Christopher Ragland’s decision to walk away from his police chief nomination — and the bureau altogether — laid bare growing divisions between some city councilors and Mayor Ed Gainey and hinted at what could be growing discord among council members themselves.

“They can try to shift blame, but the blame is squarely on them. That’s where it should be,” Mr. Gainey said Wednesday, a day after Mr. Ragland, the mayor’s top pick to lead the police bureau, walked away from both the nomination and a 31-year career with Pittsburgh police.

Mr. Ragland accused certain council members of making demands of him in exchange for their support, saying requests were made of him that went against his ethics and morals.

While the former acting chief did not identify specific individuals, several councilmembers identified themselves as the likely targets of his remarks — and vehemently denied any wrongdoing — during a scheduled standing committee meeting Wednesday morning.

Advertise with us

“Nothing here happened that was inappropriate,” Councilman Bob Charland said.

Speculating on the situation, Mr. Coghill said he believed Mr. Ragland’s comment about demands could have been directed toward him. During a meeting, Mr. Coghill asked Mr. Ragland who he intended to promote to higher positions, he recounted on Wednesday.

Mr. Gainey hinted that some members of council told Mr. Ragland who they wanted to see promoted in exchange for their votes during his confirmation process.

“I thought it was inappropriate for any council person to ask him to promote somebody knowing that his selection process had not even been completed,” Mr. Gainey said. “I think it’s wrong.”

Mr. Coghill said he believes Mr. Ragland needed to be transparent.

Advertise with us

“Not one conversation was had between me and another commander or anybody in any other rank as to a deal or something nefarious,” Mr. Coghill said, noting that he did “stress that it’s important for me to know who he surrounded himself with,” noting he’d heard from an “unprecedented amount of rank-and-file” officers who had “issues” with Mr. Ragland’s nomination.

Mr. Gainey said that admission from Mr. Coghill “confirms exactly what the chief said.”

“The reality is, that’s why he had an issue, and I respect that,” Mr. Gainey said.

He said councilmembers had “no right” to ask Mr. Ragland those types of questions.

“If the mayor wants to claim that there was an ethical dilemma in what happened here, I encourage him to put your money where your mouth is and file an ethics complaint,” Mr. Charland said.

Advertise with us

Mr. Ragland told KDKA Radio on Wednesday that ultimately he knew he couldn’t lead the department and be an example to young recruits if he felt like he had done anything unethical.

“Police officers are extremely good at spotting hypocrisy,” he said. “I don’t think I could sit in front of an academy class and talk to those recruits on their first day and say this job is about helping others, this job is about serving your community and if you do a good job and you do everything you’re supposed to and you care, that you can do anything that you want. I don’t think that’s possible given what I was asked to do.”

Fissures appeared even within council, with Councilwoman Barb Warwick accusing others of trying to slow down the process with community meetings and public forums. She said Mr. Ragland was happy to oblige when some community organizations pushed for a town hall.

“That is when members of this body got involved – members who we know have been planning for weeks to slow this appointment down as much as possible,” Ms. Warwick said.

Councilwoman Theresa Kail-Smith was upfront: “I don’t think we should be putting forward a chief right before an election, no matter who it is.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Ragland on Tuesday said that he’d been eager to participate in the community forum process.

“However, the process turned from what it should have been, which was an honest inquiry into my qualifications for the job, into a political football with endless delays and pressures for deal-making every day,” he said.

Ms. Kail-Smith and Mr. Coghill said they pushed for just three community meetings, but local organizations stood firm on six. Six meetings was what council, public safety officials, and Mr. Ragland all agreed on in the end.

Mr. Gainey said moving forward, he will work with “councilmembers that I believe had good faith” and “the ones that want to work with us” to create a system where the city will “get the best candidate for the job without it being politicized.”


How we got here

Former Chief Scott Schubert announced his retirement after years at the helm in May 2022 and officially left the bureau in July of that year. It took the city nearly a year bring in Larry Scirotto, a process that involved a lengthy nationwide search for candidates.

Advertise with us

Mr. Scirotto spent more than 20 years with the city before his first retirement in 2018, after which he applied for a number of top-cop jobs around the country and landed briefly in Fort Lauderdale. Mr. Gainey announced Mr. Scirotto as his pick for chief in May 2023. He retired about 16 months later amid controversy surrounding his side gig as an NCAA basketball ref.

Mr. Scirotto told city council ahead of his 2023 confirmation that he would not pursue a return to college basketball officiating while he served as chief. A year later, however, he announced that he would return to the court part-time — with the mayor’s blessing.

He left the bureau as scrutiny of the decision grew, saying on the way out that he and Mr. Gainey had always had a gentleman’s agreement to revisit the question of officiating once Mr. Scirotto hit the one-year mark.

Mr. Gainey has denied there was any type of deal in place from the get-go, something he reiterated again Wednesday.

Because he had spent more than a year in the chief’s position, Mr. Scirotto was entitled to a more lucrative pension than what he had received at an officer’s salary — more than $90,000 a year.

Advertise with us

As Mr. Ragland’s tenure as acting chief progressed, some city councilmembers, feeling burned by Mr. Scirotto, began a push for changes to the nomination and hiring process.

In February, Mr. Coghill called for a hearing that would open the floor for residents to share their thoughts on the acting chief — an unusual move for a mayoral appointment. Council typically sticks to interviewing the candidates themselves and then hold a vote.

“I think my constituents want to have a voice in this, at least just to be heard,” Mr. Coghill said at the time, “so I want to provide them that platform.”

Mr. Ragland said in his departure press conference Tuesday that he’d been eager to participate in the community-forum process. He said the entire situation undermined his ability to be a leader.

“I saw no end in sight,” he said. “A chief whose confirmation has become a question of political factions is a chief who cannot meet the challenges that our bureau faces.”

Advertise with us

The situation with Mr. Scirotto also pushed City Council to change the way it interviews department and bureau heads. Candidates for those roles now must be under oath during council’s interview process. City Council presidents have always had the power to swear-in appointees, but the new legislation makes that a requirement.

Mr. Ragland would have likely been the first mayoral nominee to go through the new process.

“I didn’t introduce this legislation to put people on the spot,” Mr. Coghill said in February. “Taxpayers were fooled in this instance … and I don’t want it to happen again.”

“Any time I talk, I’m a truthful individual,” Mr. Ragland told KDKA. “What I took offense to … was you had individuals saying, ‘We’re going to put people under oath’ and ‘We’re going to file perjury charges’ and ‘We’re going to try to take that individual’s pension.’ I don’t think that’s a proper way to start a relationship between your police chief and council.”

Mr. Ragland said his decision to walk away from a career with the city spanning three decades had him feeling lighter on Wednesday. He told the radio station he believes he got caught in the middle of politics between the mayor and some members of council, and he again alluded a situation in which “certain things … were demanded” in exchange for votes to approve his nomination to the permanent chief position.

“Being the boss is a very lonely spot,” he told KDKA. “It certainly takes a level of moral courage to make decisions for a group, an organization, a city that may be unpopular but are the right ones. It’s lonely.”