After more than a year with little-to-no progress at the troubled Mon View Heights housing complex, Allegheny County’s top prosecutor said Wednesday he’s prepared to file criminal charges against the bank that foreclosed on the West Mifflin property unless he sees changes in the living conditions.
“When you foreclose on a piece of property, you are now the de facto owner of that property,” District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. said during a news conference in West Mifflin. “You’re no different than the people we’re going to put in jail. You’re going to become defendants in a criminal action unless you start making sense in how we collect this money and how we use this money.”
The men behind the LLC that owns the dilapidated housing complex, Moshe Silbur and Frederick Schulman, are set to plead guilty later this year to charges of theft and creating a public nuisance.
As the charges, filed in early 2025, have worked their way through the court system, the Indiana-based bank that held the mortgage for the housing complex began foreclosure proceedings. Despite that, Mr. Zappala said, the complex remains in a state of disrepair.
He said about 180 families live in the 326-unit complex.
The complex was privately owned but receives federal subsidies for offering housing to low-income tenants. Mr. Zappala said because his office is prosecuting a public nuisance case against ownership, that means his office also has the authority to “try to rectify the nuisance.” That could mean a property sale or garnishing the money that comes in through the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development.
Read More
He said that because the bank foreclosed on the property, that makes them the owners. He said he has a criminal affidavit prepared but “I intend to talk to these people first.
“I want to know who’s responsible for making these decisions in Pittsburgh,” he said. “They’re going to come down here, and we’re going to have a discussion with them about it.”
He said the owners have treated tenants like widgets in a transaction to gain HUD money, rather than like people.
“And obviously they don’t care about the conditions under which they live — we do, and these people do,” he said, gesturing to members of West Mifflin Borough Council.
Councilwoman Carla Payne-Harrison said the living conditions at the complex remain deplorable, especially considering the number of children who live there.
“They’re living with rats and roaches and raccoons and skunks, and we’re expecting them to learn effectively,” she said. “And that’s just not happening.”
She said residents are frustrated and distrustful, as the DA’s office and borough officials have been promising changes since even before the property owners were charged.
“Their concerns are, ‘When is the property going to be remodeled? When are these things that were promised to us going to happen?’ ” she said. “And I didn’t have the answers for that. There’s a can that’s been getting kicked down the road.”
Mayor Chris Kelly said owners receive “in excess of $400,000 a month of HUD money … to provide standard living conditions.” And yet, he said, “there are times that a child shares his breakfast cereal with raccoons and skunks.”
“They’re not being held accountable,” the mayor said. “Through Mr. Zappala’s office, it ends. These people will have to come forward and make it livable or suffer the consequences.”
Mr. Zappla said one possible solution in the interim is to relocate the tenants to other subsidized housing. Borough officials and the DA’s office, he said, are consulting with the county executive’s office and the city, county and McKeesport housing authorities in that regard.
“We waited to see if things were going to be remodeled,” Ms. Payne-Harrison said. “They weren’t. So now we’re going to take that next step, and the next step is to relocate people.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.