A judge on Friday dismissed homicide charges against a McKeesport teenager, saying that DNA left on a hat at the crime scene last year wasn’t enough to send the case to trial.
Daemond Artemus, 18, who is awaiting trial in two other homicide cases, was charged earlier this month with the May 2024 slaying of Lyft driver Brandon Dean.
One key piece of evidence Assistant District Attorney Matthew Goddard presented during the preliminary hearing was a black baseball cap that was dropped at the scene.
According to the criminal complaint, footage from nearby home security cameras showed Mr. Dean pull to the intersection of Freemont and Palmgreen streets before four people came out of a home on Palmgreen. Investigators noted that the man who got into the front passenger seat of the car wore a baseball cap.
The four were in the car for less than 30 seconds before the cameras captured the sound of two gunshots followed by the four passengers running from the car, according to the complaint. The person that investigators allege was wearing the hat — the front-seat passenger — appeared to trip as he ran from the scene.
Investigators testified that an examination turned up DNA from five separate individuals on the hat, and an analysis of those profiles by Pittsburgh-based Cybergenetics showed that around 55% of the DNA belonged to Mr. Artemus. A smaller portion belonged to Mr. Dean, the victim, and the rest was from three other people who remain unidentified.
Read More
Cybergenetics case worker Jennifer Bracanontes said she couldn’t say when the DNA was left on the hat, nor could she say whether the unidentified DNA came from someone who wore the hat or just handled it.
Investigators linked the hat to Mr. Artemus via photos on social media. They also questioned the individual whose account was used to order the Lyft that night and, when detectives questioned him at his home, they saw that one of the photos of Mr. Artemus wearing the hat was taken inside that home.
Defense attorney Tom N. Farrell argued that it was impossible to know if his client was wearing the hat when it was dropped or left at the shooting scene.
“This young man is being charged with homicide strictly on a hat that he had worn,” Mr. Farrell said, noting that the fact that he’s wearing it in a photo taken at a friend’s home means that others might have had access to it.
District Judge Katherine P. Lovelace said there just wasn’t enough evidence to hold the charges for court, even with the lower burden of preliminary hearings.
“If you get more evidence, refile,” she told the prosecutor.
Mr. Artemus still faces charges in other cases.
He was arrested Sept. 3, 2024, the day after 22-year-old Dylan Saula was found shot in the street on Lysle Boulevard in McKeesport.
Security cameras in the area showed Mr. Saula’s body being dumped from a red sedan about 10:30 a.m. the day of the shooting. A neighbor later captured video of four men abandoning the same car on Pirl Street, according to that criminal complaint.
Tracking dogs led police from the abandoned car to a home on nearby Hamilton Street. There, according to the complaint, investigators detained four people, including Mr. Artemus.
A month later, Mr. Artemus allegedly arranged from jail to have two witnesses in the Saula case murdered before they could testify against him.
Niejah Hill was killed and a man was wounded in the Oct. 4, 2024, shooting on Orchard Avenue. The victim who survived told police that he and Ms. Hill were asleep in bed when someone walked in and started shooting.
Jail phone recordings showed Mr. Artemus had recruited 18-year-old John Perry to kill the man who survived, who Mr. Artemus believed was an informant for the police.
In that case, Mr. Artemus and Mr. Perry both are charged with homicide, attempted homicide, and conspiracy to commit homicide. Mr. Artemus is also charged with soliciting homicide.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.