Details of a clash between police and protesters in West Mifflin a day prior came into clearer focus on Monday through court records and interviews, although police Chief Greg McCullough and protest organizer Naomi White seem to still view those details through starkly different lenses.

About 50 to 60 people were involved in the march for 13-year-old Terrel Byars Jr., who was struck by a vehicle and killed as he crossed Kennywood Boulevard in late December. The march began near the Duquesne police station and was supposed to end just under 2 miles away at the Speedway convenience store on Kennywood Boulevard — where the East Allegheny sixth-grader was headed with a friend, his family said, when he was struck.

Among those arrested Sunday was the boy’s father, Terrel Byars Sr. His mother, Naomi White, said she was hit with pepper spray during the clash with police.

“I was not doing this protest out of anger, I wasn’t doing this protest … to cause any hazards, to have anybody arrested,” Ms. White told the Post-Gazette on Monday. “I’m just trying to get justice for my child who was killed.”

Advertise with us

Officers began taking people into custody shortly after 2 p.m. after the march crossed into West Mifflin from neighboring Duquesne. Police wrote in the criminal complaints that they gave “multiple lawful orders” for participants to disperse. The complaint alleged that the six arrested actively and passively resisted arrest. Charges ranged from resisting arrest and obstructing law enforcement to disorderly conduct and obstructing roadways.

“This is when multiple participants in the group became irate with the police presence and started getting in officers’ faces, yelling and screaming, and refusing to cooperate,” police wrote in the complaint.

Chief McCullough said he was able to calm the clash once he arrived at the scene.

“It only got a little chaotic for a moment,” he told the Post-Gazette Monday, “then everything settled down.

“We came to a nice result.”

Advertise with us

Ms. White disagreed.

“Honestly, the macing of the children, the pushing of the father — it was totally ridiculous,” she said. “Taking my deceased son’s dad to jail in front of his kids was … nuts.”

No charges have been filed in connection with the Dec. 27 incident. The chief said his department has handed its investigation over to the Allegheny County District Attorney’s Office.

First Assistant District Attorney Rebecca Spangler said the investigation is not completed, and the office is waiting for additional reports from other agencies.

“Until we receive and review all reports,” she said, “we cannot comment on a pending investigation.”

Advertise with us

Chief McCullough said he had a “nice, long conversation” with Ms. White on Monday morning — one that he thought brought the issues to an amiable resolution.

Ms. White called the conversation “OK.”

She maintained that the group was trying to follow orders — to get out of the middle of the four-lane thoroughfare — when officers “interrupted for no reason.” She said she still didn’t understand why officers had to deploy pepper spray, and she said the chief hadn’t offered her an explanation.

“I was maced … Terrel’s little sister was maced, Terrel’s little brother was maced,” she said.

The chief said the sergeant on scene “just wanted to get everybody off the roadway.” The group could have kept walking, he said, “just not in the middle of the roadway.”

Advertise with us

Police wrote in the criminal complaints that traffic in both directions continued as protesters walked, with “vehicles continuing to attempt to bypass the large crowd.”

“My thing is this,” Ms. White said. “You do not have to ask for a protest. Asking for a protest is not going to bring the statement that’s trying to be made.”

That statement, she said, is to bring awareness to her son’s death, the lack of charges filed so far, and what she sees as general unsafe driving in that area.

“I just want this woman to take accountability for what she’s done to my child and what she’s done to me,” she said. “I don’t want any other family to feel the pain that I feel.”

The four-lane stretch of Route 837 has seen deadly incidents in the past.

Advertise with us

In September, a 73-year-old Kennywood employee was struck and killed at the intersection of Kennywood and Hoffman boulevards. Authorities said she was on her way to her shift at the park.

A man was killed in a single-vehicle crash along the same stretch in March 2025. In 2021, one pedestrian was killed and another was injured when they were struck near the Kennywood/Hoffman intersection.