Alexis Herrera’s involvement in what happened at the home on 10th Street in Oakmont in 2020 differed depending on who she was talking to at the time.
She told forensic psychiatrist Sarah West that she tried to be kind to her step-niece, Bella Seachrist, when the 3-year-old’s step-mother — Herrera’s sister, Laura Ramriez — wasn’t around. She tried to sneak food to the starving girl, she said, and the only abuse she described was once “popping” the toddler in the face.
But she told Bruce Wright, a forensic psychiatrist retained by prosecutors in the case, that she only pretended to hit Bella to please her sister; rather, she would clap her hands to make it sound like she was hitting her. He testified that Herrera told him she only pretended to tie Bella up — she didn’t actually do it.
And all of that differed, Deputy District Attorney Jennifer DiGiovanni said, from what Herrera told police in the aftermath of Bella’s death — including that she gave Ramriez the idea of tying the toddler to the stairs or to a bed frame.
“The more removed she is, the more she removes herself from actual involvement in Bella’s death,” Ms. DiGiovanni said.
Three mental health experts and Herrera’s younger sister, Ashanti Garcia, were the final witnesses to testify in the case of Herrera, the third and final defendant in Bella’s death.
Read More
Herrera, now 25, pleaded guilty last year to a count of general homicide for her role in the death of Bella on June 9, 2020 — the culmination of months of abuse, neglect, and torture. Common Pleas Judge Bruce R. Beemer this week will determine the degree to which Herrera is guilty. Ms. DiGiovanni presented her case to the judge in late January. Defense attorney Michael Machen called his witnesses Monday.
Dr. West testified that she’d diagnosed Herrera with post-traumatic stress disorder, major depression, generalized anxiety, and cannabis-use disorder, and she said that Herrera’s IQ score placed her in the “borderline functioning” category. All of those taken together, she told the court Monday, meant Herrera was incapable of truly forming the specific intent to kill.
“She had difficulty confronting a sister who was known to be domineering,” Dr. West said. “She could not comprehend the significant nature of Bella’s injuries to the point where should be able to seek help.”
Dr. Wright disagreed but said even if he didn’t, diagnosis doesn’t matter when it comes to the ability to form intent. She knew the nature and quality of her acts, he said, and regardless of the diagnoses, she knew right from wrong.
Herrera had the capacity to carry out other specific, deliberate acts, he said — she did chest compressions on Bella until first responders arrived, and she called 911 when Bella became unresponsive.
“She had the capacity to carry out these acts just as, in my opinion, she had the capacity to form the specific intent to kill,” Dr. Wright said.
Herrera’s younger sister, Ms. Garcia, was 17 when she moved from Charlotte to Oakmont to live with Herrera, Ramriez, and the rest of the family. She said she got the impression that Herrera felt like she couldn’t do much because it was Ramriez’s house and Ramriez’s rules, and Herrera was afraid of how Ramriez would react if she reported the abuse to authorities. Ms. Garcia said that when Ramriez wasn’t around, Herrera treated Bella “like a normal child.”
Judge Beemer said he will announce his verdict Friday morning — whether Herrera is guilty of first-degree murder, third-degree murder or involuntary manslaughter.
Mr. Machen argued for the least of the three.
“Should Alexis have done more? Sure,” he said. “But she didn’t. And she stood in front of this court and took full responsibility.”
He reiterated Dr. West’s conclusion that, when her diagnoses were taken together, it meant Herrera wasn’t able to form the intent to kill, and he pointed to Dr. Wright’s testimony that it wasn’t wholly unreasonable or irrational for Dr. West to come to the conclusions that she did.
“I don’t think [Herrera’s] actions show any malice,” Mr. Machen said. “I think her actions were reckless and negligent.”
But Ms. DiGiovanni argued that Herrera had to have intended for Bella to die — she saw what was happening to the toddler and, not only did she do nothing to stop the abuse, she continued to take part in it.
“If you don’t want her to die, stop killing her,” she said. “If you don’t want her to die, do something.”
A jury in 2023 convicted Ramriez, Bella’s stepmother, of first degree murder. She is serving a mandatory life sentence. Bella’s father, Jose Eduardo Salazar-Ortiz was convicted of third-degree murder in his daughter’s death, and Judge Beemer sentenced him to 33 to 66 years in prison.
Herrera faces a mandatory life sentence if Judge Beemer rules her actions constituted first-degree murder. Third-degree murder would carry a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years in this case because of the victim’s young age.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.