A security guard who killed one woman and injured another when he opened fire in a crowded Penn Hills hookah bar in 2024 will spend 10 to 20 years in prison, a judge ruled Wednesday.
Chaz Jackson told Common Pleas Judge Jill E. Rangos that he “had a split second to react” when he heard gunfire inside Ballers Hookah and Cigar Bar early June 2, 2024, and it was “not [his] intention to harm anyone.”
Two people were killed amid the gunfire and chaos inside the now-shuttered Laketon Road bar — 28-year-old Stephanie Stuart and 44-year-old Nathaniel Smiley Jr. Investigators determined that rounds from Jackson’s handgun were the ones that killed Stuart. Jackson was charged with homicide and convicted of voluntary manslaughter earlier this year. No one has been charged in connection with Smiley’s death.
Seven people were injured, including one woman hit three times by bullets fired by Jackson.
Christine Bailey, Stuart’s mother, told the judge that regardless of Jackson’s intentions, the death of her daughter “has destroyed me and my family.” She said she had written down a statement to read to the judge but instead decided to speak from her heart.
“It feels like my heart doesn’t even beat sometimes because of this,” she said, telling Rangos that she can still see the photos of her daughter lying dead on the barroom floor.
Read More
Stuart was her only daughter, Bailey said.
“Everything she lived for, everything she wanted to do is never coming back,” she said. “Never.”
She said she wanted Jackson to understand the impact of what she believed were his reckless actions that night.
Jackson, 44, and his family asked the judge to consider that Jackson believed he was acting in the best interest of everyone at the bar. He told investigators he saw three muzzle flashes and thought he saw a gun in Stuart’s hand before he pulled his own weapon. As he did, he said, he was pulled backward, and he didn’t even realize his gun had gone off until days later.
Assistant District Attorney Jameson Rohrer said all of that was taken into account by verdict of voluntary manslaughter — that is, the belief one is acting in self-defense but that belief is considered unreasonable under the law.
“It was a senseless act, but at the same time, he was just doing his job,” said Jackson’s sister, Denise Holt. “It’s not like he did it just to do it.”
Darryl Jackson told the judge his brother felt he “had no choice but to react.”
“There’s no winner here,” he said. “Only losers.”
It was a sentiment Rangos reiterated as she handed down her sentence.
“The sentence I impose is not going to make anyone happy,” she said. “I don’t mean any disrespect to anyone when I give this sentence.”
Rangos sentenced Jackson to 65 to 130 months in prison for voluntary manslaughter and 60 to 120 months for aggravated assault. She ordered the sentences to run consecutively, meaning Jackson’s total sentence is roughly 10 years and five months to 20 years and nine months.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.