Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto’s abrupt announcement that he will retire just 16 months after he was sworn in is causing not only disappointment but concern about the ripple effect his decision could create.

Community leaders, former members of law enforcement and others told the Post-Gazette that the resignation — which came amid renewed scrutiny over his side job refereeing NCAA basketball — may ultimately have an impact on crime rates, officer staffing levels and the city’s economic outlook, especially in neighborhoods such as Downtown.

Terri Minor-Spencer, program manager of Sto-Rox ACTES (Achieving Change Through Transitional Employment Services), said she was disappointed to hear Chief Scirotto would move on from the department as of Nov. 1. 

The chief led efforts to increase collaboration between the department and community violence prevention groups, she said. 

Advertise with us

“I’m hoping that whoever comes to replace him comes with the same broad shoulders, with a vision of listening and learning where we are and what we have already put in, so we don’t have to reinvent that wheel,” said Ms. Minor-Spencer, whose organization addresses gun violence by connecting at-risk groups with support services. 

Carmen Brown, a community activist from Lincoln-Lemington, said crime in her neighborhood already has her feeling apprehensive, and she hopes news that the city will once again be without a permanent police chief will not make it worse.

“I just think things are going to spiral out of control,” said Ms. Brown, 50. “I really do because you have to remember, criminals know, they look at the news too. They see things that are going on. … I just see the city getting worse.”

Some said they worry the city’s struggles to address homelessness — particularly Downtown — may worsen with Chief Scirotto’s departure.

Attorney Ron Del Duca represents tenants in the Fort Pitt Commons building, which bordered a homeless encampment cleared by outreach workers and police earlier this month. The camp was littered with trash, drug paraphernalia and human waste, and those who live and work nearby reported being harassed and feeling unsafe.

Advertise with us

He said people had just begun returning to Downtown after years of decline following the pandemic, and any progress gained is in danger of being lost. 

“Developers don’t want to put up a building or renovate a building if they know that there’s going to be a situation where people don’t want to go into that building, whether it's to live or work, because of security issues,” he said.

Mr. Del Duca said he has clients who currently are involved in the sale of the 11-story First and Market building on First Avenue, where a multimilliondollar project is expected to convert the building into 93 affordable housing units for seniors. 

The success of such projects will hinge on active policing and an increased feeling of safety, he said.

This summer, a series of high-profile and seemingly random assaults across Downtown prompted Chief Scirotto to ramp up patrols in what officials called a “high-visibility police patrol initiative.”

Advertise with us

“You want it to be safe Downtown,” Mr. Del Duca said. “If you want to attract people to work there, but more importantly live there, and continue to live there, you’re going to have to maintain what’s been done in the last six to eight months. Pople don’t want to be scared to walk down the street or out of their building.”

While some say they believe the vitality of city neighborhoods may be, in part, contingent on the way the police department moves on from Chief Scirotto, others said it may also worsen the bureau’s ongoing staffing issues.

As of August, the bureau had 763 officers but was budgeted for 850. The department also had seen 25 resignations and about 40 retirements as of August, said Fraternal Order of Police President Bob Swartzwelder.

Tony Moreno, a former city detective who retired in 2018 and a former city mayoral candidate, said he had already heard from officers who said they plan to leave when the chief retires as a result of how the city handled events leading up to the chief’s retirement announcement on Friday.

Mayor Ed Gainey gave the chief his blessing earlier this month to return to officiating, insisting he had improved the bureau to the point where he could do both. When announcing Oct. 17 that he would return to officiating college basketball games, the chief said he planned to use his vacation and normal three-day weekends to referee up to 64 games a season.

Advertise with us

Mr. Moreno said the way the city handled the issue rubbed officers the wrong way.

“You’ve got officers, because of what just happened, trying to escape as fast as they can,” said Mr. Moreno, who ran for mayor in 2022. “What they realized was they were forced to work quadruple shifts while the mayor just approved the chief to not work for over 60 days [to referee basketball games]. It’s a slap in the face.”

The resignation comes less than a week after the mayor indicated he’d accepted the chief’s offer to take a $20,000 pay cut to help fund the salary for a new deputy chief position. With his retirement, and based on his previous 23 years with the city, Chief Scirotto’s yearly pension will be 50% of $185,400, his salary in 2024.

The deputy chief would have been in charge of the department while the chief was on the basketball court. The job was set to go to current Assistant Chief Chris Ragland, who now will become acting chief while city officials decide how to hire a permanent police leader.

City Council had scheduled a meeting for Tuesday to learn more about the chief’s basketball plans before approving his 2025 salary. It was unclear Friday whether that meeting was still on.

Advertise with us

Chief Scirotto’s hiring was a homecoming of sorts. He had spent more than two decades with the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police in multiple roles, including as commander of the major crimes unit and later as assistant chief.

He came back to Pittsburgh from Fort Lauderdale, Fla., where he was chief before he was fired for allegedly favoring non-white candidates for promotions.

The process to choose Chief Scirotto was lengthy — he was named to the top cop spot nearly a year after former chief Scott Schubert had announced his retirement — and fraught with criticism.

Mr. Gainey’s administration had conducted a nationwide search but kept much of the process under wraps. The city spent $80,000 to contract with the firm Public Sector Search & Consulting to assist in the search.

Now, with Chief Scirotto out, Mr. Moreno said he believes confidence in the department and city administration may be shattered.

“It’s a complete breakdown,” he said. “They need to have a public hearing with an investigation to bring people to sit down and ask how this happened.”