Prosecutors will no longer seek the death penalty against Calvin Crew, the man set to go to trial next month on charges that he kidnapped and killed Uber driver Christina Spicuzza in Monroeville in 2022, court records show.

In a docket entry dated Thursday, the Allegheny County District Attorney’s office gave notice that it was rescinding its intent to seek the death penalty against Crew.

Jury selection in the case is set to begin Monday, and testimony scheduled to begin Feb. 3.

The DA’s office offered little insight into the decision, writing in the rescission notice only that: “Intervening events have caused the Commonwealth to reconsider its decision to seek a penalty of death [in the case].”

Advertise with us

A gag order in the case has been in place since March 2022.

Spicuzza, 38, was found dead Feb. 12, 2022, in a wooded area off of Rosecrest Drive. She’d been reported missing the night prior by her fiancé when she didn’t return home after spending several hours driving for Uber.

The Uber driver picked up Crew, now 25, about 9:15 p.m. Feb. 10 for a ride he allegedly ordered using his girlfriend’s account, according to police. Footage recorded by Spicuzza’s dashboard camera showed an innocuous ride for nearly 20 minutes until the man in the backseat — who investigators say was Crew — slowly put a black handgun to Spicuzza’s head.

The footage showed that the mother of four reached up and felt the gun pressed to her head. “You’ve got to be kidding me,” she said.

Then, she pleaded for her life: “I have a family,” she said. “I’m begging you, I have four kids.”

Advertise with us

The video ends about 20 minutes after the ride started when the man reached forward and ripped the camera from its spot on the dashboard. It was found several days later, discarded along a street in Penn Hills.

Crew was charged Feb. 17, 2022, with homicide, kidnapping and robbery. District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. announced two months later that his office’s intent to seek the death penalty.

Investigators in the case, which sparked calls for Uber to change its policies, have said they believe Spicuzza was dead within an hour of her camera being pulled from her dashboard.

Police said someone tried to access various money transfer apps on Spicuzza’s cell phone, which recorded its location every few seconds, before it stopped for some time on Rosecrest Drive near where she was found dead.

Police said in the initial criminal complaint that from there the phone traveled toward Pitcairn and, eventually, on toward the Westinghouse Bridge via Route 30. The phone stopped moving not far from the bridge about 10:40 p.m. It was ultimately found below the Triboro Expressway the next day.

Advertise with us

Though the DA’s filing offered little in the way of reasoning, it was filed with the court the same day that Crew’s defense attorney gave notice that he intended to present evidence that Crew is intellectually disabled and therefore not eligible for the death penalty.

The filing by Assistant Public Defender Adam Reynolds cited case law that has ruled at the state and federal level that executing an individual with intellectual disabilities violates the Eighth Amendment, which protects against cruel and unusual punishment.

The filing included the redacted results of a commonly used intelligence test that was administered to Crew. Though the scores were redacted, the filing summarizes that: “Mr. Crew has substantial deficits in adaptive functioning,” as well as difficulties “processing and achieving commonly accepted social conventions for a young man his age to include the ability to maintain employment, control finances, live independently, and demonstrate effective problem-solving and coping strategies.”