Pittsburgh police Chief Larry Scirotto’s hasty retirement this week will leave in flux a department facing severe staffing shortages and an increased focus on public safety as multimillion dollar efforts to revitalize Downtown post-pandemic continue.
They’re much the same issues that faced the chief when he was tapped to lead the department 17 months ago.
Much remains unknown about how the city will move forward in hiring a new permanent chief, including whether it will entail another yearlong nationwide search or if soon-to-be acting Chief Christopher Ragland will be in the running.
An apparent deal between Mayor Ed Gainey and Chief Scirotto ensured the chief’s ability to return to college basketball officiating, but also remains shrouded in mystery. City Council’s post-agenda meeting meant to glean more information about the chief’s side gig reffing NCAA games remains scheduled for Tuesday afternoon despite his retirement announcement last week.
The city and its residents went from the surprise news of the chief’s return to officiating to assurances the arrangement could work to his retirement announcement in just one week. While much about what happened between Oct. 17 and Oct. 25 remains unclear — as does what comes next — here is how the city landed at this point.
His tenure
Chief Scirotto’s hiring was celebrated not just as a homecoming of sorts — he spent 23 years with the bureau before his (first) retirement in 2018 — but also because it finally marked the end of a nearly yearlong hiring process.
Read More
Former Chief Scott Schubert announced in late May 2022 that he intended to retire effective July 1, 2022. The search itself was shrouded in secrecy, although the city spent $80,000 to hire California-based Public Sector Search & Consulting to lead the process.
City officials organized three panels to interview candidates — one made up of community members, one of police union representatives and one comprised of the mayor’s executive team. While the members of the community panel were announced publicly, both they and the union representatives signed nondisclosure agreements.
It’s still unclear how many people applied to the position while applications were being accepted, nor is it clear how many times the pool was narrowed down before three finalists rose to the top: Chief Scirotto; Frederick, Md., Chief Jason Lando; and former Boise, Idaho, Chief Ryan Lee.
Chief Scirotto was announced as the mayor’s nominee on May 3, 2023, and he was sworn in a month later.
The city’s long-awaited police staffing study was released about a month into the chief’s tenure, although he balked at some of the $180,000 study’s top recommendations — including the suggestion that the bureau reallocate more than 180 patrol officers to other divisions, including a community resource unit.
“I don’t want to reallocate any patrol officers,” he said at the time. “I am of the belief that all 900 men and women are community-oriented police officers.”
Still, the chief presided over several large changes within the department, including to the way in which officers responded to overnight calls. He announced in February that only so-called “priority calls” that came between 3 a.m. and 7 a.m. would receive in-person police responses. Others would be queued up for in-person response the next day or for an officer to reach out via phone.
He also instituted a Telephone Report Unit, referred to as TRU, to handle low-level calls that didn’t actually involve a crime actively happening — parking complaints, lost wallets and break-ins where no one was present.
Much of the chief’s 16-month tenure came amid intense scrutiny on crime and perceived crime in the city’s Golden Triangle. The need for increased foot patrols in Downtown meant that Allegheny County police chipped in patrolling at times, and the city ultimately allocated more officers to the area. Even more officers were sent to Downtown after a series of high-profile and seemingly random assaults.
His departure
The fallout from Chief Scirotto’s Oct. 17 announcement that he would return to his previous part-time gig refereeing NCAA Big Ten basketball games was swift.
The announcement raised the eyebrows of some City Council members who were under the impression that the chief had given up that job for the duration of his Pittsburgh tenure.
In May 2023, as Mr. Gainey introduced Chief Scirotto as his pick for top cop, he said of the chief’s officiating: “We had a conversation about this, and at this time, he will not being doing that.”
Two weeks later during City Council’s public interviews with Chief Scirotto, Councilman Anthony Coghill asked him to confirm his commitment to putting that job to the side.
“I know that you have committed to not pursue that profession while you’re here as a Pittsburgh police chief, correct?” Mr. Coghill asked.
Chief Scirotto replied: “Correct.”
But Mr. Gainey said Friday, hours after the chief’s retirement announcement, that there had always been a deal in place for the chief to return to officiating if homicides in the city decreased.
“We talked about the homicides coming down and if he wanted to run this program where he was taking kids to different activities as part of him reffing, we could talk about it, and we did,” Mr. Gainey said last week.
The chief declined interview requests from the Post-Gazette, directing all questions regarding his return to officiating to Mr. Gainey’s office. The mayor’s communications staff did not respond to numerous lists of questions posed by the Post-Gazette.
The chief did, however, speak to other Pittsburgh media outlets to defend the idea that he could both head the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police and hold down his side gig officiating 60 to 65 NCAA games.
“That is the focus of my every day, and it doesn’t change whether I’m in Madison, Wis., or Portland, Ore., or I’m in Pittsburgh at my desk,” he told KDKA Radio a day after his officiating announcement.
What comes next
Safety Director Lee Schmidt said Friday that it was too early to say how the search for a new chief will play out.
Mr. Schmidt said it was too early to say whether it would be another nationwide search for chief, although he noted that he doesn’t believe it will be as lengthy a process as the last time.
“I think we have some new folks in place that weren’t here then or weren’t in the same places they’re in now,” he said. “I think we also have that information from our last search and experience with our last search to go by — to have those discussions with council, with the mayor — and decide the best step going forward.”
Chief Scirotto’s retirement is effective Nov. 1. Assistant Chief Christopher Ragland will be acting chief in the interim.
He had already been tapped to be Chief Scirotto’s deputy chief — that is, the person at the helm when Chief Scirotto would have been on the basketball court.
“I think there are many people that respect Chief Ragland,” Mr. Schmidt said. “I’m sure there are some that might not appreciate him all the time, but I think he does a great job. He’s been a good assistant chief of administration, moving projects forward that the chief put through.”
Before his retirement announcement, Chief Scirotto had offered to take a $20,000 pay cut to supplement the pay raise the title of deputy chief would entail. He told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV the mayor took him up on that offer.
Public safety officials said last week the chief’s departure would prompt them to “re-evaluate the current command structure and corresponding salaries,” and a “final determination on remuneration regarding the affected positions” will be in the 2025 budget.
Many of the challenges Chief Scirotto faced in his brief tenure will fall to the next chief as well, including a dearth of officers compared to what a full complement looks like in Pittsburgh.
As of Monday, there were 751 officers employed by the bureau, which includes two recruit classes that are still completing their field training.
Fully staffed, Pittsburgh’s police bureau has around 900 officers, although it has been years since the department was at that level. The city lowered the number of officers budgeted for in 2024 to 850, and the mayor’s preliminary 2025 budget drops that number again — to 800.
A new academy class of 30 to 35 recruits starts Monday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.