In 1992, a man was pulled from the Allegheny River, his head bloodied and his pockets turned out.

It was never a whodunit.

The witness who directed police to the man’s body in late July 1992 also directed them to a suspect: a 31-year-old man from McKeesport. He was arrested, charged, tried and convicted of third-degree murder — all while his victim remained unidentified.

“I came into the [homicide unit] in 1999, and guys in the office were still talking about it,” said Pittsburgh police homicide Detective George Satler, who is also the bureau’s one-man cold case squad. “This was rare — this was the rarest of the rare.”

Advertise with us

The man from McKeesport — now nearly 65 — has long since served his sentence and been released from prison.

The man from the river, though, remained a mystery.

Authorities had some clues to go on: Witnesses said the man was a drinker and seemed to be transient. He had told people he was from Louisville. Despite the head wound he sustained before ending up in the river — his death was ultimately ruled to be from drowning — authorities had taken clear photos of his face. He was just under 6 feet tall, and he weighed around 175 pounds. They thought he was in his 30s. Witnesses said he had been living under the Ninth Street Bridge.

For nearly 34 years, his DNA and fingerprints remained on file with Pittsburgh police and the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office. In 2024, the medical examiner’s office, Pittsburgh police and Allegheny County police received grants to use genetic genealogy to identify unknown suspects and victims.

The now-identified victim, Allan Keener, was born Feb. 5, 1940, meaning he was actually 52 when he was struck in the head and dumped into the Allegheny. He was born in Louisville, Ky., but he had been living for years in Bridgeport, Ohio.

Advertise with us

He has a daughter who still lives in Ohio. She believed her father just left, the detective said.

“If that happened to me or my family, I’d want to know what happened to my dad,” Det. Satler said. “It’s very satisfying to know that we’re making a difference — that we still care. Even though this case was solved 30 years ago, the detectives still want to figure things out.”

Allegheny County officials announced the development Wednesday.

“We never give up on our cases,” Mandy Tinkey, lab director at the medical examiner’s office, said in a statement. “I am thrilled that after decades of looking into leads and trying new technologies, we are able to finally identify Mr. Keener as the decedent from the 1992 homicide. This brings closure to a family that never knew what happened to their loved one.”

She said the medical examiner’s office has more than a dozen other cold cases on its shelves, and the hope is that the grants will help to shed more light.

Advertise with us

When people use DNA-based family tree websites like Ancestry and 23andMe, they can also upload those results to a site called GEDmatch. Then, users can opt in to allow law enforcement to have access to the DNA profile. When investigators upload the unknown DNA of a suspect or unidentified victim, the website returns a list of imperfect matches — often relatively distant relatives.

But it gives police a place to start.

From those distant relatives, investigators can build out a family tree with branches that ultimately get closer and closer to the unidentified person in question. In this instance, the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office submitted the unidentified man’s DNA to Texas-based Othram Labs. The private lab uses its own trademarked technology to analyze even the most degraded or miniscule DNA samples, build a profile and find possible genealogical matches.

From there, investigators in the medical examiner’s office were able to take that information and start contacting potential relatives.

“It’s a really neat mix of old-school police work and modern technology meeting together,” Det. Satler said.

Advertise with us

Investigators in both offices believed they might have found the answer in 2017 when they found a missing person report out of Kentucky: James Joe Poole was last seen riding his bicycle toward Murray State University in Kentucky in early July 11, 1992, and he has never been seen again.

“So we’re thinking, ‘Oh, this is it, we’re finally going to solve this,’ ” Det. Satler said. “We didn’t forget about it.”

Polaroid photos show the scene of an Aug. 1, 2992, homicide along the Allegheny River on Pittsburgh’s North Shore. (Megan Guza / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Decades later, Pittsburgh police still had the Allegheny River victim’s glasses in evidence. They didn’t match those that Mr. Poole wore when he went missing, and other evidence ultimately confirmed that Mr. Poole was not the man in the Allegheny.

Det. Satler said there were a few aspects of the original leads “where things went wrong, but [there was] nothing we could have done any different.” Estimating age isn’t a precise science, and while he was originally from Louisville, he hadn’t been living there at the time.

Othram has helped identify hundreds of victims and suspects across the country as genetic genealogy has emerged as a solid last hope for cases long gone cold.

Advertise with us

Last year, authorities in Perry County were able to identify a so-called Jane Doe who had been found dead on an embankment near Watts Township in 1979. Known as the “Girl with the Turquoise Jewelry,” she was identified after more than 40 years as Doris Joanne Girtz, of Ohio.

In October, authorities in Bucks County announced that Othram’s work had identified a suspect in the 1962 murder of 9-year-old Carol Ann Dougherty, who was found dead under a stained glass window in St. Mark’s Roman Catholic Church. The suspect, William Schrader, died in 2002, authorities said.

In 2024, the Westmoreland County District Attorney’s Office announced it submitted DNA from several unsolved cases to the Texas-based lab. The same year, state police in Lancaster County were able to file charges in a 1997 sexual assault of two children based on genetic genealogy work by Othram.

"As long as there is DNA, it doesn't matter how old a case is, or whether it seemed hopeless in the past, there is technology here today that works and is able to bring answers to families," said Kristen Mittelman, Othram’s chief development officer. "Our hearts go out to this man's family for what they've been through, especially because we now live in a world where we're able to identify people immediately and families don't have to wait."