A Westmoreland County jury convicted Thomas Stanko of first-degree murder Wednesday for the death of his ex-girlfriend, Cassandra Gross, marking the first so-called no-body homicide conviction in the county in more than 40 years.

Ms. Gross was 51 when she was last seen April 7, 2018, and was reported missing two days later. A day after she was reported missing, state troopers found her car burned near railroad tracks in Twin Lakes Park.

She was declared dead in 2019. Stanko, 55, was charged with Ms. Gross’ murder in October 2022.

Jurors deliberated for about four hours Wednesday after two hours of closing arguments from prosecutors and Stanko’s defense attorney, Marc Daffner. Testimony in the case began last week.

Advertise with us

“We knew when we pursued prosecution in this case, it would be a complex and challenging case to present to a jury,” District Attorney Nicole Ziccarelli said in a statement. “This has been a long, exhausting eight years for the Gross family waiting for justice, and I am proud justice was finally served.”

Stanko took the stand in his own defense for three hours Tuesday, telling jurors that he did not kill Ms. Gross. According to Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV, he testified that he and Ms. Gross had a good relationship until a fight in 2018, after which things were rough for a bit, but they had made up and continued seeing each other before her disappearance.

“There was nothing to hide,” Stanko said, indicating he would take a lie detector test to clear his name. The TV station reported that when he was asked if he killed Mr. Gross, Stanko responded, “I did not.”

Prosecutors pointed to pieces of clothing and glasses that appeared to belong to Ms. Gross that were found in a burn barrel and burn pit on Stanko’s property in the days after her disappearance. Investigators also recovered a burned vial of her dog’s insulin and a magazine addressed to her.

On the stand, according to KDKA, Stanko said he’d burned the items at Ms. Gross’ request, as she didn’t want to throw them away in a Dumpster.

Advertise with us

Prosecutors asked Stanko about angry voicemails he had left Ms. Gross in which he accused her of cheating.

“I wrongfully accused her of cheating,” he said, “but that doesn’t make me a murderer.”

Late last week, Dr. Anne Levri testified about treating Stanko at a MedExpress on April 13, 2018. She said Stanko came in with scratches on his face and hand — injuries he told her he had sustained falling from a pine tree days earlier.

According to KDKA, Dr. Levri said she was skeptical of the story — the scratches were in multiple directions rather than the same direction, which would be expected if he had scraped his skin against a tree. His face was red and swollen, which the doctor said could have been from a burn.