If not for the gun Jaylone Hines was carrying on the North Side late one night in October 2022, Betty Jean Averytt and Jacquelyn Mehalic would still be alive, a judge said Tuesday — even if a jury did find Hines not guilty of murder.

If Hines, now 25, hadn’t been carrying the gun he knew he wasn’t supposed to have, Common Pleas Judge Bruce R. Beemer said, he’s certain the defendant never would have confronted the group of rival gang members he spotted across Cedar Avenue at the Sunoco gas station. The ensuing shootout never would have happened, and Ms. Mehalic and Ms. Averytt — two bystanders at a nearby bus stop — never would have been caught in the crossfire.

A jury in January acquitted Hines of murder in the deaths of the women, finding that he had pulled the weapon and fired to protect himself and others. But he was guilty of illegally possessing a firearm, and Judge Beemer said there was no question in his mind that the insistence on carrying a gun he wasn’t allowed to have is what “led to this horrific series of events.”

The judge sentenced Hines to 12½ to 25 years in prison — outside of the standard range set forth in Pennsylvania’s sentencing guidelines and far higher than the lesser sentence for which Hines’ attorney had asked.

Advertise with us

“The evidence absolutely bears out: There is no way you went across that street to Sunoco if you didn’t have a gun that you weren’t supposed to possess,” Judge Beemer told Hines.

The shootout on Cedar Avenue Oct. 15, 2022, between the rival groups left three dead: Ms. Averytt and Ms. Mehalic, as well as John Hornezes, who authorities said was with Hines at the time of the shooting.

Another man involved in the shootout, Charron Troutman, pleaded guilty to his role in the chain of events last year. Troutman pleaded guilty to conspiracy, aggravated assault and weapons charges in exchange for eight to 20 years in prison. Prosecutors also withdrew two attempted homicide charges as part of the plea deal.

Troutman was part of a group of people at the Sunoco the night of the shooting, which officials have characterized as a shootout between the Brighton Place Crips and a “hybrid group” called the Commons. He was the frontseat passenger of a Hyundai Tucson that pulled into the gas station around 10 p.m. He and a woman had just returned to the vehicle from inside the gas station when a white Hyundai Palisade pulled up.

Hines got out of the Palisade and a confrontation ensued — a confrontation that Judge Beemer on Tuesday maintained wouldn’t have happened if Hines didn’t have the security of his illegal firearm.

Advertise with us

Authorities said Hines drove the short distance to the Allegheny Commons housing complex, spoke to a group gathered there, and then took off running back toward the gas station before ultimately returning to the adjacent park.

As the Tucson left the gas station and headed toward the park, several people started shooting toward the SUV from the park. Troutman, authorities said, returned fire, hoisting himself into the open passenger-side window and shooting over the roof.

Hines was charged with firing the shots that killed Ms. Averytt and Ms. Mehalic. Troutman was initially charged in the death of Hornezes, but police ultimately determined that none of the shots he fired could have been the ones that killed the 20-year-old.

Hines was acquitted of most charges after a 10-day trial in January. His attorney, Adam Michael Bishop, successfully argued to jurors that Hines was defending himself and those around him when he started firing that night.

That may be, Judge Beemer said, but it can all be traced back to the gun.

Advertise with us

Hines was barred from owning or possessing a gun after a violent crime conviction as a juvenile that led to an adult sentence. He was released and later arrested in 2019 after he was caught with a gun. He pleaded guilty and spent three years in prison.

“You lost three years of your life for possessing a gun when you knew you weren’t supposed to possess one,” Judge Beemer said.

Hines was released in April 2022. Five months later, he was involved in the fatal shootout — while, the judge noted, he was still on parole for the previous gun charge.

“Your absolute insistence on breaking the law in this regard led to this chain of events,” he said.

Bridgette Mehalic, Jacquelyn’s mother, said she remains embarrassed and ashamed of the jury’s verdict in January.

Advertise with us

“It was never a question of who murdered my daughter,” she told Judge Beemer during her victim impact statement. “We know all the names, yet no one is being held accountable. No one is facing any consequences. The only thing the jury did was justify her murder.

“They placed zero value on her life,” she said.

LaRonda Averytt wrote in a letter read by Deputy District Attorney Emma Schoedel that her mother was known around the North Side as “Beautiful Brown Betty.”

“My mother had so much life to live, so many memories to make, so much love to receive,” she wrote. “It will forever break my heart that she didn’t get that time.”

Both women asked the judge to impose a steep sentence.

Advertise with us

“Are you willing to make an example?” Ms. Averytt asked.

Ms. Mehalic said she’s now raising her daughter’s four children. She said the oldest girl “doubles over in pain” because of her grief. The oldest child, Jacquelyn’s only son, “is so angry he can’t talk about it.

“Do you know how hard it is to find a therapist that specializes in trauma for children?” she asked.

Hines spoke briefly, telling the court he was “sorry for the victims’ families.

“I didn’t want any of this to happen,” he said.

Advertise with us

Ms. Mehalic said in her victim impact statement she didn’t believe it.

“The gang member that murdered by daughter will continue to carry a firearm,” she said. “He will continue to live a violent life, live in conflict, and he will continue to murder.”

Judge Beemer, in sentencing Hines, seemed to agree.

“If you won’t stop carrying a gun … everybody in the community isn’t safe anymore,” he said. “You are being sentenced here today because you won’t stop.”