Native American activist Leonard Peltier, who was convicted in 1977 of killing two FBI agents, walked out of a federal prison in Florida on Tuesday to return to his tribal homelands in North Dakota. He will serve the remainder of his two life sentences under home confinement.
Peltier was convicted of murdering the agents after a shootout in 1975 at the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota, where they were attempting to serve an arrest warrant on a different man. Peltier has maintained his innocence for nearly half a century, and his supporters have argued that his trial was unfair. Law enforcement officials, however, have staunchly opposed clemency for him.
Last month, President Joe Biden commuted Peltier’s sentence in one of his final acts while in office. The decision allowed Peltier to finish his life sentences at home without being pardoned for the killings.
“Today I am finally free!” Peltier said, according to the NDN Collective, an Indigenous rights organization that advocated for his release. “They may have imprisoned me but they never took my spirit!”
Peltier, a member of the Turtle Mountain Band of Chippewa in North Dakota, was active in the American Indian Movement. In the 1970s, AIM became known for public and large-scale demonstrations organized to protest the federal government’s mistreatment of Native Americans.
On June 26, 1975, Peltier was at the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in Oglala, S.D., when FBI agents Jack Coler and Ronald Williams arrived to serve an arrest warrant in a theft case. A shootout between the agents and people on the reservation ensued and, afterward, Coler and Williams were shot at close range, according to the FBI.
Peltier has said he was at the scene and fired from a distance in self-defense, but he has denied being the person to shoot the agents at close range. He fled and was arrested in Canada in 1976.
During a five-week trial, prosecutors portrayed Peltier “as a violent man,” The Washington Post reported at the time. Defense attorneys attempted to undermine the FBI, accusing the agency of fabricating evidence and threatening prosecution witnesses for affirmative testimonies.
The jury found Peltier guilty.
Two other AIM members accused in the killings, Robert Eugene Robideau and Darrelle Dean Butler, had already been tried separately and acquitted on self-defense. Exculpatory evidence that was admitted during their trials was excluded from Peltier’s.
Charges against a fourth person, Jimmy Eagle, the man to whom Coler and Williams had been trying to serve the warrant, were dismissed because of a lack of evidence, according to the FBI.
In 1979, Peltier was involved in an armed escape from a California penitentiary. After authorities recaptured him, he was convicted in the escape and got seven years added to his sentence. The FBI has also said Peltier violated prison rules multiple times during his incarceration.
Peltier’s case garnered — and kept — worldwide attention.
In the decades after his trial, he appealed and requested clemency multiple times, to no avail. He also became a symbol to Native Americans and Indigenous activists of the federal government’s suppression of their rights.
During one attempt to secure a new trial, in 1984, Peltier’s attorney argued that the prosecutors at his original trial had not fully disclosed evidence as required by law. After Peltier’s conviction, his legal team had filed a request under the Freedom of Information Act and received thousands of pages of FBI documents that were not shown in court, though a prosecutor said there had been “total disclosure.”
Among those files was evidence that would have countered the government’s claims about Peltier’s role in the killings, his attorney argued.
During the 1984 hearing, about 100 people came to a North Dakota courtroom to support Peltier, many of them in traditional wear. Watching them were “two dozen finicky federal marshals, walkie-talkies in hand and guard dogs at the leash,” The Post reported.
Activists have also said that witnesses were coerced to give favorable testimonies at trial. According to the FBI, there is no eyewitness testimony about what happened at the agents’ cars after the shootout, where officials believe they were shot at close range.
In a 2021 letter to Biden, James Reynolds, the U.S. attorney whose office had handled the prosecution and appeal on Peltier’s case, said his conviction rested on the fact that “he was present with a weapon at the Reservation that day.” Reynolds urged Biden to commute Peltier’s sentence, writing that the activist was convicted on “the basis of minimal evidence, a result that I strongly doubt would be upheld in any court today.” Reynolds’s plea came alongside similar appeals from notable activists and celebrities.
In the nearly 50 years since his conviction, Peltier’s case has caused intense friction between federal officials, law enforcement, Native American activists and Indigenous rights advocates. The saga has inspired a documentary, prompted a rare public protest from federal officials and continued to raise bitter clashes between those keenly aware of the case.
During the campaign for his release, Peltier’s supporters — a group led by Indigenous people — hosted rallies nationwide and lobbied government officials.
The FBI has strongly opposed any sort of clemency for Peltier. A 1994 open letter from active and former agents described Peltier as “simply a vicious thug and murderer with no respect or regard for human life.” When President Bill Clinton was considering clemency in 2000, hundreds of agents marched to the White House to present petitions against his release — an unusually public and physical show of their stance.
As Biden weighed clemency more recently, the FBI made clear that its position had not changed.
In January, FBI Director Christopher A. Wray wrote to Biden, calling Peltier a “ruthless murderer” and adding that the activist’s supporters were “wrongly [promoting] him as a standard-bearer for legitimate grievances about the United States government’s historical treatment of Native Americans.”
But Biden granted the commutation on Jan. 20. He noted Peltier’s age, 80, and his “severe health ailments.”
Peltier walked out of a Florida federal penitentiary around 8:30 a.m. Tuesday, said Nick Tilsen, the founder of NDN Collective, who was there to receive him. He came out of the facility carrying a bag of clothes and his canupa, a ceremonial pipe, Tilsen said.
As Peltier returned to Turtle Mountain in Belcourt, N.D., where he will remain in home confinement, hundreds of people lined the streets to welcome him, Tilsen said.
“This moment is one of just pure joy and healing,” he said. “And it’s so powerful to see our elder come home.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.