director for the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office and her team in their exam area on Thursday March 12, 2026. Left to right, Jeff Veltre, Dan Giannettino, Mandy Tinkey, Lauren Karran and Hannah Skropits.. (Sebastian Foltz / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A spokeswoman told the New York Times late last year that it was less a change and more of a clarification.

“Ancestry is intended solely for family history research, not law enforcement,” spokeswoman Gina Spatafore told the newspaper, noting that the company has always prohibited “law enforcement, or those acting on its behalf, from using Ancestry to investigate crimes except through due process.”

Advertise with us

‘These cases stick’

Another stumbling block for law enforcement and other investigating agencies is money.

The cost of this kind of service varies by case and even by the type of DNA sample. For a lab such as Othram to test something like a blood sample from a crime scene, Mr. Gurney said, “it can be as cheap as $2,500 to get that part done.

“A rootless hair or old bones is going to be significantly more expensive,” he said — upwards of $10,000 for the extraction and sequencing.

There’s also a cost for law enforcement to upload the results to those public databases — between $1,200 and $1,400 per DNA profile.

“That’s all before the investigative genetic genealogy even starts,” he said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Gurney said much of the actual genealogical work — combing public records, making connections, building out the family trees — is done by volunteers.

That’s great, he said, but it’s not sustainable. To solve cases, there has to be funding.

“It’s an absolutely game-changing [investigative] method, but the power has really been fully realized by the relevant communities” — namely, he said, the government.

“It really has the potential to end serial killing and serial rape,” he said. “That requires money.”

For now, some law enforcement and investigative agencies have turned to crowdfunding their genetic genealogy efforts. Othram offers a public-facing crowdfunding platform in which agencies can detail their cases and solicit funds to offset the cost of the lab’s services.

Advertise with us

Most recently in Pennsylvania, state police and the Luzerne County District Attorney’s Office reached a funding goal to try to identify “Baby Doe” — a newborn boy found in 1980 in a landfill in Larksville, a borough about two miles west of Wilkes Barre.

Other agencies, including the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office and Pittsburgh police, are relying on state grants to fund their cold case work.

“It invigorates you,” Ms. Tinkey said of making progress on cases that once might have seemed destined to stay cold. She said that after Mr. Keener was identified, she made calls to colleagues who’d worked on his case decades ago.

“I got to say, ‘OK, well, you worked this case 10 years ago — guess what we did?’” she said.

It’s proof that no matter what, there are people who care about such cases.

“It doesn’t matter what the time and space is,” she said. “These cases stick.”