Jurors on Monday convicted a man of first-degree murder in the 2021 shooting of a teenage line cook outside his mother’s Strip District restaurant.

Testimony in the case against 50-year-old Howard Hawkins began last week, more than four years after he gunned down 18-year-old Ahmir Tuli.

The teen was on his break outside of his mother’s bar/restaurant, Preeti’s Pit, when there was a confrontation between Ahmir and Hawkins, who had been tossed from the bar about 15 minutes earlier for fighting.

It was the second time the case has gone to trial: Several days into proceedings last year, Common Pleas Judge Beth Lazzara granted the defense a mistrial after a police witness referenced Hawkins’ criminal history during testimony.

Advertise with us

Hawkins faces a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole. He will be formally sentenced Jan. 20.

In her opening statement, Assistant District Attorney Sarah Weikart told jurors that while no single security camera showed the shooter’s face that night — Feb. 21, 2021 — all of the footage stitched together would give them the evidence they needed to find Hawkins guilty of the murder.

Hawkins, she said, had 15 minutes between when he was escorted from the bar by a security guard and when he confronted Ahmir, who was in his car smoking a cigarette. Hawkins went to his car twice during that time, Ms. Weikart said, and instead of getting in and going home, he retrieved a gun and tried to return to the bar.

Defense attorney Casey White said it’s true that someone shot and killed the 18-year-old that night — and that’s a tragedy, he said.

But while there’s footage from a “grainy city camera from a block away,” he added, “you will not see any DNA, you will not hear of any fingerprints.”