The first story Alexis Herrera told was one of relative normalcy: Bella Seachrist, the 3-year-old daughter of her sister’s longtime partner, was, for the most part, a happy and healthy child, as Herrera told it.

Her speech wasn’t quite where it should be by that age — Herrera said she communicated mostly in one-syllable words and sounds — and she still hadn’t mastered potty training. But no one ever hit her, Herrera told investigators late June 9, 2020, and she had a healthy appetite.

The dark marks on her legs were from a heat rash, she told then-Allegheny County Police Detective Dan Mayer — “that’s 110% honest,” she said.

The hours-long interview at county police headquarters the day Bella died was recorded and, for the first 90 minutes or so, Herrera told Detective Mayer of a relatively idyllic life.

Advertise with us

“She bruises very easily,” Herrera told the detective as the recording of the questioning was played in court Friday. “I will take a polygraph test and I will pass it.”

Confronted with photos of Bella’s frail and broken body taken at UPMC St. Margaret after her death, the façade quickly crumbled.

“Listen,” Detective Mayer told her. “I know she got beat. I know your sister beat her. I know you saw your sister beat her. Don’t sit here and lie to me.”

Herrera, 24, is the third and final defendant to face a judge in connection with Bella’s death. She pleaded guilty in May to aggravated assault, child endangerment, unlawful restraint, conspiracy and a general count of homicide. The hearing that began Thursday in front of Common Pleas Judge Bruce R. Beemer is to determine the degree to which Herrera is guilty — that is, he must decide if she is guilty of first-degree murder, third-degree murder or involuntary manslaughter.

Bella’s stepmother, Laura Ramriez, and her father, Jose Salazar-Ortiz, were tried and convicted in 2023.

Advertise with us

In the recording of her questioning the night Bella died, Detective Mayer told her: “You have to be truthful.”

“What’s going to happen to me?” she asked him.

The truth came out slowly at first: Ramriez would hit her with a wooden spoon or a sandal, she told the detective.

Then: Ramriez sometimes hit her as punishment for sneaking into the kitchen for food or for getting off of the potty chair she was forced to stay on for hours.

Finally: Ramriez would punch her and kick her, had knocked her unconscious and pushed her down the stairs, tied her to a railing and burned her with cigarettes. Herrera, herself, had punched Bella in the face a few days prior, she said. The toddler was confined for hours each day to a closet, and she was forced to nap under a bed.

Advertise with us

“Am I going to go to jail?” Herrera asked the detective. She told him that Ramriez had asked her not to tell the police about the abuse.

Detective Mayer said he believed Herrera’s eventual truthfulness was self-serving — a way to try to distance herself from the abuse and pin a majority of it on her sister. Testimony later Friday afternoon, though, painted Herrera as an active participant in torture to which Bella was subjected.

Allegheny County Police Detective Scott Klobchar read through hundreds of text messages exchanged between Herrera and Ramriez, including two days’ worth of messages while Ramriez was in Charlotte visiting family.

Photos Herrera sent to her sister during that time showed Bella with her hands tied to a banister while she stood barefoot on a heating grate and another in which she was again tied to the banister but with one leg stuck through the spindles.

That was a common theme, Detective Klobchar testified: Whenever she was punished, Bella was often forced to stand on one leg with her hands above her head or clasped behind her back. In one photo, she was forced to stand under a shelf in a closet, her head cocked at an unnatural angle, and her legs tied above the knees to keep her from sitting down. In another, Herrera had turned a daybed against the wall, turning it into a makeshift cage. Her arms were tied to the bedframe.

Advertise with us

Later, Herrera texted Ramriez that Bella slept that way.

“You savage,” Ramriez replied.

Testimony began Thursday and included photos that one detective took of Bella after she was pronounced dead. They showed a little girl whose ribs and shoulders, knees and collarbone jutted out from her skin. Her dark hair was falling out, and she was covered in bruises, abrasions and scabs. The outer edge of her left leg was covered completely in bruises from her knee to her ankle. More bruises lined her back.

A jury in 2023 convicted Ramriez, Bella’s stepmother, of first degree murder. She is serving a mandatory life sentence. Bella’s father, Jose Eduardo Salazar-Ortiz was convicted of third-degree murder in his daughter’s death, and Judge Beemer sentenced him to 33 to 66 years in prison.

Herrera faces a mandatory life sentence if Judge Beemer rules her actions constituted first-degree murder. Third-degree murder would carry a mandatory minimum sentence of 15 years in this case because of the victim’s young age.