Testimony began Monday in the retrial of a man accused of gunning down a teenage line cook in front of his mother’s Strip District restaurant in 2021.

Ahmir Tuli, 18, was on his break outside his mother’s restaurant, Preeti’s Pit, shortly after 9 p.m. on Feb. 21, 2021. Police and prosecutors allege a confrontation followed between the teenager and Howard Hawkins, who had been tossed from the bar about 15 minutes earlier.

“Howard Hawkins walks over to Ahmir and within seconds shoots him in the head,” Assistant District Attorney Sarah Weikart told jurors in her opening statement. “Then he walks away as Ahmir’s body falls to the ground.”

She said numerous security cameras inside and outside of the Penn Avenue restaurant captured the fight inside, Hawkins’ retreat outside to his car, and the subsequent shooting. While no camera angle clearly shows the face of the shooter, Ms. Weikart said, they can be pieced together into a “direct timeline of where Howard Hawkins was before and after [the shooting].”

Advertise with us

Hawkins, she said, had 15 minutes between when he was escorted from the bar by a security guard and when he confronted Ahmir, who was in his car smoking a cigarette during his break. He went to his car twice during that time, Ms. Weikart said, and instead of getting in and going home, he retrieved a gun and tried to return to the bar.

Defense attorney Casey White said it’s true that someone shot and killed the 18-year-old that night — and that’s a tragedy, he said. But while there’s footage from a “grainy city camera from a block away,” he added, “you will not see any DNA, you will not hear of any fingerprints.”

Mr. White told jurors he believes the evidence will not stack up to prove Hawkins the shooter beyond a reasonable doubt.

“[Prosecutors] want to try to prove an innocent man guilty,” he said, asking jurors to “put the emotional component to the side.”

Ms. Weikart said a security guard at the bar saw the shooting and described Hawkins to police when they arrived at the scene. She described him again later during an interview at police headquarters.

Advertise with us

But Mr. White said she was left alone for hours at the police station, where she scrolled through social media and “was getting suggestions and inferences.”

“They’re going to want you to make assumptions and conjecture,” he said. “The commonwealth has accused an innocent man of these crimes.”