Exactly three years after Christina Spicuzza failed to return home from an evening of driving for Uber, jurors on Monday convicted the man who kidnapped, robbed and ultimately killed the mother of four of first-degree murder.
The verdict means a mandatory sentence of life in prison without parole for 24-year-old Calvin Crew, whose homicide trial began last week and spanned just over four days. Jurors deliberated for around four hours on Friday and briefly on Monday morning.
Crew will be formally sentenced to life in prison May 5.
Ms. Spicuzza, 38, was reported missing early Feb. 11, 2022, after she didn’t return home from driving for Uber the night prior. Her body was found off of Rosecrest Drive in Monroeville a day later. Her car was found parked along Fourth Street in Pitcairn.
The jury of six men and six women also found Crew guilty of robbery, kidnapping, tampering with evidence and carrying a firearm without a license. Crew did not react as the jury foreman read the verdict slip.
Common Pleas Judge Edward J. Borkowski noted that Monday marked three years since Ms. Spicuzza’s death. He told jurors the verdict was correct because it was the one that they reached.
Read More
“Regardless of any perception of the verdict, it is the correct verdict,” he said.
Prosecutors initially sought the death penalty for Crew but dropped that push in early January, shortly before jury selection for the case began.
Investigators began to look at Crew after it was discovered his girlfriend ordered the last ride that Ms. Spicuzza did the night she disappeared. She told investigators she and Crew didn’t have a car, and she frequently ordered him a Lyft or Uber to get around.
Crew told investigators he had taken the Uber that night from his apartment on Brinton Road in Pitcairn to Dersam Street in Penn Hills. From there, he told them, he walked to Pershing Street to check an old address for mail. Finding none, he walked to the Wilkinsburg bus station and caught a Pittsburgh Regional Transit bus to the stop next to the Pitcairn police and walked from there back to Brinton Road.
Authorities, however, could find no evidence to corroborate Crew’s alibi. No surveillance footage showed him walking toward the Wilkinsburg station, no footage from any PRT bus that showed him on board, and no cameras in Pitcairn showed him disembarking in Pitcairn. In fact, one detective testified, the bus in question didn’t even stop near the police station that night.
Five days after Ms. Spicuzza was found dead in the Monroeville woods, an Allegheny County Police detective canvasing Dersam Street discovered the Turtle Creek woman’s dashboard camera, which hadn’t been found with her car.
The footage showed a routine Uber ride turn into a kidnapping when Ms. Spicuzza tried to drop off Crew on Dersam Street. He slid to the center of the backseat and then pressed a gun to Ms. Spicuzza’s head.
“Keep driving,” he told her.
Ms. Spicuzza begged:
“Why are you doing this?”
“I have four kids.”
“Please, please stop.”
Crew told her: “Do what I say, and everything will be OK.” Then, he reached up and pulled down the dashboard camera.
Investigators used cellphone pings to track the phone’s movements for nearly an hour after Crew should have been dropped off in Penn Hills. It moved throughout the eastern part of Allegheny County before it stopped about 10:20 p.m. on Rosecrest Drive. Authorities said the phone disconnected from the Bluetooth of Ms. Spicuzza’s car for about four minutes. Then it reconnected and left the area.
Andy Howard, Crew’s defense attorney and chief deputy of the Public Defender’s Office, told jurors that if they found his client was the man in Ms. Spicuzza’s backseat, he was, at worst, guilty of second-degree murder. He argued that the killer, whether it was Crew or not, clearly didn’t premeditate the killing: The location was far from isolated or secluded, he said, and he knew Ms. Spicuzza had a camera recording inside her car.
"[It was] horrifying, truly, skin crawlingly horrifying," Mr. Howard said of the footage from inside Ms. Spicuzza’s rented Nissan Sentra. Despite the “tragedy and scariness” of the video, he told jurors in his closing arguments, didn’t prove motive or premeditation.
Mr. Howard alleged last week that investigators and prosecutors were racially motivated in pushing for first-degree murder over second degree. In a statement several hours after the verdict, District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. decried those implications.
“This was a brutal senseless execution of a mother of four children simply trying to earn a living,” he said. “Given the overwhelming evidence supporting this prosecution and the jury’s verdict, it is extremely disappointing to have the Public Defender’s Office attempt to characterize the investigation and prosecution as racial and political.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.