A federal grand jury has indicted six men in connection with the 2024 attack on a Jewish University of Pittsburgh student off campus in the city’s Oakland section.

The incident happened Sept. 27, 2024, around 2 a.m. on Semple Street, just off Pitt’s campus. The student reported to police at the time that he was walking toward Ward Street when at least five men walked past and made “antisemitic statements.” Those comments, according to the indictment unsealed Monday included “[expletive] Israel” and “[expletive] the Jews.”

Muhammed Koc, 27, of Pittsburgh, and Omar Alshmari, 28, of Monroeville, were both indicted for allegedly violating federal hate crime statutes. Mr. Koc and Mr. Alshmari and four others are also accused of conspiring to obstruct the investigation into the attack:

• Abraham Choudhry, 22, of Monroeville.

Advertise with us

• Emirhan Arslan, 24, of McKees Rocks.

• Ali Alkhaleel, 19, of Pittsburgh.

• Adeel Piracha, 22, of Murrysville, who authorities said was not part of the group when the attack happened but allegedly conspired with the others after the fact to impede the investigation.

“[This] incident began with two defendants physically attacking an individual because of the victim’s Jewish identity,” U.S. Attorney Troy Rivetti said in a statement. “Then, these defendants corruptly colluded with one another to provide false and misleading testimony before a federal grand jury tasked with investigating the assault.”

According to the 23-page indictment, the student wearing the Star of David turned and questioned the group about the comments, at which point an argument ensued.

Advertise with us

“[The victim] stood his ground and asserted it was ‘dumb’ to insult someone for being Jewish … but was not physically aggressive toward any of the defendants,” according to the indictment.

The argument allegedly devolved to violence when Mr. Koc and Mr. Alshmari both hit the student, splitting his lip.

According to the indictment, the group discussed the incident via Snapchat and text the following day, including one exchange in which Mr. Alshmari told a witness: “Some Jew [expletive] said something so I stomped his head in.”

Federal investigators began interviewing the men and ultimately issued grand jury subpoenas in January 2025, according to the indictment. In an interview with FBI agents, Mr. Koc first denied he was on Semple Street the night of the incident but, after being confronted with surveillance footage, said he was there but the victim had started the fight.

After that first interview, according to the indictment, the group began to speak about getting “all on [the] same page.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Alshmari allegedly told the rest of the men in a Snapchat group message that, “We need to know everything they talked about” — a reference to previous interviews by federal agents, according to the indictment.

Authorities also alleged the men lied during their grand jury testimony in February 2025. Among the alleged false statements included in the indictment:

• Mr. Alshmari told the grand jury that he didn’t hit anyone that night nor did he see anyone getting punched or hit. He said no one on Semple Street that night said anything about the victim being Jewish, and there was no mention of a Star of David. Asked at the end of his testimony if he’d been truthful, Mr. Alshmari said he had been.

• Mr. Choudhry told the grand jury he didn’t recall any conversation about Judaism that night. He said he didn’t remember if Mr. Koc made any such reference and said “no” when asked specifically about whether Mr. Koc mentioned Israel or Judaism.

• Mr. Arslan, asked if there was a fight that night, told the grand jury: “I honestly don’t know. I mean, whenever I [saw] it, it looked more like an argument to me.” He said he didn’t see anyone throw any punches that night, and he didn’t notice any necklace. Mr. Arlsan said he didn’t hear what the argument was about, and no one told him what to say during his testimony. He, too, told the grand jury he’d been truthful in his testimony.

Advertise with us

• Mr. Alkhaleel said he didn’t see anyone hit anyone else the night of the incident nor had he talked to anyone about what to say during his testimony. He also testified he’d been truthful to the grand jury.

• Mr. Piracha told the grand jury he didn’t remember if he spoke with Mr. Koc about the Semple Street incident, and he wasn’t sure if he’d discussed the incident with anyone else.

The Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh welcomed the charges, thanking federal and local authorities.

“Their commitment to holding perpetrators of hate-motivated violence accountable sends a clear and necessary message,” Shawn Brokos, director of community security, said in a statement. “Attacks targeting people for their Jewish identity will not go unanswered.”